Flames fan here. I’m not going to analyze the trade other than to say I can see the logic on both sides. I’m here to give you my impression of Tkachuk as a Flames fan who did not like him and I’ve wanted to see him gone for a couple years.
First he’s a weasel as is widely known. You’re going to find out now how big of a weasel he is. If you like that kind of player you’ll love Matty. If you don’t at some point you’re going to find him to be an embarrassment.
Don’t worry about his skating. It’s not elite but it’s more than adequate, especially since his hockey IQ is for the most part good.
His defensive game is strong. Backlund really helped him develop that being his centre for a few years.
His offensive game is good, but not as great as many think. His 104 point season last year was a product of playing with Gaudreau, Lindholm and Sutter’s coaching. He’s going to need to really click with Barkov or he’s a 60-80 point guy otherwise.
He’s not a playoff player. There‘s certainly the potential for him to develop into one if he changes his attitude.
There’s a misconception around the league he’s a physical player and that he drags his team into the battle. I don’t see him as either. He punks the other team, and when the other team gets to the point they want to push his nose into his face he turtles and his teammates have to stand up for him. It got to the point in Calgary that they quit standing up for him. There‘s been several documented and rumored stories about that.
He’s been called a top 10 winger in the league. He’s not. More like top 20 with the potential to become a top 10 if he gets his stuff together.
He’s not a team player. He’s a selfish prima Donna who doesn’t mesh well with a lot of teammates. I’m not sure if he can change that.
Take my comments as you will. I started off loving him but grew to really dislike him.