Toggle sidebar

Proposal: TOR - MIN

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
FriendlyGhost92 said:
Why do you continue to cite $8M+/year contracts to compare to your suggestion that Knies sign for $4M/year?

These situations are not remotely similar...
Click to expand...

There are plenty of examples of lower AAV deals, those are just the ones that came to mind. Many of them are dmen, but the point remains. I guess the most recent comparable I can think off the top of my head is Konecny at 5.5
 
HockeyVirus said:
There are plenty of examples of lower AAV deals, those are just the ones that came to mind. Many of them are dmen, but the point remains. I guess the most recent comparable I can think off the top of my head is Konecny at 5.5
Click to expand...
The most recent "Comparable" you can think of was signed almost 6 years ago?

Nevermind that Konecny signed for $1.5M more than you suggested for Knies, for 2 years less than you suggested for Knies, under a salary cap $11M lower than what it was projected to be at the time you made that suggestion.

Konecny's contract is not remotely close to the 8 x $4M you were suggesting for Knies lmao.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KevinRedkey
FriendlyGhost92 said:
The most recent "Comparable" you can think of was signed almost 6 years ago?

Nevermind that Konecny signed for $1.5M more than you suggested for Knies, for 2 years less than you suggested for Knies, under a salary cap $11M lower than what it was projected to be at the time you made that suggestion.

Konecny's contract is not remotely close to the 8 x $4M you were suggesting for Knies lmao.
Click to expand...

Ok. I don't really care that much man. You have your issues with the Leafs so I get it. Just vibing over here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ciao
HockeyVirus said:
Ok. I don't really care that much man. You have your issues with the Leafs so I get it. Just vibing over here.
Click to expand...

I love how you get confronted with a counterpoint and when you can no longer argue the point you retreat to your "You're just a Leaf hater" shield.

For the record, Knies wouldn't sign that contract you suggested with 31 other teams, either. :thumbu:

It's not Leafs hate. You just made a ridiculous and ignorant contract suggestion.
 
Impossible to know how teams really view these players and how they fit into plans 2-3-4 years out. But on the surface, this feels like a deal the Wild would do. Imo
 
not dealing knies

he brings alot of what our other players, especially our other two wingers really don't
 
  • Like
Reactions: Minty Cowboy
Stramel is one of the worst 1st round drafted prospect that I can think of.

He has tanked his value since going R1 in 2023

Knies is ahead of Jiricek who struggled and got moved out once already.

Not interested in this trade
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: MK9 and Ciao
FriendlyGhost92 said:
I love how you get confronted with a counterpoint and when you can no longer argue the point you retreat to your "You're just a Leaf hater" shield.

For the record, Knies wouldn't sign that contract you suggested with 31 other teams, either. :thumbu:

It's not Leafs hate. You just made a ridiculous and ignorant contract suggestion.
Click to expand...
Here it is, and ya he wasn’t doing an 8 year deal at that money. Like most said if that money it’s a bridge.

HockeyVirus

Friedman: Thread 'Leafs and Knies talking extension'

theleafsnation.com

Report: Maple Leafs, Matthew Knies have had conversations about extension

Matthew Knies and the Toronto Maple Leafs have held conversations abou...
theleafsnation.com theleafsnation.com

During an episode of 32 Thoughts the Podcast released Monday, co-host Kyle Bukauskas touched on the fact that Knies wore an ‘A’ during Saturday night’s preseason game against the Montreal Canadiens and asked Friedman why he felt that was significant.

“I’m wondering if they’re going to sign him. I think Knies is on the precipice of being a really long-term, important piece of the Toronto Maple Leafs,” Friedman said. “He’s heading into the last year of his ELC and I think...
Click to expand...
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Wow
 
I think OP is banking heavily on the fact that Knies is established and Jiricek and Stramel aren't, but giving up a C prospect and potential top 4 (maybe top pair) RD prospect like Jiricek for a 50 point winger isn't smart asset management.
 
AKL said:
I think OP is banking heavily on the fact that Knies is established and Jiricek and Stramel aren't, but giving up a C prospect and potential top 4 (maybe top pair) RD prospect like Jiricek for a 50 point winger isn't smart asset management.
Click to expand...
Seems like youre underselling Knies a bit, since hes on pace to have 50+ points and potentially 30 goals in his second season.

