No.
He's a good player. He's even a good player who fits what our team wants and needs. But he's had his chance and he's blown it, three times now. The regular season doesn't matter, playoffs are what matter and he's proven time, and time, and time again that he cannot keep his cool in the playoffs. I loved him as a Maple Leaf, but he was effectively fired for inexcusable behavior in the playoffs two years in a row. He's about to be fired again by Colorado. The fact that a player with his talent, on a cheap contract, playing C keeps getting traded away from teams trying to be contenders tells you that he's not a guy that you can count on.
If he wants to have a redemption tour somewhere else and come back to the Leafs late in his career, I'm down with that. And you know what, if we get him super cheap there's a point where it's worth it. But he has done everything he can possibly do to prove that he's just not worth the investment. We need guys who want to win in the playoffs, but we can't afford guys who lose their composure. It's every bit as bad as folding.