Again, the point production is there. And as you said, has improved every year.
It’s the “power forward” aspect of his game that I think people had high hopes for (including myself) which really hasn’t come to be. That certainly may have been the fault of giddy fans like myself that thought we were getting a Lucic-lite rather than him failing to achieve his potential in any way.
Just to reiterate. The skill and production makes him a very effective long term third line forward, second line if you really need him there. But he’s not a guy you want to have in the top 6 or a guy you can count on to produce when the game tightens up. Just my two cents.