Yes it depends on the cost. A B prospect and a low draft pick is all I would offer. If someone makes a ridiculous offer like Dubas in the McGroarty trade they can have him.
HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #88: 2024 Off-Season Thread
- Thread starter MarkovsKnee
- Start date
- Status
Even Betman would love this , now that we have a management that is friendly with the commissionerI think he beats Gordie Howe's record
The subscriber base on TVA, RDS and Sportsnet would go through the roof. It would definitely be in the NHL's best interest to surrender the Crosby to us!
Meh... I probably wouldn't do that.
Value is fine, but fit not so much. Question of Short term boost of Robertson vs longer runway of waiver exempt status to let Mesar develop ... I prefer the latter
Fair.
Suspect the Laffs are looking for more than that, but if something like Farrell/ Trudeau/ Davidson/ Kidney + a 4th or 5th is the cost, then sure.
Not sure why Laffs wouldn't just keep him at that kind of return. He's got zero leverage in trying to force a trade.
Yes. I would keep Davidson but any of the others I would do. Mesar won't be traded. He is Slaf's buddy so it is unlikely he is moved unless and until he shows he is not an NHL player.
Sterling Archer
Registered User
- Sep 26, 2006
- 23,338
- 14,099
I wouldn’t give anything for an undersized, non productive, bust of a winger from Toronto.
It’s like acquiring all of Caufield’s cons with none of his pros. Hard pass.
He has most of Caufield's pros. Hasn't really been given a real shot with Toronto. Some of that is due to injuries though.
jellybeans
Registered User
- Nov 9, 2007
- 1,352
- 1,138
Roy ahead of Demidov lmfao.If Crosby leaves Pitt (that's a big IF, odds are he elects to finish his career there & unlike Tampa with Stamkos, I doubt the Pens flinch at paying him full market value/term, plus he probably takes less to help them add for one last push), then I think there's legitimate reason to view the Habs as a front runner...
- childhood team + his sense of hockey history
- cap room & roster/cap situation to pay him market value on a 2-4yr deal without blowing up cap
- top 3? 5? U25 group in the league... Perfectly set up to push towards contending in that 2-4year window, especially adding a piece like him
- management group building the kind of culture a person & player like Sid will value immensely
Slaf Suzuki CC
Roy Crosby Laine
Demidov Dach Newhook
Ca sent la coupe icitte
That's a very big stretch...
Do you really think Caufield on the Laffs the past few years would not have been getting regular top 6 role?
I think that's highly unlikely. If anything, Caufield playing with that group is already a 40+ goal scorer and a fixture in their top 6. Robertson is not at all in the same ball park.
Habs could probably extend Crosby's career. He wouldn't have to carry the team on his back. He might be able to play longer and have more left for the playoffs.
Seriously why even bother if you're going to be playing Crosby on the 3rd line..Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Happy
He won't waive for that.
The coach was clueless. No telling if Caufield would have even gotten decent minutes. He had 55 goals in 46 games in his last OHL season. Of course he has missed more games than he has played. Could be a glass body and no telling why he wants out so I wouldn't give up much to get him. If they got him he has to do something this season to justify a spot or increase his trade value.
Jesus. There is NO 3rd line. Just 3 first lines.Seriously why even bother if you're going to be playing Crosby on the 3rd line..
He won't waive for that.
Seriously why even bother if you're going to be playing Crosby on the 3rd line..
He won't waive for that.
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
There
It's as if some posters haven't actually followed real NHL games
Yall should just throw their names in a hat and pick whoever, like we just didn't finish with a 5 OA
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
There
It's as if some posters haven't actually followed real NHL games
??????????Yall should just throw their names in a hat and pick whoever, like we just didn't finish with a 5 OA
Keep living in the past... Enjoy that.Yall should just throw their names in a hat and pick whoever, like we just didn't finish with a 5 OA
The Great Weal
Phil's Pizza
- Jan 15, 2015
- 55,260
- 71,011
What if we are giving an undersized, even less productive, and lower-potential winger?
Robertson doesn't really make any sense given how we are kind of filled up on forwards, but the irony of your post needed to be pointed out.
Monday's
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
There
It's as if some posters haven't actually followed real NHL games
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Tuesday's
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Wednesday's
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Thursday's
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Friday's
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Saturday's
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Sunday's (alternates every-week with the 3 1st lines)
now that is how you distributes minute whens you have 3 first lines
BLONG7
Registered User
How do we pry Crosby out of Pittsburgh? Who gets traded?
Reverse The Sherriff for Struble also.....and David Savard is gone himself at the deadline.
I sacrifice Newhook and trade Matheson over Savard, completing the offers with the depth of the pool (Kapanen, Konyushkov, etc...) and picks. It's entirely possible I'd have to sacrifice Struble also you're right.
Sterling Archer
Registered User
- Sep 26, 2006
- 23,338
- 14,099
So you took my post, intermingled it with your imagination and created a completely fantasizes new “ironic” meaning to what you imagined I meant to say.
Niiiice job there.
Someone hire this manMonday's
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Tuesday's
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Wednesday's
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Thursday's
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Friday's
Slaf Suzuki CC
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Saturday's
Demidov Dach Newhook
Roy Crosby Laine
Slaf Suzuki CC
Sunday's (alternates every-week with the 3 1st lines)
now that is how you distributes minute whens you have 3 first lines
- Status
