You clearly did not watch Marlies games if you thought Marchment was a good player... He was mediocre at his peak. His skating was not going to be anywhere close to good enough for our system.
Good for him for figuring it out in Florida, but that doesn't change the fact that he was a nothing prospect here and Malgin had a lot more potential to turn into something. Which is not too dissimilar to the McKegg-Hyman trade. Or even Douglas-Timmins for that matter. I am guessing you didn't like either of those either, or do you only like the trades that work out? You must love that we got Hunt, since we got the Marchment/McKegg player in the deal this time.
I am making that Marchment-Malgin trade again, just like I would make the McKegg-Hyman and Douglas-Timmins trades again. So far, we are 3/3 in getting guys who can take an everyday shift in the NHL out of those trades, and only one guy we have sent back can say the same... So if, for example, CBJ wanted to do Bemstrom for McMann, I'd do that trade too. Maybe we can go 4/4, and McMann seems like the kind of guy who would thrive in Columbus.