20 goal/50 point season during the worst season of his career while playing on the 2nd line and 2nd PP unit is still pretty good. As for the playoffs there is no defending his performance, he was really bad at both ends of the rink. The thing is that it takes 82 games to get to the playoffs and Eberle is a good regular season player that helped us get into the playoffs.
I know that this isn't exactly the be-all and end-all of stats, but quite frankly I don't really agree with this sentiment for the main reason that Eberle had exactly 0 Game Winning Goals last season.
I decided to run the numbers on the
types of points he scored in each game, and to his credit, 6 of his goals were game-tying goals, of which we wound up winning 4 of those games. Half of his total goals (10) were scored when we were already leading. He scored our first goal 4 times. He scored 2 empty net goals.
Of his 20 goals, 12 of them came against Vancouver, Calgary, and Colorado (evenly split at 4 per team). Of the remaining 8 goals, three of them were against playoff teams (2 against PIT, 1 against NSH). Counting Calgary, 7/20 of Eberle's goals were against teams that made the playoffs. Other than Calgary and Vancouver, Eberle did not score against a Pacific Division team.
Assists fare a bit better, as 14/31 of Eberle's assists were against teams that made playoffs. Eberle definitely performed better as a playmaker against Pacific Division teams, putting up 13 assists in 29 divisional games. Eberle certainly had a big impact in game #26 in particular, with 3 points against the Ducks in a 3-2 OT victory, so I'll give him direct credit for those points. Overall, including the power play and empty net, 13/31 of his assists were primary assists, which isn't a terrible ratio.
He's definitely not a bad player by any means, but he's streaky - he had 8 different stretches of 5 games of more without scoring a goal, including one span of
19 Games (Games 29 - 46 inclusive) without scoring a goal. As others have mentioned, four of his goals (20% of his total, that is) came after we clinched the playoffs.
Jordan Eberle, in my eyes, is most effective as a "win more" player - once you have established an offensive presence (hopefully with a goal or two on the board), he can help you extend that lead. There's a place for this type of player, but I question whether the playoffs in the Pacific is that sort of place.