Darnell Nurse? Has no business on this roster. Pelech, Hamilton, Ekblad, Montour, Chabot, Byram, Dobson, Spurgeon and even Morgan Reilly > Nurse.
Who Would Make Canada's Roster If There Was Olympics This Year?
- Thread starter NVious
- Start date
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 19,479
- 10,818
ManofSteel55
Registered User
There’s no argument to be made lol. Pelech is a top 10 shutdown guy in the league and is a lock on most of these mock teams. Despite Ekblad’s fall-off since his injury, he’s still better both offensively and defensively than Nurse. Chabot and Byram show more upside than Nurse ever has on both ends of the ice and Dougie Hamilton is simply a better offensive option. Spurgeon is also a reliable stay-at home option for Canada. I’m not saying Darnell Nurse isn’t good offensively, you simply don’t need him when you have guys like Makar, Theodore and Morrisey on the roster already.
ManofSteel55
Registered User
Pelech and Spurgeon. I can understand those guys making a team like this over Nurse, but the rest are either one way only players, or just aren't as rounded. Nurse is way better than most here think. He makes the odd mistake, but he's always on the ice against the top opponents and comes out ahead, regardless of what forward line is out there with him (so no, it isn't only due to McDavid and Draisaitl). If you prefer a stay at home only guy, sure, take Pelech or Sturgeon. Nurse plays in all situations aside from the powerplay though, he's more versatile, and doesn't need to be sheltered to be good like some of the defensemen you listed as better options.
Mathieukferland
Registered User
Needs to prove he can play at a consistent level with which he finished last year with; right side is very deep though with Makar, Pietrangelo, and Hamilton all being top 15 defenders in the league; and players like Dobson, Ekblad, or Doughty who could stake a claim for a spot
Also , Owen power , he is really good and young and big
I think both Bouchard and power will be here one day
As of now, Bouchard wouldn’t even crack Canada’s B-Team. Possibly in the future though.
A-Team:
Toews-Makar
Theodore-Pietrangelo
Pelech-Morrisey
B-Team:
Chabot-Hamilton
Spurgeon-Ekblad
Montour-Doughty
Reilly, Byram, Dobson, Power, Dunn, Weegar and Chychurn would probably round out C-Team. Bouchard would be a C-Team shortlist or D-Team LOCK with guys like Sam Girard, Colton Parayko, Ryan Pulock, Darnell Nurse and Kris Letang. Who knows by 2026 though, Bouchard might make it.
Last edited:
Mathieukferland
Registered User
I take him on the B team easily and maybe even over Pelech on the a team, he’s so good defensively and can be an effective play driver first pass man on offense
Pelech clears Bouchard defensively. He’s a top 10 shutdown guy in the league anlong with guys like Brodin, McAvoy, Slavin, Heskinanen, Tanev, Lindholm and should be a LOCK. Byram was on pace for more points this year, has more upside, is faster than Bouchard and better defensively. You can argue him for B-Team sure, but in no way does Hockey Canada take him in a best-on-best this year.
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 19,479
- 10,818
You don't hear this very often but LAF was GREAT, tonight, and QB scores last night. Maybe the 2020 Draft is making an impact?
- Oct 9, 2012
- 31,776
- 30,502
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 19,479
- 10,818
If Laf, Nolan Patrick and Byfield had panned out the way they were supposed to, I don’t think we’d be hearing all this moaning and groaning.
A lot of Canada’s elite talent was drafted in 2011-2015: Mcdavid, MacKinnon, Marner, Barzal, Point, Huberdeau, Schiefele, Stone, Theodore, Hamilton, Morrisey, Ekblad, Toews, Chabot.
In contrast, the USA had stronger classes in 2016-2020 and so Canada is still relying on guys like Stamkos, Marchand and Pietrangelo to fill in the shoes. That’s not to say Canada didn’t produce good talent in those years: Makar, Thomas, Suzuki, Mercer, Byram, Cozens and Kyrou. It’s just that they lack in comparison to USA’s 2016-2020: Matthews, the Tkachuks, the Hughes, Jrob, Tage Thompson, Otter, McAvoy, Zegras, Caufield, Fox, Sanderson and Boldy smoke those guys.
HFpapi
Registered User
It’s a toss-up for Canadian goaltending right now. Who ever is hot. Right now, probably Hill. You could argue Thompson, Hart or Kuemper though.
There’s very locks up front as well. Outside of McDavid, Mack, Crosby, Point and Marner. Stamkos and Marchand likely make it, but then it’s a lot of question marks.
Bedard?
PLD?
Barzal?
Huberdeau?
Schiefele?
Thomas?
RNH?
Kyrou?
Tavares?
Cozens?
Crosby2010
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2023
- 1,281
- 1,118
We are in a tight spot with goaltending. This is not a good sign for Canada right now. Even up until 2016 we had pretty solid goaltending and depth. In 2016 we had Price, then Holtby who had just won the Vezina, and then Crawford who had just won a couple of Cups. None of them are in the NHL anymore.
There was a time when Canada had at least half of the best goalies in the NHL. It is pretty scary right now. I like what Hill did with Vegas in the playoffs but we have some slim pickings. FLeury is old and Price is gone. There really isn't anyone left that is elite. I know someone always comes out of the woodwork but I don't know who it is now. I guess you can say that Kuemper and then Hill were the last two Cup winning goalies, if that helps. Could be worse I guess, but man we don't have a star goalie. Is that D'Aigle kid from the QMJHL still a hot prospect for the 2025 draft?
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 19,479
- 10,818
Bedard is exceeding HIGH expectations. LAF with a 3 point night. Byfield is (almost) a PPG. Plus, there are a ton of new kids coming. All of a sudden, Canada's future looks much brighter.
Even Nick Suzuki is looking really good (I am not a fan).
Even Nick Suzuki is looking really good (I am not a fan).
Last edited:
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 19,479
- 10,818
It was getting worrisome. The 2016 - 2018 Drafts were garbage for Canada and when the average NHL career is 4.5 years, it takes its toll. The 2019-2020 Drafts have a LOT of Canadian talent but, unfortunately, they're taking their time stepping up. For those reasons, when choosing players for Team Canada's future Best On Best, the team ends up looking OLD.
Also worrisome : The U.S. produced HIGH end talent from 2016 - 2019. Many of whom succeeded right out of the box.
On the plus side : Canada has an avalanche of YOUNG talent coming. We just have to hope the older players can hold the fort until the new players are ready.
Last edited:
Honestly,
If Laf can even become half of the player that he was supposed to be, I’d have him on Team Canada.
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 19,479
- 10,818
When I watched him play this year, he's been terrific. Let's hope all the young prospects reach their potential soon - before the old guard gets too old.
Last edited:
Mathieukferland
Registered User
I think our d-core is fine. Could you ask for a Slavin-like player? Sure, but you can get some of that with Toews and Pelech. On the right side you have Dobson as you mentioned, but you also have Hamilton, Ekblad, Montour. Not sure how Drysdale will plan out, but he’s also an option. Left side is stacked with Toews, Morrisey, Theodore, Chabot, Pelech, Power. Canada’s main problem is goaltending and their forward depth.
