Those very same words could be used to describe Campbell and Kuemper. Both have missed multiple game stretches multiple times in their careers (even last season), and that concern would only be magnified going forward on contracts with the terms they will be receiving (rumored to be 5 years minimum).
The Leafs meanwhile, get a goalie who was .915 going into his final start of the season, a 3rd, and a 7th for $4.69 million in cap space for only 2 season.
People seem to have this bizarre impression that this will be the only goalie acquisition. Having mentioned that both current 'backup' goalies are both waiver exempt, this would seem to suggest that another move for a G is coming.
And don't get me wrong, I do not like this deal at all - because it let Ottawa off the hook. But realistically the overwhelmingly negative response is mostly rooted in disappointment based on the reported return for Buffalo - which we don't really know the full scope of the reported deal.
But at the end of the day, it's like finding a $5 bill on the ground and complaining that it's not a $20.