Toggle sidebar

Value of: Thomas Chabot to MTL

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
50 in 07 said:
Take off the homer glasses. Chabot and Sergachev are close in value, I wouldn't argue if you said that Sergachev was worth more. But the way you're making it out to be is just asinine. They're both blue chip defensive prospects, in the same stratosphere. It's not like we're comparing Hammond to Price here.
Click to expand...

Sergechev is worth alot more, plz take off urs before telling others to do so.
 
SenzZen said:
I believe people conceded that Sergachev is the better prospect- but not to the extent that we'd make a deal within the division.

"Massive overpayment" not clear enough for you?
Click to expand...

Trading within the division?? How does Chabot qualify for that :laugh:
 
Legend123 said:
I doubt any team should be concerned with trading within the division when the players involved are chabot. If u think otherwise :help:
Click to expand...

Oh I see now.

You're pissed off at Ottawa fans because a Montreal fan asked what it would take to get Chabot.

Glad we're done here.
 
SenzZen said:
Oh I see now.

You're pissed off at Ottawa fans because a Montreal fan asked what it would take to get Chabot.

Glad we're done here.
Click to expand...

so me saying Chabot wouldnt be a concerned over a trade within divisions suggest that?? What the?? He isnt a Matthews (A+prospect), Eichel (young Promising player) or Crosby(superstar) type of players.
 
Legend123 said:
Cuz u try to make it look chabot is worth anywhere close to Sergechev who has #1 D all over him.
Click to expand...

Again, no one cares what you perceive his value to be, Chabot is a massive piece for Ottawa and the only way you get him is to overpay.
 
Unbiasedd said:
Well I guess Varone is a NHL star if preseason is what a player truly is. Keep clinging to that, Chabot hasnt played at his best yet is still more effective than McCarron. Shows how much of a prospect McCarron is. You keep trying to dance around the fact Chabot is miles better than McCarron with comments about his preseason. I never knew two games makes your career.
Click to expand...

Im pretty sure u need to show something at the higher levels, no? He was bad vs the AHL Habs, that leaves me to question whether he's even ready for the AHL.
Chabot isnt miles ahead better, he might be better but the Habs prob would rather keep McCarron cuz Chabot aint better than what they currently have.
 
As a Sens fan,

Nothing of Montreal interests me other than Serge for Chabot.

I personally think Serge will end up a better d-man from what I have seen. That said, Chabot still projects to be a top two d-man.

I don't think there is any realistic deal between the teams. Ottawa needs a Top 2/4 LD. Chabot will be that. End of story.
 
Legend123 said:
so hes untouchable? Im curious how he went from a mid first prospect to a cant miss one. Anyways, I see you guys think hes the next Bobby Orr, I guess im done here:nod:
Click to expand...

Let's recap what's happened in this thread. So far, you've insinuated or straight up said that:

- Sergachev is way, way, way better than Chabot and they aren't in the same stratosphere
-McCarron is better than Chabot, and worth more in a one for one trade
-Chabot will never achieve the level of play that Beaulieu has, in his entire career
-The previous three assertions are based on the Sens/Habs pre season game
-Trading Chabot within division shouldn't matter because he isn't a "A+ prospect" (Matthews), "young promising player" (Eichel), or "superstar" (Crosby)
-Chabot isn't an integral piece of Ottawa's future
-Sens fans think Chabot is the next Bobby Orr

Is that enough reasons for people to stop reading anything you post from here out?

:laugh:
 
Lmao how is this thread still open, it's just the one side arguing Chabot sucks and Sens fans stating (correctly) that he's 19, developing, fills a future need, and isnt available barring an overpayment.

Shoulda been closed 2 pages ago

Edit: as a neutral fan I'd take Chabot over any Habs prospect other than Serge.
 
Skiffer55 said:
Lmao how is this thread still open, it's just the one side arguing Chabot sucks and Sens fans stating (correctly) that he's 19, developing, fills a future need, and isnt available barring an overpayment.

Shoulda been closed 2 pages ago

Edit: as a neutral fan I'd take Chabot over any Habs prospect other than Serge.
Click to expand...

Look you're from Ottawa therefore you are clearly a Senators fan. Get real and if you want to trade Chabot the price from Montreal is a 5th rounder. Take it and leave.
 
Legend123 said:
'A MCCarron' is a pretty good player. Better than Chabot, get real sens fan. Im not just a habs fan. Im also a caps and Jackets fan and I know Chabot wouldnt be worth much in all 3 of those teams.
Click to expand...
Ill offer a 4th for him ,then you can reject it and then ill tell you how he would be outclassed by our forward prospects like White and Brown .:nod:
 
Legend123 said:
'A MCCarron' is a pretty good player. Better than Chabot, get real sens fan. Im not just a habs fan. Im also a caps and Jackets fan and I know Chabot wouldnt be worth much in all 3 of those teams.
Click to expand...

I find it hard to believe you're a fan of anyone but Montreal because your Habs bias is so clearly evident in all your posts.
 
Has it not been mentioned that Chabot came 2nd in the Q for top D, while missing 20 more games than his competition?

Or that he had 66 points in 64 games (including 21 in 17 playoff games)?

Sergachev is the better D, I have no qualms with that. I'd kill to have him in a Sens uniform. To use Sergachev winning top D as a reason why he's a better prospect is suspect, at best.

He was drafted as a riser at 18th (just for the one specific poster who ignorantly is judging him based on his draft position), and he continued that rise throughout the season.

Last year, he:
- Was the only 18 year old D on the WJ team
- Played a top 2 role on said WJ team
- Set a career high in points, with 45 (in 19 less games played than his previous high)
- 2nd in the QMJHL playoffs in points for a D, with 21 in17 games played (1 less point in 4 less games than the leader)
- Was the best player on his junior team, which featured ~10 NHL drafted players (Not quantifiable, just obvious to those who follow the Sea Dogs)

So, if Chabot is only worthy of his 18th overall selection while progressing at a very high level since being drafted, can you please explain to me what McCarron has done in his 3 years since being drafted that justifies him being a better prospect, and worthy of moving up from his 25th overall selection (in a MUCH weaker draft) while Chabot is still "just a mid round prospect"?

I can't believe some actually rank Chabot below Juulsen....

Don't worry Hab fans, I know this fella doesn't represent your line of thinking.
 
Last edited:
This thread got me thinking how Les Canadiens have basically no French-Canadian players except for Desharnais, and no top-end Franco prospects.

Whereas the Sens have Brassard, Pageau, Methot, as well as Chabot as top prospect.

How is it being received in Montreal that there are basically no local players?

Interestingly, this year, Karlsson might be the only European on the Sens.

As far as Chabot, Sens fans feel about him how Habs fans feel about Sergachev. That would be the price. Either that or Pateryn, Andrighetto, Tokarski and a 3rd.
 
zenator said:
This thread got me thinking how Les Canadiens have basically no French-Canadian players except for Desharnais, and no top-end Franco prospects.

Whereas the Sens have Brassard, Pageau, Methot, as well as Chabot as top prospect.

How is it being received in Montreal that there are basically no local players?

Interestingly, this year, Karlsson might be the only European on the Sens.

As far as Chabot, Sens fans feel about him how Habs fans feel about Sergachev. That would be the price. Either that or Pateryn, Andrighetto, Tokarski and a 3rd.
Click to expand...

The Sens literally don't need, or even remotely want anything, in that package, all due respect to Andrighetto
 
Considering Montreal doesn't know how to value elite Dman Ottawa would just rob this current GM in a trade.

We could of gotten PK for Dion Phaneuf that's how bad this GM is
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom