Value of: What would Carey Price realistically cost?

[Captain Controversy]

On a serious note, Would rather shore up the Defense than pay that much to have carry Price. He is no longer the best goalie in the world. Holtby is.

 

[Frank Drebin]

Jesse Puljujarvi + 2018 first round pick + Laurent Brosoit + Rights to Bogdan Yakimov

Ok I'll bite. Why wouldn't Talbot be coming back?

 

[Captain Controversy]

Ok I'll bite. Why wouldn't Talbot be coming back?

Brosoit has a better upside.

 

[Frank Drebin]

Brosoit has a better upside.

how considerate of you

 

[2020 Cup Champions]

HF: Habs only good cuz of Price, Without Price, the Habs = Leafs

Someone says Price is Game changer,

HF: sarcasmception

More like Montreal would never turn down Tavares+Hamonic for him.

Come back to reality, bud.

 

[HydroF]

Most playoff calibur teams wouldn't benefit as much from the goaltending upgrade as they would upgrading other positions, and most non playoff teams aren't going to trade their futures to build around a goalie. Montreal relies so much on price that what they would require to make up for him I doubt any team would even consider paying.

 

[HydroF]

Just gonna throw some teams.

If the Devils were to trade for Price:
Schneider + Palmieri/Henrique

Rangers
McDonagh + Zibanejad + Miller

Islanders
Tavares + Hamonic + Dal Colle

Penguins
Crosby + Murray

Sharks
Vlasic + Couture + Jones

Nashville
Josi + Rinne + Neal

Edmonton
McDavid

Florida
Ekblad + Barkov



theres some examples!

Maybe Nashville and NYI start discussions there, the rest easily turn it down. Pittsburgh and San Jose hang up laughing.

 

[jacks*]

That being said, the only goalie who probably looked like he could backstop a team to a cup no matter what the hell they were doing in front of him was the Dominator

Well that's been proven completely false.The Dominator couldn't win the cup till he was trade to a stacked team.
Your describing Roy. 1993.

 

[jacks*]

Completely disagree.

A generational talent goalie cant win a cup without a solid all around team in front of him. Hasek found that out the hard way for years in Buffalo.

A team can and has won a cup with a just OK goalie in net.

One thing every NHL cup winner has had is Norris caliber dman and/or a bona fide 1C. THOSE are the positions you cant do without

Roy 1993.

 

[Halla]

"What would Carey Price realistically cost?"

haha. Leafs wouldnt trade matthews for price and every habs pick in 2017

 

[jacks*]

Probably a young replacement goalie, young top 6 forward, 1st.

Not saying Tampa would want him but value wise think vasilevski, drouin, 1st

Which is a ridiculous price to pay but the guy is unreal so it's hard to tell.

This one seems the most accurate not the joke proposal like Tanev + Both Sedins + 1st or the joke proposal one post above.

 

[Frank Drebin]

haha. Leafs wouldnt trade matthews for price and every habs pick in 2017

Price will be retired by the time the Leafs are competitive.

 

[KingJoffrey]

He's UFA soon enough. Why any team should waste assets, when they can just offer him 7x11-12 mil contract and be done with it.

 

[TT1]

He's UFA enough soon. Why any team should waste assets, when they can just offer him 7x11-12 mil contract and be done with it.

This, he's a UFA in 2 seasons. He won't be getting a premier return like Crosby/McDavid obviously, that would be ridiculous.

Ugh i wonder how much it's gonna cost us to resign him.. hopefully between 9-10M.

Price will be retired by the time the Leafs are competitive.

that guy wouldn't trade JVR for Gallagher, Gallagher is apparently a "3rd liner"..

 

[Wanderson]

deez nuts

 

[zar]

McDavid.


If we're talking realistically, he'll never be traded.

Just gonna throw some teams.

If the Devils were to trade for Price:
Schneider + Palmieri/Henrique

Rangers
McDonagh + Zibanejad + Miller

Islanders
Tavares + Hamonic + Dal Colle

Penguins
Crosby + Murray

Sharks
Vlasic + Couture + Jones

Nashville
Josi + Rinne + Neal

Edmonton
McDavid

Florida
Ekblad + Barkov



theres some examples!

OK, I realize some of the Oiler poster offers were weak but in what world would you trade a player like McDavid for 2 years of Carey Price? ... and I think Price is the best goalie in the game. If Price were signed for 6 more years then were talking a much different scenario.

I feel the most the Oilers would pay for 2 years of Price, with the possibility of signing him thereafter...


Carey Price


Cam Talbot
Leon Draisaitl
Jesse Puljujarvi or 2017 1st
Maybe another pick 2nd round or later in a future draft.

 

[bobholly39]

Just gonna throw some teams.

If the Devils were to trade for Price:
Schneider + Palmieri/Henrique

Rangers
McDonagh + Zibanejad + Miller

Islanders
Tavares + Hamonic + Dal Colle

Penguins
Crosby + Murray

Sharks
Vlasic + Couture + Jones

Nashville
Josi + Rinne + Neal

Edmonton
McDavid

Florida
Ekblad + Barkov



theres some examples!

NJ trade - neither of the extra 2 players excite me. I'd rather keep Price than get Schneider.

Rangers - neither of the 3 players excite me, so no.

Islanders - Tavares has one of the highest values in the NHL. Arguably higher than Price. The value is certainly there - though i would want a goalie coming back. Maybe Halak?

Penguins - Crosby is worth more than Price. "value-wise" a simple 1vs1 trade should the Penguins one day decide to move malkin or crosby for some reason could be plausible, but Crosby is worth more. Canadiens are also built around Price, and likely better with him than Crosby bc of it.

Sharks - That's high value than San Jose. I'd hate to lose Price, but if that trade happened as a Habs fan i would at least think "hrmm, who? Hrmm that's a lot". San Jose really has a lot of strong roster spots

Nashville - don't really want Rinne. His value is based on how good he was, not how good he maybe has fallen to. Though as a habs fan i still do this trade 100% no questions asked. Give me an actual reason to completely switch my allegiance to being a Nashville fan with PK/Price reunited again

Edmonton - McDavid is worth more than Price, by a wide gap. No way this happens

Florida - Price is worth more than either of those players individually. Combined though? Combined i'd argue they're worth more than Price. If Florida offers this i'd expert Bergevin to take it and run.

 

[Captain Controversy]

Haha price for Mcdavid.
Montreal wishes.
It is like trading patrick roy for mario lemiux.

 

[Zonk]

Jocelyn Thibault, Martin Rucinsky and Andrei Kovalenko.

Of course, no GM would be crazy enough to accept these three for the top goaltender in the league.

 

[KingTux]

Pretty much the same price you would pay for Karlsson. Price is the team

 

[Peter Puck]

On a serious note, Would rather shore up the Defense than pay that much to have carry Price. He is no longer the best goalie in the world. Holtby is.

Did you see the world cup? Holtby isn't even 2nd.

 

[Unspecified]

Does Price come with 3 cases of Osteo Bi-Flex?

 

[Soedy]

P.K. Subban for Price would be fun.

 

[Unspecified]

Halak+2nd

 

[Measles]

lol Price would cost the Oilers Pulji AND Draistl in any deal. Then u add with Talbot and the first (wont be worth much with Price and McJesus). Habs would ask for Eberle/RNH.

You think Price for 2 years would cost more than Subban for 7 years? Not a realistic price.