Your teams all time team

[nerdybeard]

Sharks

Marleau - Thornton - Heatley
Friesen - Couture - Nolan
Michalek - Hertl - Pavelski
Larionov - Damphousse - Meier
Clowe

Blake - Karlsson
Vlasic - Boyle
Wilson - Burns

Nabokov
Irbe

*honorable mention/meme forward line
Ricci - Roenick - Selanne

 

[Puckstuff]

Matthews-Sundin-Marner
Sittler-Lindros-Clark
Nylander-Gilmour-Kessel
Mahovlich-Keon-Armstrong

Horton-Salming
Kaberle-Turnbull
Rielly-McCabe

Bower
Potvin

 

[Hennessy]

Deadmarsh, Liles and Foote were for sure the ones I figured that would be questioned, maybe some others as well. I just enjoyed those 3 players on and off the ice when they played (Or in Liles case, still doing tv things for the team)

There's no question on Foote. For a time he was likely the best defensive dman in the game.

Deadmarsh was tracking to become a player belonging to these lists, but injuries cut that short. Like you, though, I've got a soft-spot for him.

I used to have Liles on these types of rosters in my head (they help me fall asleep sometimes), but as time has gone by he's slipped. Just no room for him with Makar, Foote, Blake, Bourque, Toews, and Ozolinsh. And then I've got Erik Johnson. Liles is in there after with Barrie. That line-up is vastly improved in recent years with Makar and Toews. The Avs haven't had a lot of outstanding D. I'd be tempted at times to include Nordiques, but for what? One great season of Duchesne? Mario Marois?

 

[PenguinSuitedUp]

A couple of these picks are kind of cheap, but since there are no rules, this one’s just for fun:

Francis Lemieux Jagr
Robitaille Crosby Iginla
Stevens Malkin Kessel
Tocchet Trottier Recchi

Coffey Murphy
Letang Gonchar
Karlsson Zubov

Fleury
Barrasso
Murray (huge part of 2 Cup wins)

 

[Based Anime Fan]

Sharks

Marleau - Thornton - Heatley
Friesen - Couture - Nolan
Michalek - Hertl - Pavelski
Larionov - Damphousse - Meier
Clowe

Blake - Karlsson
Vlasic - Boyle
Wilson - Burns

Nabokov
Irbe

*honorable mention/meme forward line
Ricci - Roenick - Selanne

You forgot about Claude Lemieux. Maybe not a regular season powerhouse, but come playoff time...

 

[Spawn]

Oilers all time “cup of coffee” team (max 100 games played)

Nilsson-Nichols-Cole
Sykora-Damphousse-Samsonov
Courtnall-Carson-Lupul
Glencross-Peca-Hecht

Pronger-Spacek
Ruotsailanen-Pitkanen
Keith-Mike Green

(60 games max for goalies)
Bryzgalov
Gerber

 

[Auston Marlander]

Matthews-Sundin-Marner
Sittler-Lindros-Clark
Nylander-Gilmour-Kessel
Mahovlich-Keon-Armstrong

Horton-Salming
Kaberle-Turnbull
Rielly-McCabe

Bower
Potvin

No Thornton, JT or Brian Leeych?

Cujo, Eddie, Rask, Murray, Fuhr?

There are tons of great players that came through well past their prime that could be on this list.

 

[Zenos]

No Thornton, JT or Brian Leeych?

Cujo, Eddie, Rask, Murray, Fuhr?

There are tons of great players that came through well past their prime that could be on this list.

I think it makes more sense to take into consideration how the players actually were for the team. And to a lesser extent, tenure.

Leetch on the Buds, Adam Oates on the Oilers, or Mats Sundin on the Canucks is just kinda dumb IMO. It's much more fun to pick meaninful players who were fan favourites, played integral roles, and were a part of the culture and history of the club. That's why a guy like RNH probably deserves to be on the all-time Oilers squad for instance, even if there are "better" centres / LWers available.

 

[wintersej]

Probably not the best Bruins, but tried to pick guys that were with us most of their careers and that sort of make a complete team instead of just the best scorers. Some nasty in this lineup too.


Bucyk-Esposito-Neely
Marchand-Bergeron-Pasta
Marcotte-Krejci-Middleton
Axelsson-O’Reilly-Cashman

Orr-Bourque
Chara-Shore
Smith-Milbury

Rask
Cheevers

Schmidt, Park, Clapper notable omissions. Adam Oates.

 

[Double-Shift Lasse]

Kunitz-Crosby-Hornqvist
Jagr-Lemieux-Francis
Guentzel-Malkin-Hossa
Hagelin-Bonino-Kessel

Dumoulin-Letang
Martin-Daley
Määttä-Schultz

Murray
Fleury

A couple of these picks are kind of cheap, but since there are no rules, this one’s just for fun:

Francis Lemieux Jagr
Robitaille Crosby Iginla
Stevens Malkin Kessel
Tocchet Trottier Recchi

Coffey Murphy
Letang Gonchar
Karlsson Zubov

Fleury
Barrasso
Murray (huge part of 2 Cup wins)

Pronovost
Larouche
Carlyle
Burrows
Apps
Stackhouse
Kovalev

 

[Regal]

Made a simple adjustment


Yes... Islanders were absolutely great and undefeatable. Talent, grit, netter and coaching.
Habs, Oilers and Islanders were in my opinion, the best of thy NHL dynasties.

