deadhead
Registered User
- Feb 26, 2014
- 52,268
- 22,734
Gustaffson, TDA and Ghost are similar styles of players, offense first, physically soft defensemen.
Gustaffson was developing into a real defenseman under Q, then fell apart under Colliton, and didn't recover until last season.
TDA was so good offensively he was able to get away with being undisciplined as long as he has a veteran D-man to CYA like Slavin.
Ghost may have chafed, but the best thing to happen to him was Hakstol, who at least taught him a modicum of discipline.
But this is why I scoff at the "new defensemen," being mobile and skilled isn't sufficient to make you a good player, you need to at least be adequate on defense. Sure Makar is a great offensive talent, but he also plays defense, not just goes through the motions b/c his offense could let him get away with it.
Gustaffson was developing into a real defenseman under Q, then fell apart under Colliton, and didn't recover until last season.
TDA was so good offensively he was able to get away with being undisciplined as long as he has a veteran D-man to CYA like Slavin.
Ghost may have chafed, but the best thing to happen to him was Hakstol, who at least taught him a modicum of discipline.
But this is why I scoff at the "new defensemen," being mobile and skilled isn't sufficient to make you a good player, you need to at least be adequate on defense. Sure Makar is a great offensive talent, but he also plays defense, not just goes through the motions b/c his offense could let him get away with it.