Yeah he had 12 more points than Maroon and did it while not playing with McDavid.
Goals are important but he isn't scoring 27 sniper goals. He is the kind of guy who is good at rebounds and crashing the net.
His HIGHEST goal total outside of last year was 11. You do not pay a player like that $5mill+.
If he repeats that and bumps up his assists than absolutely you have an argument. But after 1 year that was a VERY large outlier in his career...yeah its overpaid.
It would be an easier arguement to make if RNH, Lucic, etc. weren't such bums that Maroon was outproducing them in many respects.
It's not easy to ask really your 3rd best employee to accept a salary that's the 5th or 6th highest on the team.
His agent can very easily point and say "hey my guy is outproducing this guy who you're paying $6 millon dollars to". It's also why Leon's agent was never going to budge on his salary demands ... why should he take only a million measly more than Nugent Hopkins or Lucic when he clearly was far better than them? You have to be careful who you pay money to because it will be used as a comparable.
If you can get Maroon locked in at 4 per ... (5/5/5/3/2.5) I think you have to do it. If Strome has to walk for nothing so be it. If Kassian has to go, so be it. We're not going to get a top line LW off the UFA for less than $6 million.
Unless you want to play Drake Caggiula as McDavid's LW and gamble a season on that working.