Confirmed Trade: [UTA/TBL] Mikhail Sergachev for Conor Geekie, J.J. Moser, 2025 2nd, 2024 7th

[JTBF81]

Didn't they win 2 Cups with Sergachev playing Top 3 minutes? lol

He was a sheltered dman behind both Hedman and McD. He hadn't lived up to the 8.5 aav contract and was still making very questionable decisions far too often, especially in his own end. He has plenty of talent, and perhaps he puts it all together in Utah, but whether Tampa had acquired Hanifin at the deadline or them when they did re-acquirr McD, the writing on the wall was there for Serg. It was a win-win, but Moser and Geekie have looked good so far in Tampa.

 

[FinnLightning26]

Good for Sergachev playing well in Utah but I haven't missed him one single bit. I've loved what I've seen from Moser and Geekie and the defense is better balanced with Sergachev's cap hit spread around.

 

[Drake1588]

If the bump was intended to dunk on Sergachev or Utah for trading for him, well that's asinine because he's been excellent this year. He has played like a very good No. 1 defenseman. Now Moser looks very good for Tampa as well and fits better into their salary structure. It's early days, but this trade looks win-win to me.

 

[KevinRedkey]

Looked like a win-win at the time.
Still looking like a win-win.

 

[JFleegs]

Glad to hear Sergy is doing well! I’ll always root for him to succeed. I need to catch more Utah games.

 

[Hockeyville USA]

Didn't they win 2 Cups with Sergachev playing Top 3 minutes? lol

Sergachev was good in the 2020 Cup run, but quite pedestrian in sheltered minutes in the 2021 Cup run. He showed big time flashes in the 2022 Cup Final run, had a great offensive regular season in 2022-23, but his defensive play was inconsistent to outright bad in Tampa.

Moser has been dominant at times defensively for the Lightning so far, and Geekie looks damn good on the 2nd line with Cirelli and Hagel. Plus we still have the 2nd to use.

 

[rt]

https://x.com/i/web/status/1851843189587743183

Up to 9pts in 11gp

All that said, I do STILL feel like this is going to be a win-win. Everyone wants to declare a winger five minutes after a trade. It’s ridiculous. I suspect both teams will end up happy. But the season just barely started. And Geekie could be anything from an All-Star to a 3rd line tweener. It’s way too early to say anything definitively. I really like all three players and hope they all play great.

 

[Figgy44]

https://x.com/i/web/status/1851843189587743183

Up to 9pts in 11gp

All that said, I do STILL feel like this is going to be a win-win. Everyone wants to declare a winger five minutes after a trade. It’s ridiculous. I suspect both teams will end up happy. But the season just barely started. And Geekie could be anything from an All-Star to a 3rd line tweener. It’s way too early to say anything definitively. I really like all three players and hope they all play great.

Has this trade helped to stabilize that d corps? Valimaki not playing over his head, getting as injured etc.?

 

[Rschmitz]

Sergachev was always going to be a lock for a ton of offensive production, now that he's getting #1 PP time.

Obviously no Kucherov/Stamkos/Point etc. but I said he'd be a lock for 60+

 

[rt]

Has this trade helped to stabilize that d corps? Valimaki not playing over his head, getting as injured etc.?

He’s been the team’s MVP this season. It’s only been a month. So I don’t want to get too crazy. But he’s Utahs October MvP anyway.

Sergachev was always going to be a lock for a ton of offensive production, now that he's getting #1 PP time.

Obviously no Kucherov/Stamkos/Point etc. but I said he'd be a lock for 60+

His all around play has been great. He’s keeping the team together out there.

You don’t lead the nhl in ice time and also get sheltered, easy minutes. It’s literally not mathematically possible.

 

[Rschmitz]

He’s been the team’s MVP this season. It’s only been a month. So I don’t want to get too crazy. But he’s Utahs October MvP anyway.


His all around play has been great. He’s keeping the team together out there.

You don’t lead the nhl in ice time and also get sheltered, easy minutes. It’s literally not mathematically possible.

This was the main problem with Sergachev in Tampa, he was gifted as much offensive zone time as we could spare outside of the #1 PP, but he was sub-par defensively and consistently was guilty of being out of position or getting beat to pucks. Lackadaisical is the best word to describe him, just going through the motions.


Looks like inserting him into the #1 role flipped a switch for him. Big fan favorite here, nice to see his play mature to match his heart.

 

[rt]

This was the main problem with Sergachev in Tampa, he was gifted as much offensive zone time as we could spare outside of the #1 PP, but he was sub-par defensively and consistently was guilty of being out of position or getting beat to pucks. Lackadaisical is the best word to describe him, just going through the motions.


Looks like inserting him into the #1 role flipped a switch for him. Big fan favorite here, nice to see his play mature to match his heart.

I really think this is the type of trade both fanbases could end up loving.

 

[ViD]

Sergachyov is now 7th in d man scoring passing Hedman.

Big trade win for Utah

 

[Michoulicious]

Sergachyov is now 7th in d man scoring passing Hedman.

Big trade win for Utah

Moeser is awesome, Geekie is a stud.

Not so fast.

 

[Jumptheshark]

both teams won this trade--

 

[Treb]

People have such a hard time grasping mutually beneficial deals.

 

[crackdown44]

People have such a hard time grasping mutually beneficial deals.

Tampa probably can’t sign Guentzel without moving Sergachev out either

 

[Breakers]

I remember the hype around drouin when he was sitting out

It was as bad as the Jimmy Vesey hype as a UFA

Serg has done well

 

[Five Alarm Fire]

Happy that Serg is having success with Utah. Last year was tough for him on multiple levels.

We’re very happy with Moser and Geekie.

 

[BLNY]

People have such a hard time grasping mutually beneficial deals.

Two men enter. One man leaves!

There can be only one!

 

[Byrddog]

People have such a hard time grasping mutually beneficial deals.

Tampa probably can’t sign Guentzel without moving Sergachev out either

Yes they could have but they would not be able to ice a 21 or 22 man roster. Glad Sergi is doing well he is a quality player. Geekie and Mosier still have room to improve but not many are going to complain about their game.

 

[Rschmitz]

Yes they could have but they would not be able to ice a 21 or 22 man roster. Glad Sergi is doing well he is a quality player. Geekie and Mosier still have room to improve but not many are going to complain about their game.

Many on the Lightning board believe a deal with Utah was already basically done when we traded for McDonagh, and Stamkos was on his way out when we went for Guentzel

 

[Treb]

Yes they could have but they would not be able to ice a 21 or 22 man roster. Glad Sergi is doing well he is a quality player. Geekie and Mosier still have room to improve but not many are going to complain about their game.

Which is what I'm saying, both team benefited from the deal.

 

[Llewzaher]

Totally a win- win

I wish we could have done this and kept Geekie though

 

[Schemp]

Sergachyov is now 7th in d man scoring passing Hedman.

Big trade win for Utah

Tampa got the better end of the trade, but Utah got the best player, which is what they were seeking, and tried to get adequate replacements for the assets that were replaced.