At one point I was very optimistic about downtown. There was a real resurgence of downtown areas across Canada from 2000-2015 and I thought Winnipeg could ride that wave. And for a while it looked like we were. But the last decade has killed any positive momentum.
There have been 60+ years of attempts of revitalizing downtown with billions of public dollars spent (think about things like City Hall, the Centennial Concert Hall/Manitoba Museum, Portage Place, The Forks, the Human Rights Museum, Canada Life Centre, Hydro Building, housing subsidies, etc.) , and look what it got us. You could spend another $3 billion trying to improve things but it wouldn't make a difference, new buildings simply won't fix the social problems that are the real issue.
I don't mean to be too negative, I don't think downtown is so bad that people refuse to go to Jets games on account of that. It's just that downtown is so dysfunctional now it doesn't really have any drawing power. Downtown is something you simply have to endure to go to a home game. And that's unfortunate for the Jets and TNSE.
You were right to be optimistic. There was a resurgence downtown, UW and RRC had gone on a building spree, new condos, lofts and hotels opened downtown and on the the river path, landlords in the Exchange had actually gone ahead and leased at reasonable rates to upstart restos and shops and the area was humming.
Then Covid hit. Spending dropped. Neither the city or province seemed minded to support downtown biz or residents. Ever larger housing estates opened elsewhere in the city and offered more living space and newer roads and schools -- it wasn't the developers who paid for those schools -- and why live or work or relax downtown when nothing was open past midnight and you had to pay for parking and there were people sleeping rough and when was the last time you actually saw a police officer not in a car making sure all was well there?
It's mostly the same all over. We have family elsewhere in NA and Europe and live in London and travel round the UK to see family friends and... it's mostly the same all over. Try walking down any major artery in central London, the West End, Oxford Street, and you'll find a rough sleeper in many doorways and most ATM machines. TO has hundreds sleeping rough in parks in any weather but dead of winter, and in my first week in Montreal as a student I found a dead man frozen on a bench on Rue St Catherine. There are too many who need help and not enough help available, and nearly no longterm help, and the police want some relief from what they call "mental health" cases because they take up a huge amount of time and effort and there's no end.
When I was at HSC a decent percentage of daily intake were folks we would see again and again, and who we could not help beyond a patch up and who there was not enopugh help for elsewhere. If they wanted to be there it was because it was warmer and there was someone to briefly help out. Briefly.
In the UK laws are being passed that, among other things, will allow arrest and removal for producing "an offensive odour," so living for any length of time as an unhoused person / rough sleeper. Where will the estimated 300,000 go who can be arrested for this?
It's a problem. No one wants to be accosted time and time again by aggressive panhandlers or witness some of the altercations or violence or desperation and stark need we too often see in downtowns. But it isn't going to disappear or be removed elsewhere without concerted effort by the levels of government and social services, including police and mental health supports and housing and food banks and people to support those and will and good faith.
It isn't really about choice, though choice may play a part in it. It's about issues that can only be solved by group action. So maybe tying these issues into the survival of a hockey club and the need to remake a downtown isn't such a bad thing, because something may actually get done that works. IMO.