The dynasty was awesome. I thought you meant 3rd out of these all time teams. They’ve been pretty mediocre outside of the dynasty that I don’t think their all time team is very strong

 

[Rebels57]

23 Man Roster


Line 1: Reggie Leach - Bobby Clarke - Bill Barber (The LCB Line)

Line 2: John LeClair - Eric Lindros - Claude Giroux

Line 3: Simon Gagne - Rick MacLeish - Mark Recchi

Line 4: Tim Kerr - Rod Brind'Amour - Brian Propp

• Extras: Jake Voracek, Rick Tocchet

Defense 1: Eric Desjardins - Mark Howe

Defense 2: Kimmo Timonen - Chris Pronger

Defense 3: Brad McCrimmon - Tom Bladon

• Extras: Joe Watson

Goalie 1: Bernie Parent

Goalie 2: Pelle Lindbergh

 

[BlueSeal]

2018-19 Blues team is all that matters to me now.

 

[SPV]

I feel like tenure should be considered, like Gretzky is Edmonton, Lindros is Philly, Oates is Washington, Jagr is Pittsburgh, etc.

Jagr, Paul Coffey and Kevin Stevens played in Boston, but they were way past their prime and I’d never think of either one as a Bruin

 

[CanadienShark]

Out of curiosity with regards to your comment about guys like Heatley... Why do you then have both Stutzle and Karlsson?

 

[PenguinSuitedUp]

Pronovost
Larouche
Carlyle
Burrows
Apps
Stackhouse
Kovalev

Those are all options! I haven’t seen most of them play, and picked Kessel over Kovalev because of the Cup runs.

 

[CanadienShark]

That is a heck of a D core...

He also left off Subban and Markov. And Roy in net. Crazy depth.

 

[Bouboumaster]

He also left off Subban and Markov. And Roy in net. Crazy depth.

And also Plante!

Montréal:
Roy
Dryden

Laval:
Plante
Price

 

[kingsholygrail]

Robitaille-Gretzky-Kurri
Kempe-Kopitar-Palffy
Simmer-Dionne-Gaborik
Cammalleri-M. Richards-Carter

Doughty-Mitchell
Blake-Muzzin
Murphy-Visnovsky
Murdoch

Quick
Vachon

 

[mr figgles]

Philadelphia

Leach Clarke Barber
LeClair Lindros Recchi
Giroux MacLeish Tocchet
Propp Brind’Amour Kerr

Pronger Desjardins
Howe McCrimmon
Timonen Bladon

Parent
Hextall

 

[Tommy Shelby]

Avs

Landeskog-Sakic-Hejduk
Tanguay-Forsberg-Rantanen
Kamensky-MacKinnon-Lemieux
Lehkonen-Drury-Young

Towes-Makar
Bourque-Blake
Ozolinsh-Foote

Roy
Varlamov

 

[Warh1ppy]

I feel like tenure should be considered, like Gretzky is Edmonton, Lindros is Philly, Oates is Washington, Jagr is Pittsburgh, etc.

Jagr, Paul Coffey and Kevin Stevens played in Boston, but they were way past their prime and I’d never think of either one as a Bruin

What do you mean man?

Seeing Arizona field Pronger and Weber side by side on the blue line

With a forward core of any of the following (in random order)

B. Hull-P. Datsyuk-M. Hossa
T. Hall-S. Doan-K. Tkachuk
J. Roenick-O. Jokinen-P. Nedved
P. Kessel-K. Turris-C. Keller

HM
R. Whitney-A. Tanguay-G. Laraque

A defensive core of

C. Pronger-S. Weber
K. Yandle-E. Jovanovski
M. Schneider-J. Lumme

HM to OE. Larson-J. Demers

With you choice of goalies
N. Khabibulin
C. Joseph
M. Smith
I. Bryzgalov

I'd say that the Coyotes had a chance at a quality playoff team there.

 

[Idiot Stick]

Panthers (lines are not that optimized)

Mellanby-Barkov-Bure
Jagr-Thornton-Tkachuk
Verhaeghe-O.Jokinen-Reinhart
Huberdeau-Weiss-Horton
Hornqvist

Forsling-Svehla
Bouwmeester-Ekblad
Campbell-Kulikov

Luongo
Bobrovsky
HM:Beezer

 

[Jorma Heart]

Team KalPa

Sami Kapanen - Olli Jokinen - Artturi Lehkonen
Teemu Hartikainen - Eetu Luostarinen - Kasperi Kapanen
Alexandre Texier - Oliver Kapanen - Craig Smith
Jyri Junnila - Adam Hall - Iiro Pakarinen

Kimmo Timonen - Jussi Timonen
Mathew Maione - Niko Mikkola
Mika Strömberg - Adam Masuhr
Lasse Lappalainen

Eero Kilpeläinen
Kimmo Kapanen

Extras: Marko Tuomainen, Mikko Jokela, Juha Jatkola

 

[Lawzy]

Canucks:

Forward:
Sedin - Sedin - Sundin
Mogilny - Pettersson - Bure
Kesler - Messier - Burrows
Linden - Miller - Naslund

HM: Bertuzzi, Tanti

Defense:
Hughes - Salo
Hamhuis - Ohlund
Lumme - Tanev

HM: Edler, Jovanovski

Goal:
Luongo
Demko

HM: McLean

No rules, so they're all in their prime.

I know he said no rules but I think the Canucks need at least one rule...