HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #88: 2024-25 Season

BozoTheClown

Registered User
Jul 10, 2021
1,652
2,101
At some point, it didn't go well for Max and he was sent down. He was so pissed that when he returned he had a drive and became the top player that he got known for. Maybe that's what they need to do with Dach.

But when Dach joined us, he was good. Esp. when they paired him with CC and Suz. But he got injured and he has sucked this season. He just stopped being physical, he's not being himself. That's why we need a hard ass coach to make him realise this.
We could all tell by Pacioretty’s 3rd season that he was special. Chicago got rid of Dach, a3rd overall after 3 seasons only and is now in his 6th season and look terrible.

I don’t like the fact Chicago gave u on him so fast and I think they saw something that I think we are now seeing. Part of it must be his lack intensity, his nonchalance and his poor work ethic.
 

MarkovsKnee

Global Moderator
Nov 21, 2007
55,484
70,531
Toronto
Have you seen who the canes coach is?

KK would not get any icetime with poor work ethic.

KK's on-ice work ethic is generally fine. He's the first one to get benched if it isn't. It's his off-ice work ethic that has been questioned particularly summer training.

He's a 2nd/3rd line tweener. He's not good enough offensively to be a true 2nd line center, but his physicality and his willingness to go to the net opens the ice for his linemates particularly Necas. He's not good enough defensively to be a shut down, 3rd line guy like Jordan Staal either.

The guy we're really missing is Monahan. He could carry his own line. There's not much available out there right now.
 

Treb

Global Flanderator
May 31, 2011
29,758
30,584
Montreal
I wonder if we could entice TB in a Primeau for Johansson+ swap? Pretty confident it would be an upgrade for them with a limited cap increase. Also gives them the chance to get a cheap goalie next year as Primeau is still RFA (and they have nothing in the pipeline).

On the Habs side, they would send Johansson on waivers and try Dobes and Hughes as backups.
 

BozoTheClown

Registered User
Jul 10, 2021
1,652
2,101
You're completely wrong on both Pacioretty and Markov. Both had to be sent down and a lot of people and posters here thought Pacioretty would be a bust, until he asked to be sent down and lit it up with Desharnais in the AHL. Markov took off in his third season, but had a really tough year in 2003-2004 after his father's death. Lots of players take time. Chicago let Strome go the same year as Dach and he's become a great player for Washington. Newhook isn't going to be special, but he can become a serviceable and versatile player with time. Dach, we still don't know what we have as he's missed so much time, but he looked like a legitimate top 6 player before the injury.
I knew after a couple of seasons that Markov and Pacioretty were going to be special players and both were already impactful in their 3rd season with Montreal.

Dach and Newhook are in their 6th and 5th seasons and still have not made the impact Max and Andrei had.

So no, I am not wrong, I am actually right.
 

Andrei79

Registered User
Jan 25, 2013
16,504
30,671
I knew after a couple of seasons that Markov and Pacioretty were going to be special players and both were already impactful in their 3rd season with Montreal.

Dach and Newhook are in their 6th and 5th seasons and still have not made the impact Max and Andrei had.

So no, I am not wrong, I am actually right.

No, you would be wrong again. Both started coming into their own in their D+5, I don't know why you would not count the seasons they spent elsewhere after their draft, it's frankly disingenuous not to. Pacioretty in particular was a draft pick many were bashing until he asked to be sent down and made strides in his game. Dach did in his D+4 then got a major injury in his D+5 that has derailed his progress. Newhook was very good down the stretch last year and was pacing for 50 points. Lots of players are looking bad this year due to the team being dysfunctional on the ice, it's hard to make any projections on the roster right now due to it.
 

BozoTheClown

Registered User
Jul 10, 2021
1,652
2,101
No, you would be wrong again. Both started coming into their own in their D+5, I don't know why you would not count the seasons they spent elsewhere after their draft, it's frankly disingenuous not to. Pacioretty in particular was a draft pick many were bashing until he asked to be sent down and made strides in his game. Dach did in his D+4 then got a major injury in his D+5 that has derailed his progress. Newhook was very good down the stretch last year and was pacing for 50 points. Lots of players are looking bad this year due to the team being dysfunctional on the ice, it's hard to make any projections on the roster right now due to it.
I know I am right, but we will agree to disagree.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Habs7631

Estimated_Prophet

Registered User
Mar 28, 2003
11,157
12,387
Yes, since Buffalo, and Guhle is playing better. But Matheson playing on his off side is a disaster in waiting. The guy already have a hard time playing his natural side. Shopping for a rd is essential
Matheson is a very good dman and the criticism around here is embarrassingly ill-informed.

How many of these posters know that Matheson is second in the league in takeaways (he was 1st before the 5 game layoff) and has the best Takeaway:Giveaway ratio of any dman in the top 100 and maybe even the entire league if I could see past the top 100.

Every single game he makes defensive plays that only a handful of dmen even have the ability to make yet he is the whipping boy for those who can't see past the odd gaffe yet miraculously are easily able to do so when Hutson does it who happens to have committed 25% more giveaways than Matheson and has 40% fewer takeaways than Matheson. I think Lane has been fantastic for the most part so I am not s******g on him at all. I have just noticed that the Matheson negativity is often linked to the Hutson hype and it is annoyingly prevalent around here.

Mistakes are going to happen when a player has the puck on his stick as much as Matheson does but the fact is that he does far more good than does bad and to not recognize that is troubling to read/listen to.

So.....If we are fine with the Hutson good/bad trade-off then let's be intellectually honest and put away the pitchforks and torches that are consistently headed Matheson's way and acknowledge the positive disparity between good and bad.

Skater Advanced Statistics​


Corsi (EV)Fenwick (EV)PDO ()Zone Starts (EV)
RkPlayerAgeTmPosGPCFCACF%CF% relFFFAFF%FF% reloiSH%oiSV%PDOoZS%dZS%TOI/60TOI(EV)TK
GVE+/-SAtt.Thru%
1Travis Sanheim28PHID2144748048.24.831432349.34.310.987.998.847.952.125:3221:3724231.610447.1
2Mike Matheson30MTLD2032839945.1-1.022727845.0-0.211.585.797.244.155.924:0517:452220-3.48733.3
3Cale Makar26COLD2147038754.81.931626654.31.510.784.995.764.435.624:3619:06203310.216138.5
4Jake Sanderson22OTTD2042136553.6-0.930125454.2-1.35.187.192.350.249.824:3518:5020323.39244.6
5Evan Bouchard25EDMD2257333563.112.040725961.18.89.886.396.168.931.123:5420:0418359.715737.6
6Mitch Marner27TORRW2033131751.12.223721652.32.011.590.1101.650.949.121:3615:3618274.59553.7
7Alex Vlasic23CHID2132544942.0-3.923429544.2-1.512.090.1102.241.558.523:3119:141825-3.15642.9
8Zach Werenski27CBJD2050041254.84.835129854.13.89.191.1100.259.540.526:0521:3216251.316645.8
9Filip Forsberg30NSHC2139630256.77.527221955.46.99.186.996.062.137.918:5615:3516241.617343.4
10Barclay Goodrow31SJSRW2326529147.73.317820446.62.03.487.891.243.656.415:1712:061624-2.35754.4
11Jaccob Slavin30CARD2042232556.5-6.330524056.0-6.612.489.6102.060.639.421:2617:5116150.96830.9
12Charlie Coyle32BOSC/RW2224227846.5-2.216819945.8-2.46.389.195.438.661.417:2711:501614-1.86350.8
13Alex Tuch28BUFRW2137530555.14.326520856.06.715.587.7103.259.440.620:0815:0915153.310945.9
14Hampus Lindholm31BOSD1726325950.43.218818350.74.39.487.697.044.655.420:5115:221430-0.38143.2
15Dylan Samberg26WPGD2138936751.53.829826652.85.512.190.5102.743.956.120:1717:4214261.46342.9
16Noah Dobson25NYID2144842151.65.033929153.86.18.189.998.053.946.124:4920:5514232.311951.3
17Mikko Rantanen28COLRW2146237055.53.032025056.14.613.885.999.765.035.022:2318:2614228.712352.0
18Dmitry Kulikov34FLAD2136933352.6-1.227525452.00.312.389.5101.854.145.920:1218:2614154.25040.0
19MacKenzie Weegar31CGYD2142736154.25.927823654.15.57.992.8100.749.750.323:3118:461343-0.413043.8
20Roman Josi34NSHD2152738857.610.437029655.68.77.985.493.370.129.925:2620:0213311.815446.8
21Damon Severson30CBJD2041234954.13.229124554.33.712.485.497.845.354.721:5318:0213294.08145.7
22Carter Verhaeghe29FLAC2137430055.53.227323254.13.47.783.991.553.646.418:4315:3813264.214551.7
23Mario Ferraro26SJSD2335946543.6-2.424433642.1-4.56.589.796.341.458.620:3317:391320-9.45940.7
24Adam Fox26NYRD1939130056.612.528721457.312.99.889.799.655.244.822:3017:4013202.96936.2
25J.J. Moser24TBLD1931433348.5-2.722623249.3-1.313.292.0105.244.755.320:5417:481319-1.15639.3
26Kris Letang37PITD2040238451.1-1.028028949.2-1.77.488.095.455.644.423:0618:211318-3.99652.1
27Mika Zibanejad31NYRC1924732543.2-7.318123843.2-7.79.887.497.249.450.618:1613:141317-4.57946.8
28Chandler Stephenson30SEAC2131332149.41.121022348.5-0.810.488.198.447.252.820:0414:531315-7.54050.0
29Anže Kopitar37LAKC2131329751.3-2.521221050.2-6.015.089.4104.545.454.619:0614:501313-1.15944.1
30Erik Karlsson34PITD2351347551.91.335834251.12.38.786.394.950.749.322:4319:301243-3.615536.8
31Rasmus Andersson28CGYD2144750147.2-5.533034049.3-2.09.792.0101.745.354.724:5520:121232-1.79838.8
32Vincent Trocheck31NYRC1933034049.31.324025348.7-0.110.190.5100.651.248.821:3116:3712320.07859.0
33Thomas Chabot28OTTD2047232159.59.133823259.37.39.687.196.863.736.323:2519:0412306.512642.1
34Colton Parayko31STLD2239950144.3-6.727633745.0-3.58.988.697.538.161.924:5021:371230-4.78450.0
35Leon Draisaitl29EDMC2248229761.99.135722561.38.510.888.399.164.735.321:1517:3512299.611154.1
36Lane Hutson20MTLD2035142945.0-1.223928945.30.39.486.495.851.049.022:5620:061225-1.77126.8
37Mattias Ekholm34EDMD2257833663.212.340925661.59.59.784.994.668.131.923:0719:40122411.212747.2
38Brady Skjei30NSHD2140234154.13.728426651.61.49.288.097.262.637.421:0317:311224-3.19346.2
39Connor Clifton29BUFD2022725247.4-6.115517746.7-5.98.792.4101.130.669.415:3912:291223-1.55230.8
40Shayne Gostisbehere31CARD2039019966.28.327915164.96.88.987.396.263.836.218:5514:5412185.910637.7
41Jacob Middleton29MIND2034040245.8-3.723428345.3-5.415.994.7110.649.850.220:2618:371217-1.05655.4
42Owen Tippett25PHIRW2130833647.83.321023547.20.57.184.791.948.851.217:2714:221217-0.813542.2
43Jake Walman28SJSD1835132152.28.125122552.79.110.789.8100.555.944.122:4117:2412133.711546.1
44Mikhail Sergachev26UTAD2041333355.42.329224454.52.810.887.898.650.449.625:3318:2011360.29634.4
45Brent Burns39CARD/RW2043130758.4-3.231022757.7-3.711.287.498.662.038.021:3317:2811321.510338.8
46Ian Cole35UTAD2033730452.6-2.122920752.5-0.412.288.4100.646.953.120:1817:051131-1.75731.6
47Ivan Provorov28CBJD2045338154.33.632328153.52.69.688.998.551.648.423:4319:4011300.58333.7
48Shea Theodore29VEGD2035737948.51.724327247.2-1.69.988.698.655.944.122:1718:5911282.29743.3
49Esa Lindell30DALD1932233948.7-7.723923850.1-3.910.290.9101.141.958.121:5118:1511270.66048.3
50Charlie McAvoy27BOSD2236437249.52.125426948.61.69.991.5101.460.639.424:0217:411127-0.19348.4
51Jack Hughes23NJDC2344936155.49.830725754.48.69.890.8100.673.826.220:3016:3311266.614650.7
52Wyatt Kaiser22CHID1927028648.66.419219050.37.25.194.499.546.054.017:0315:181126-0.54738.3
53Ryan Graves29PITD2026326949.4-3.018919449.3-1.54.988.493.338.161.915:1913:3111252.65532.7
54Oliver Ekman-Larsson33TORD2036835051.32.626525351.20.310.190.9101.061.838.221:0917:3911240.88246.3
55Mikael Backlund35CGYC2134632351.72.024722152.83.48.892.9101.734.665.419:4015:1511220.910453.8
56Kirill Marchenko24CBJRW2038228257.57.928221057.38.011.990.2102.156.343.718:1315:3711226.410250.0
57Matt Boldy23MINLW2034428654.69.525120255.410.112.491.3103.742.257.819:3115:3611173.313852.2
58Ondřej Palát33NJDLW2226629647.3-2.817522344.0-6.47.891.599.358.241.813:2512:471116-1.75056.0
59Connor Brown31EDMRW2224024549.5-8.116316649.5-8.05.792.197.846.653.413:5112:2411151.26068.3
60Taylor Hall33CHILW2027828849.16.217719447.73.37.989.697.453.446.615:1213:451114-0.98350.6
61Morgan Barron26WPGC2117314454.66.51259856.17.94.291.395.529.570.511:079:1611121.14257.1
62Trevor Moore29LAKLW2131424356.44.622916058.96.19.887.397.149.051.016:5913:071111-0.59154.9
63Uvis Balinskis28FLAD2122219753.0-0.515815650.3-1.96.785.792.463.636.414:1411:391180.45152.9
64David Pastrňák28BOSRW2230130449.82.322022149.93.49.989.799.665.734.319:4114:511038-1.916952.7
65Josh Manson33COLD2131731650.1-5.120721848.7-6.610.184.794.740.559.518:0916:131034-6.37331.5
66Johnathan Kovacevic27NJDD2334236348.5-0.824625848.80.012.493.8106.234.066.020:2217:3910333.06334.9
67Marcus Pettersson28PITD2353345254.15.037032753.15.59.786.295.948.351.722:2319:301032-3.07832.1
68Mason Lohrei24BOSD1824728646.3-1.816220843.8-3.810.591.0101.552.147.917:4115:441030-3.34443.2
69John Carlson35WSHD2041237452.45.930026153.54.514.889.9104.753.446.624:3918:1610295.211541.7
70Miro Heiskanen25DALD1944639253.2-0.830328951.2-2.610.891.0101.856.743.324:4821:0110284.513334.6
71Rasmus Dahlin24BUFD2151836059.011.735726157.810.911.089.4100.457.242.824:4520:0910251.914843.2
72Connor McDavid28EDMC1945326263.411.033020761.59.112.384.296.574.225.821:1317:38102410.512754.3
73Jared McCann28SEAC2127826850.93.119019050.01.216.190.3106.449.250.817:1912:5910214.011444.7
74Maxim Tsyplakov26NYIF2131429052.04.723221551.92.49.992.2102.155.244.816:3814:2310192.46942.0
75Moritz Seider23DETD2038341448.14.326130246.43.79.891.5101.343.656.424:2319:271018-2.07744.2
76Troy Terry27ANAC/RW1929033946.13.421624646.83.27.092.999.944.255.817:5414:421017-2.89444.7
77Jack Eichel28VEGC2132836847.10.123826547.3-0.815.390.1105.456.543.520:4515:3710162.111256.3
78Clayton Keller26UTAC2033226156.03.023019853.71.412.186.698.759.940.118:6015:2810161.110048.0
79Alexis Lafrenière23NYRLW1935031053.06.926022953.26.69.985.495.358.341.717:3116:1810160.77455.4
80Ryan McLeod25BUFC2126827649.3-4.119320348.7-3.815.091.3106.345.154.916:0713:361015-4.94742.6
81Yanni Gourde33SEAC2127528349.30.919919750.31.610.590.8101.439.660.415:1713:171014-1.15248.1
82Elias Pettersson26VANC1929125853.01.820417154.45.212.390.3102.643.356.719:3214:4510142.38348.2
83Fabian Zetterlund25SJSW2335238547.83.823027645.50.613.391.6105.056.543.517:2115:061013-2.210442.3
84Nic Dowd34WSHC2024427846.7-2.717019346.8-5.213.491.5104.910.090.015:5113:15109-0.84358.1
85Brandon Montour30SEAD2044739253.37.731027353.27.010.193.3103.451.248.823:3620:20928-0.614645.2
86Justin Faulk32STLD2240143947.7-0.927532645.8-2.36.391.597.954.745.323:2519:32927-1.79842.9
87Noah Hanifin28VEGD2136443945.3-2.727531246.8-1.611.587.799.353.846.221:1218:36925-1.06955.1
88Nick Schmaltz28UTAC2031524456.43.421818154.62.611.684.696.258.341.718:1914:219240.08946.1
89Adam Fantilli20CBJC2028028149.9-3.019220648.2-5.09.387.196.460.839.216:4714:26922-2.48549.4
90Ivan Barbashev29VEGC2131736746.3-1.123326646.7-1.715.990.5106.457.442.616:2715:239210.46852.9
91Jakob Chychrun26WSHD1526026549.5-0.418618150.7-2.314.992.3107.256.343.719:4018:109211.26543.1
92Warren Foegele28LAKLW2129023355.43.220415756.52.811.392.2103.455.444.615:0412:399211.99252.2
93Matty Beniers22SEAC2130229850.32.420320449.91.110.192.5102.655.244.817:3214:529201.97051.4
94K'Andre Miller25NYRD1937934452.46.327724453.26.88.588.897.253.946.122:0419:01920-1.87040.0
95Phillip Danault31LAKC2131623657.25.722715559.46.97.991.399.250.849.217:1913:27919-0.57542.7
96Owen Power22BUFD2139336252.1-0.327726051.60.213.186.799.855.344.721:4517:56919-3.67450.0
97Alexandre Carrier28NSHD2130536545.5-9.121626944.5-9.27.389.196.440.759.320:1217:06917-6.43748.6
98Jalen Chatfield28CARD2037025958.8-2.327319059.0-1.613.594.7108.149.550.518:2316:189172.97136.6
99Pavel Dorofeyev24VEGLW2126931446.1-1.319921747.80.08.187.895.862.637.416:1013:49917-0.89761.9
100Conor Garland28VANRW1926425850.6-1.720517753.74.28.892.2101.151.848.219:1115:019171.68548.2
 
Last edited:

jellybeans

Registered User
Nov 9, 2007
1,354
1,139
I wonder if it would be possible to explore CC for B. Tkachuk. One big obstable is I know CC has a no movement and I doubt he would like going to Ottawa.
CC can be traded anytime,habs do this very quickly but Ottawa laughs and hangs up
 

Treb

Global Flanderator
May 31, 2011
29,758
30,584
Montreal
I wonder if it would be possible to explore CC for B. Tkachuk. One big obstable is I know CC has a no movement and I doubt he would like going to Ottawa.

Caufield's M-NTC starts in 2028-2029 with a 15 no-trade list. Goes down to 10 and 5 the two following years.
 

skidcells

Registered User
May 11, 2023
394
783
Question for you all: at what point do you ‘quit’ on Dach and newhook and try to trade them while they still have some value? Holding onto them for too long will deplete any residual trade value they might have a la Barron.

For me they can be packaged with other pieces for a promising RHD
 

Sterling Archer

Registered User
Sep 26, 2006
23,358
14,126
Another edition of Hughes working the phones:


The Fourth Period/ Pagnotta must have been inspired by LeBrun. 💀
There’s nothing to write about so they wrote about nothing. Then when Habs make a trade, they make it sound like they knew all along what was going to happen. It’s the “insider” formula. Teams are looking to do something, teams are working the phones, teams looking for a shakeup. Same ol’ all the time to justify having a full time job.
 

BargainBinSpecial

Registered User
Jul 2, 2018
2,705
1,414
We could all tell by Pacioretty’s 3rd season that he was special. Chicago got rid of Dach, a3rd overall after 3 seasons only and is now in his 6th season and look terrible.

I don’t like the fact Chicago gave u on him so fast and I think they saw something that I think we are now seeing. Part of it must be his lack intensity, his nonchalance and his poor work ethic.
It's mostly his injuries. Drouin is doing fine in Colorado. Sometimes, young players come with high expectations and they simply crack. Dach is one of these. Relegated to a third line, I'm sure Dach would be just fine. Nothing special though. Priority at the draft would be to draft a bonefied C.
 

Gaylord Q Tinkledink

Registered User
Apr 29, 2018
33,932
37,259
I'd easily swap a couple lower end a prospects for Jiricek. Like Mesar and Mailloux.
Mesar looked good stars wise, but Jiricek is definitely better/worth a lot more, so I doubt Columbus does that type of deal.

Habs' prospect pool isn't as good as people think and for RHD it's pretty much non-existent because they'd rather draft a random Latvian goalie than a 6'3, rhd in his 2nd go through, but that's another thing.

Habs need to keep Reinbacher and Mailloux AND add Jiricek and hope one of them works out to be at least a top 4 dman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sampollock

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad