Derailed75
Registered User
I am genuinely curious why one would want to put any top ten list together and limit the parameters to bottom ten teams?
Then start your own poll, with your parameters.I am genuinely curious why one would want to put any top ten list together and limit the parameters to bottom ten teams?
I kinda agree with this one with just 1 modification....I switched 2 and 3....1. Dahlin
.
.
2. Seider
3. Sanderson
4. Chabot
5. P0wer
6. Zub
7. Byram
8. Samuelsson
9. Ch1arot
10. Edvinsson
Buffal0>Ottawa=Detr0it
I wonder based on where Edvinsson was picked if he's Detroit's version of Philip Broberg?Lot mediocre.![]()
Broberg? The odds are better that Edvinsson tops this list in a few years than he becomes Broberg.I wonder based on where Edvinsson was picked if he's Detroit's version of Philip Broberg?![]()
Thing is though that Broberg FINALLY showed how good he is when he basically replaced Vinny Desharnais in the playoffs and played very well. I can't wait to see what he'll bring to the table next year in a full season ! And I think Simon is in the same boat, once he plays a full season, It'll be interesting to see what he can do as he gets better. That's why I compared the two, similar draft spots taken and similar sizes and and similar lack of offensive abilities so far at least and not because I dislike both because I don't !Broberg? The odds are better that Edvinsson tops this list in a few years than he becomes Broberg.
Let me guess.. in a few years the top 3 on this list will be.Broberg? The odds are better that Edvinsson tops this list in a few years than he becomes Broberg.
Nah. ASP'll be better than Hronek, but he won't be better than Mo.Let me guess.. in a few years the top 3 on this list will be.
1. Edvinson
2. Asp
3. Seider
When do you see asp passing him?Nah. ASP'll be better than Hronek, but he won't be better than Mo.
ASP will be coming over to NA next season ('25-'26, or tail end of '24-'25 if Skelleftea doesn't go deep again and repeat SHL titles...). He'll have a nice and cushy spot behind Seider, likely with Edvinsson as his partner (if the Wings keep Edvinsson and Seider apart). So by the end of his ELC.When do you see asp passing him?
I think he is head and shoulders above Chabot, with or without factoring cap hit.
Why not engage directly with an Edvinsson/Broberg comparison instead of jumping to hyperbole?Let me guess.. in a few years the top 3 on this list will be.
1. Edvinson
2. Asp
3. Seider
Not sure why you feel a need to be condescending.Sure, I'll try to respond in a manner that you are capable of comprehending.
Applying your analytical technique, sure sounds like he's regressing. In your own words, what he did prior to this season is irrelevant, no?
Buffalo has by far the best group although Sanderson/Seider are 2/3 in no particular order but Dahlin is the top dog here.Jensen is better than Chiarot… there is a clear top 9, imo, and while Detroit only has Seider in that top 9, they have by far the most guys who can and should rocket up that list (Edvinsson, ASP, Buium, Wallinder, Gibson to a lesser degree, etc)
Seider and Chabot are both guys who have regressed a bit but could benefit massively from some stability.
Personally I like Buffalos group in the short and long term but Detroit and Ottawa should close the gap a bit over time (and both have the potential to build very solid backend groups)
Samuelsson could never really get going - wear and tear from injuries are his main issue. Wouldn’t say he was a train wreck this year or anything. Was a letdown for sure but it’s clear why.My brain almost broke reading that. Chiarot played just below 20 mins a game without PP time, on a better team than Buffalo. Sure he'd play less on a better team, but Samuelsson certainly would too.
Samuelsson, even reading Sabres fans opinions, had a really bad season. Even if you rate his defense highly, is it so good that it outweighs the fact he provides next to zero offense and can't stay healthy?
Samuelsson could never really get going - wear and tear from injuries are his main issue. Wouldn’t say he was a train wreck this year or anything. Was a letdown for sure but it’s clear why.
This.Detroit has a couple of really good young guys who could crack top 5 if we take this poll in 3-4 years but they have to get there and it might take a while.