What Would You Do With This Team Over the Offseason?

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
1) Fire Keefe
2) Ask Marner to waive his NMC, strip him of the A
3) Let Brodie + Gio walk
4) Re-sign Domi
5) Extend McCabe
6) Re-sign Bertuzzi
7) Re-sign Edmundson
8) Unsure about Lily, give him another 3 years if cheap
9) Find a 1B goalie to rotate with Woll
10) Ask Tavares to give the C to Matthews. Stripping him of it publicly is messy, make it a succession.
Bertuzzi looked like he was going to cry when Pasta scored. I'd definitely bring him back. His blood turned blue.

I'm not sold on Domi. The non-shots turned costly when he carried that bullshit into the playoffs. Game 3 was his to win by himself if he wasn't so weird with having to shoot. He became status quo of what were already used to seeing when losing. If we can only keep 1 I'm going with Bert and his in your face playoff style.
 
Last edited:
Fire Shanny. Give the team to BT and see what he can do. No President. Just a GM and that's it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: socko
Fire Shanny. Give the team to BT and see what he can do. No President. Just a GM and that's it.
Absolutely. This will make the GM job so much more attractive when you don't have to answer to Shanny. If Tre doesn't work out, the job will be way more appealing without this guy's interference. And Tre deserves a chance here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thewave
The most key strategic decision management has to recognize is contending next year is a pipe dream. We're likely to get worse in the short term in any Marner trade and we need to get more picks. Also Tavares contract is off. Our drafting department is good. Matthews, Willy, Knies, and Woll. Everyone else is expendable.

There is lots of regression that was masked by random trade deadline defenceman becoming very good.

If we're patient, draft well, hit on FA, we'll be big contenders.

Anything else is trying to get past the first round without a prayer of beating a team like Florida.

That doesn't mean Matthews and Nylander can't drag us to a playoff series win. Playoffs are of course expected.

We need to spend money on a good QB #1 D.

Our PP is screwed over by 3 players specifically. Tavares, Marner and Rielly. It's horrific come playoff time.

Knies was very good. Why not put him on PP1? Because Keefe is an idiot. Why not try Domi over Marner? We're 5%. No one is safe lmao.
 
1. Fire Keefe. I like the guy, but if you don't fire him then you are delusional about accountability in the org's culture
2. Try to trader Marner
3. 2 will fail, teams don't want him so just accept this franchise is a joke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeywiz542
Keep

Forwards
1) Matthews
2) Domi
3) Bertuzzi
4) Nylander
5) #2 Center
6) Knies
7) #3 Center
8) McMann
9) Jarnkrok
10) Dewar
11) #4 Center
12) Reaves

Defenceman
1) Rielly
2) #2 RD
3) McCabe
4) Benoit
5) Edmundson
6) Lyubushkin
7) #7 LD
8) #8 RD

Goaltenders
1) #1 G
2) Woll
3) #3 G

Remove

Marner
Tavares
Holmberg
Robertson
Gregor
Brodie
Liljegren
Timmins
Giordano
Samsonov
Jones
Kampf
 
My Plan:

1. Remove Shanahan immediately and do not fill the position. It's a fluffy waste of a position to begin with. Let BT report up and nuke an unnecessary buffer.

2. Fire Keefe immediately and hire Berube at all costs. Knowing Chief, he jumps at the opportunity to coach the Leafs.

3. Ask Tavares for an approved list and sell him for pennies on the dollar without retaining. Idgaf if we get a 4th rounder for him outright. If he refuses, at the very least, the C is removed from him and given to Matthews.

4. Shop Marner and try to find a feasible hockey trade. Then let him know he's no longer part of the future in any way, shape, or form, and I'd image the kid has enough pride to accept a trade and move on. If not, let him rot on the 3rd line and try to produce his way into a big payday as a FA. The days of the inmates running the asylum should be over.

5. Give Matthews the C and make it clear this is now his team, sink or swim. I have been as critical as anyone of Matthews, and personally, I don't think he has enough dog in him to carry a team on his back when it matters most. There's always an "excuse" once the playoffs start with this guy... "hot goalie", "lack of depth", "injuries", "sickness", etc. Newsflash: Every other NHL player deals with the same stuff when the playoffs ramp up. This has been EIGHT YEARS and since he's been on the team we have ONE playoff round win. There's a pattern here. Not acknowledging that is pure denial. That said... we are all in with 34. It's time to turn everything over to him to write his own legacy. If he succeeds, he'll go down as an all-time great Leaf (perhaps the greatest) and if he fails, he'll end up a huge disappointment. But this now must be up to him. No more excuses, no more roadblocks.

6. Given the above ^ 5... BT's mission must be to surround Matthews with the "right" pieces... not just the "flashy" ones. I would bring in dogs and alphas because Matthews just doesn't own that DNA. Target guys like Guentzel, Konecny, etc. Guys who combine skill with dog and love to battle.

7. Address the defense. If we can't get Rielly a "Batman" we need to get him a "Robin" at the very least. If Brandon Montour hits the open market, we should be all over him. He could run PP1 and help the PP immediately, which would lessen the burden on Rielly. If we can't go the FA route, try to land one in a hockey trade.

8. Re-up Domi and Bertuzzi and give them more of a role on the team. With the right coach -- and the right softy stars removed -- the culture of this team could morph into a more gritty and competitive team with Matthews and Nylander at the helm offensively.

9. Drop napalm on the "country club culture" that has been enabled under Shanahan. No more overpriced deals. No more wasting money. No more time dedicated to debating the dress code. No more gifting players positions or contracts without proving their worth. No more babying the players and coddling their feelings. Our new era should be labelled: "The Era of Accountability", full stop.
:clap::clap::clap:
 
IMG_2537.png
 
1) Fire Keefe
2) Ask Marner to waive his NMC, strip him of the A
3) Let Brodie + Gio walk
4) Re-sign Domi
5) Extend McCabe
6) Re-sign Bertuzzi
7) Re-sign Edmundson
8) Unsure about Lily, give him another 3 years if cheap
9) Find a 1B goalie to rotate with Woll
10) Ask Tavares to give the C to Matthews. Stripping him of it publicly is messy, make it a succession.
what if Matthews doesn't want it? What if Matthews only wanted to stay a few more seasons to break the Leaf's scoring title along with a few more kicks at the can with his buddy Mitch and then peace out at the end of this contract?
 
  • Like
Reactions: arso40
1) Fire Keefe
2) Ask Marner to waive his NMC, strip him of the A
3) Let Brodie + Gio walk
4) Re-sign Domi
5) Extend McCabe
6) Re-sign Bertuzzi
7) Re-sign Edmundson
8) Unsure about Lily, give him another 3 years if cheap
9) Find a 1B goalie to rotate with Woll
10) Ask Tavares to give the C to Matthews. Stripping him of it publicly is messy, make it a succession.

No to Lilly. Dude isn't good. Time to move on
Domi vs Berts. I rather sign Berts.
Brodie and Gio are both done, so is TImmins. Not coming back. Possibly Boosh
 
You'd show 34 the door? That's interesting, what leads you to that suggestion?
MARNER didn't get it done is the common refrain, it's all 16s fault. Just a pouty little loser!

So what! 34 got it done, is that it? 34 and those big shoulders carried the team to a better result. He didnt outscore anyone he didn't dominate anyone and didn't lead the team to glory.

I mean it's great he's won a couple of Rockets, but that doesn't get the team #14, but it got him 14
 
  • Like
Reactions: egd27
MARNER didn't get it done is the common refrain, it's all 16s fault. Just a pouty little loser!

So what! 34 got it done, is that it? 34 and those big shoulders carried the team to a better result. He didnt outscore anyone he didn't dominate anyone and didn't lead the team to glory.

I mean it's great he's won a couple of Rockets, but that doesn't get the team #14, but it got him 14
They are all to blame, not just Marner. As a collection, they can’t get it done. It’s not a reaction based on 1,2,3,4 years, it’s now 7 of 8. That is way more time than most other organizations would give. They’ve had every opportunity and unlimited resources to succeed. Can’t get it done.

As such it needs to change. It won’t be Matthews, Nylander is locked in, that leaves Marner and his pending UFA. Change is overdue. Sometimes a group hits the wall, this one can’t get over it. It’s not just being said here, many reputable people from Ferraro on down say the same. Change is inevitable if you are serious about taking another step. Unfortunate, we should have had a few conference finals by now. But no.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arso40
Some pretty decent D available in FA this year. If we can clear $11M, plus Brody and Bertuzzi coming off of the books, plus the cap rising another $4M. Can we take a real swing at 2 of them? Shorter term and higher cap? Montour and Pesce each at 4 x 7.5 type thing?

Marner and Kampf for Sarros and 2 2nds

Konecny and Laughton for Easton,
Liljegren, 1st and NSH 2nd

Knies Matthews Nylander
Domi Tavares Konecny
McMann Laughton Jarnkrok
Robertson Minten Reaves

Rielly Pesce
McCabe Montour
Edmundson Niemala

Saros
Woll

Wouldn't mind Bertuzzi coming back either to be honest. Not at $5M though - so probably not happening
 
Last edited:
I'd find 2 goaltenders that can be trusted.

Samsonov is a disgrace to the team.

And Woll while talented is WAY to injury prone, he missed 3 months this year because he got hurt on a muffin of a shot.

Then hurt himself again making a save on a shot he didn't need to stop because the game was already over, and it went in anyway.

you can't have that, you can't have your goaltender getting hurt on saves they don't need to make because the game was decided.

That is especially true when the next game is a game 7.

Woll took himself out of game 7.

Address the goaltending the right way.

I'd also try to move Kampf and sign Monahan.

Monahan has had injury issues too but he's not a goaltender
 
Until your best players are the best players on the ice, it ain't going to happen. I've yet to see our best be THE best. I don't know why anyone would think things will change.
 
The goalie situation is iffy.

I don't like the idea of running a tandem with Broissoit or Stolarz. It's still just as risky as what they had between Sammy and Woll.

They will have to ask and see whether or not they can grab Gibson, Saros, Ullmark, or perhaps Markstrom.
 
Until your best players are the best players on the ice, it ain't going to happen. I've yet to see our best be THE best. I don't know why anyone would think things will change.

You never watched both our series against Tampa I take it
 
I'd find 2 goaltenders that can be trusted.

Samsonov is a disgrace to the team.

And Woll while talented is WAY to injury prone, he missed 3 months this year because he got hurt on a muffin of a shot.

Then hurt himself again making a save on a shot he didn't need to stop because the game was already over, and it went in anyway.

you can't have that, you can't have your goaltender getting hurt on saves they don't need to make because the game was decided.

That is especially true when the next game is a game 7.

Woll took himself out of game 7.

Address the goaltending the right way.

I'd also try to move Kampf and sign Monahan.

Monahan has had injury issues too but he's not a goaltender
Bro I know you're all in on the goaltender thing, and I don't actually disagree with you per se, but our biggest problem in the playoffs is our lack of offense. We can't afford a really good goaltender because of the expensive black holes upfront.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad