Post-Game Talk: Trade Deadline Day: March 7, 2025: Montreal stands pat

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
  • We are currently aware of "log in/security error" issues that are affecting some users. We apologize and ask for your patience as we try to get these issues fixed.
Seriously why are we not selling? Hello? I must be going crazy..... Sell everybody we are rebuilding don't fall for the trap wtf.

Evans resigning doesn't mean we have to keep all the guys who won't be on the team when we are ever good
This isn't NHL 25, there's a locker room to manage too. You send the wrong message to the players if you just trade everything after they're making a push for the playoffs.

I rather have a strong locker room than to sell everything and mess up the juju. We're trending in the good direction, changes will be made this summer.

I would love for a hockey trade, get a good 2C if possible or a strong 5th D ALA Carrier again.
 
Because if they can make the playoffs then players get playoff experience. And 95% of them have never been in the playoffs so they will see how different it is and be ready when thay are a real contender.
I personally think smart asset management is more important than getting stomped in the first round that we probably won’t even make it to anyway but I also understand the desire to get young players the experience
 
This isn't NHL 25, there's a locker room to manage too. You send the wrong message to the players if you just trade everything after they're making a push for the playoffs.

I rather have a strong locker room than to sell everything and mess up the juju. We're trending in the good direction, changes will be made this summer.

I would love for a hockey trade, get a good 2C if possible or a strong 5th D ALA Carrier again.
Right this season is more important than our next 2-3-4 seasons , good to know
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michelangelo
I would surely put Kapanen on the market.

Kapanen, Engstrom, Mailloux, Roy are interesting pieces you can add to a 1st pick to get a good player back.

Unless they identify that somebody from your list has absolutely no future with the club, you can't trade those peices for a rental at this stage of their competitive cycle.

It would have to be a hockey trade which are much harder to pull off and are more rare to see on deadline day. By that, I mean the guy they get back is someone they identify as a good peice for years to come.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dralaf and Ozmodiar
It’s strange to not sell players and also not acquire players to replace Dach and Guhle.

If this is the case, it will be the second of four Trade Deadlines where Hughes sat on his hands and warmed them up.

I don’t agree with it but will defer to Hughes’ insight. So if doesn’t make any moves this summer I’ll be negatively surprised.

The “wait till summer before you criticise the GM” is an issue that persisted throughout the Bergevin era — I’m not gonna subscribe to it again. This trade deadline can be quiet, that’s fine, but not this coming summer.
It won't be. Hughes loves the draft, you've seen it pretty much every one he's been GM. The team HAS taken a step. We're not there yet obviously but we're also not Chicago anymore either. He knows this is a pivotal offseason with a ton of money coming off the books and assets at our disposal.

One thing Hughes isn't is dumb, which, eh, I don't know if you couldn't exactly say about Bergevin with his "moar big, more muscles" philosophy. He knows Dach going down means it's probably it for him as a future piece/C of this team.

You'd be you wouldn't be surprised if he doesn't do anything this summer, I'd be EXTREMELY surprised.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MarkovsKnee
Could use? Must. I could use a G-Wagon. I must have my liver and both kidneys.

Overpay? Yes. And we will eventually overpay for our true 2C too. Now we MUST overpay for a passable (no pun intended) 2C. This is a dead team walking without one.
I should have clarified that we needed someone till the end of the season with a bigger move coming in the summer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SisuHabsSisu
Right this season is more important than our next 2-3-4 seasons , good to know
We don't need picks, we have enough. Why trade a player for a 5th rounder if we can mess the locker room at the same time? It makes no sense. You add players in the room now in a trade, but not for futures and I don't think there's a strong market for a hockey trade without picks right now
 
Is Connor Murphy (RD) a guy that we could acquire/sign and have him replace Savy on our 3rd pairing next year?
I wrote a post a few days ago that I'd target him and Nico Sturm. I think Sturm was a great pickup by Florida. I think Murphy would be a good pick up for Montreal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deebs
Unless they can aquire a guy to plug at 2C in the medium term, they need to sell. They wont go anywhere with rookie Owen Beck as their second center.
I feel that all depends what's being offered. If it isn't some sort of overpayment, there's value in battling as long as you can I'm hopes of making the play offs. If holding on to Savard and Armia keep them in the race that much longer or possibly make it then that's worth more then say a 3rd rounder. In my opinion of course
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catanddogguitarrr
Do we get a 1st for Armia at 50%?

Do we get a 2nd for Savard at 50%?
Maybe for Savard.

No way in hell for Armia. You have to be pretty stupid, or the Habs are adding one of their 2nds(pens/their own), so the drop isn't that significant.


If the Habs arent going to make a trade, why not use the last retention spot to help facilitate a trade and get a later round pixk in 2027 ?

It's not my money and gives you future assets to draft, or acquire a depth player.
 
Unless they identify that somebody from your list has absolutely no future with the club, you can't trade those peices for a rental at this stage of their competitive cycle.

It would have to be a hockey trade which are much harder to pull off and are more rare to see on deadline day. By that, I mean the guy they get back is someone they identify as a good peice for years to come.
Off course not for a rental.

Habs will never pay a 1st for a rental, let alone add a nhl ready prospect.
 
It doesn't matter if they lose. The experience will be invaluable when they are a contender.
Someone mentioned it the other day but Suzuki is the only guy we have that's played in the playoffs with the Bell Centre at full capacity. I want the other guys to see what it's going to be like when they take the step.

I don't know if we get there this year but I appreciate the fight to do it. The only guy that would have been worth trading was Evans, and now that he's locked up I don't really see the benefit in trading others for lower pieces.

Edit: Might have been Gallagher, not Suzuki. Cause Gallagher has as well.
 
Hughes is sticking to his plan. He may grab a player to replace Beck because Beck clearly isn't ready.
What I hope they do is add good AHL vets to help Laval go deep into the post season
Beck isn't ready to play between Laine and Newhook quelle surprise. The fact that he looks like the only one doing anything positive on that line is what concerns me. Put Dvorak or even Evans between those two and my guess is they aren't that much better. Beck should be playing with Gallgher and Anderson or Heineman and Armia long before he should be playing with those other two. The fact that they haven't totally shit the bed defensively is a good enough indication for me that Beck is ready if deployed properly.
Back to Laval please is right.
 
I personally think smart asset management is more important than getting stomped in the first round that we probably won’t even make it to anyway but I also understand the desire to get young players the experience

Management is dealing with humans though.

One way to make your leadership group pissed off and lose their trust is if they get to the stretch drive and work their ass off to be in striking range of the playoffs, only to have the rug pulled under them by management.

They have earned the right to see this through as a team. The experience they earn down the stretch and the reinforcement of a serious culture is worth more than a middling draft pick which most likely won't turn into an nhl level player, let alone an impact nhler at this stage of the build.

Regardless, this team already has loaded on draft capital. At some point it's time to focus on trying to fit some peices of the puzzle from a team building standpoint, than adding even more redundant jigsaw peices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: President XD

Ad

Ad