I love this pick.
I would have rated him 2nd or 3rd overall.
He scored 7 points in the KHL this regular season. That compares to 10 for Tarkasenko, 9 for Panarin and 8 for Kuznetsov in their pre-draft years. Kucherov and Buchnevich had 2. Those aren't best case scenarios, those are the most similar players to him based on pre-draft, regular season output. And that's without even accounting for the most impressive part of his resume, which was when he almost put up a point per game in the playoffs. When he played in the VHL and the MHL, the results were borderline laughable.
It's clearly not a case of him putting up points because of the situation he's in. He oozes skill. He dangles and carves through veterans in the 2nd best league in the world. He's 6'4" and he blows by pro-level defensemen with speed. He wins puck battles, controls the puck, makes high level passes, and can beat goalies cleanly with his shot or dekes.
As far as I can tell, the most comparable players to him at this age from the KHL are Tarasenko, Panarin, and Kuznetsov, and they are all perennial all-star, franchise cornerstone players. For me, a guy with that profile is more attractive than anyone else in this draft outside of Dahlin (obviously), and maybe Svechnikov. I think taking him 9th is a home run.