Not that hes guaranteed to hit those numbers but "a 50 point winger" is a bit of an understatement when you consider hes 22 and 6'3 230 lbs and gritty.

That's not talking about your prospects at all either, just saying I think you're simplifying the return Minny gets, a tad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Minty Cowboy and chamchibap
AKL said:
I think OP is banking heavily on the fact that Knies is established and Jiricek and Stramel aren't, but giving up a C prospect and potential top 4 (maybe top pair) RD prospect like Jiricek for a 50 point winger isn't smart asset management.
Click to expand...
You can not like the trade but you don't need to downplay Knies to do it. He is 22 years old playing at a 30+ goal pace and 58 points over 82 games with most of the production coming at even strength.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Minty Cowboy and chamchibap
Sundinisagod said:
Won’t comment on value, but Leafs won’t trade Knies for futures, need him for the playoffs.
Click to expand...
Jiricek will probably be in the playoff roster if OP trade goes through. McCabe - Tanev as shutdown pair and Rielly - Jiricek. Jiricek should be better than Timmins or Myers...... Leafs already have Marner, Matthews, Nylander, Tavares etc.... Moving forward asset for defence should be the way to go, let the 4 big worry about offense
 
Situationally I don't think this would be smart for the Wild even if they'd do it in a vacuum. I guess if TOR can count on their other forwards for production they could afford to lose Knies? Certainly wouldn't be a desperation move so I'd think they could afford to shop for a good deal.

Rossi isn't signed, and Ek is developing a worrisome injury history so trading away a good and trending up C prospect might bite us in the future. Not to mention Spurgeon and Brodin on the back end keep getting hurt. Losing a guy we're hoping will be a top four mainstay would be tough too, even with Buium arriving shortly.
 
Hotpot said:
Jiricek will probably be in the playoff roster if OP trade goes through. McCabe - Tanev as shutdown pair and Rielly - Jiricek. Jiricek should be better than Timmins or Myers...... Leafs already have Marner, Matthews, Nylander, Tavares etc.... Moving forward asset for defence should be the way to go, let the 4 big worry about offense
Click to expand...
It’s a nice idea to trade Knies for a rhd with top pairing upside, but in the short term (playoffs specifically), the Leafs would be taking a step back and that’s not the kind of trade they will be making. We already know the core 4 need some support, Tavares is mid 30s and Marner could walk. It could take Jiricek a few more years to hit his stride and by then Matthews contract will be expiring.
 
Sundinisagod said:
It’s a nice idea to trade Knies for a rhd with top pairing upside, but in the short term (playoffs specifically), the Leafs would be taking a step back and that’s not the kind of trade they will be making. We already know the core 4 need some support, Tavares is mid 30s and Marner could walk. It could take Jiricek a few more years to hit his stride and by then Matthews contract will be expiring.
Click to expand...

That's fair, Knies should be an impact playoff performer, but given how weak the Leafs defense is, I think it's possible that Jiricek might have a bigger impact, the Leafs will be playing Timmins, Myers, and Benoit on Friday. Jiricek will improve that and he has a nice shot from the point too, so the Leafs might get more offense from defence. It is higher risk that things won't work out though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sundinisagod
Namikaze Minato said:
Seems like youre underselling Knies a bit, since hes on pace to have 50+ points and potentially 30 goals in his second season.

Not that hes guaranteed to hit those numbers but "a 50 point winger" is a bit of an understatement when you consider hes 22 and 6'3 230 lbs and gritty.

That's not talking about your prospects at all either, just saying I think you're simplifying the return Minny gets, a tad.
Click to expand...
TheBeastCoast said:
You can not like the trade but you don't need to downplay Knies to do it. He is 22 years old playing at a 30+ goal pace and 58 points over 82 games with most of the production coming at even strength.
Click to expand...

I get he's your guy and you feel like I was attacking him or whatever, he's on pace for 53 points this season spending a vast majority of his time with Matthews and Marner, so it's hard for me to feel like I'm short changing him here.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom