OT: The Pittsburgher Thread: Ploff wins?!? Fire Tomlin

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
IMG_2994.webp
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Jiggyfly
If they're trading Pickens, they basically need to sign Adams and draft a WR in round 1. Trading him without that level of investment in their WRs would be unacceptable.

I'd accept Adams and a WR2 type in FA. Don't like getting tied to WR in this draft.
 
Nah that's not enough of a long-term addition for the WR group. Adams is purely a 1 or 2 year guy and they simply need to draft their next #1 WR as soon as possible.

You could still draft one in that scenario if the player makes sense. You don’t want an Artie Burns scenario though where you’re dead set on taking a position no matter what.
 
If you have some losing seasons, it’s not the end of the world.

The last time this org had a losing season, they ended up with a franchise QB.

Ya it’s not always going to work out that way, but being mediocre in perpetuity gets this org nowhere.

They aren’t even good at being mediocre - because Tomlin Purgatory means annual playoff embarrassments that set new franchise records of ineptitude.

This org will be stuck in the mud as long as Tomlin is here - because you can’t have the guy that broke things, be the fixer - it’s illogical.

He gave up on KP after just two years, only to bring in retreads that put this org back in the exact same spot.

What concerns me is either he badly
missed evaluating KP or he blew the development side.

He had a massive advantage of seeing KP every day for five years in the same practice facility, and still somehow blew the pick

I’m not a big Fields guy, at all, but he then followed the same playbook with him as well.

Is this really a guy you can trust to evaluate, draft and develop a franchise QB ala Harbaugh with Flacco/Jackson?

Put another way, how badly would he have botched the development of Jackson, had they drafted him?
I couldn't have said this better myself without repeating what you wrote.
 


And DJ had quite the season.

Traded to Panthers.

Traded to Ravens.

Waived by Ravens.

Went to Texans.

Waived by Texans.

Claimed by Ravens, but ineligible to play rest of the playoffs.

His only real value this season was being claimed so Ravens could get a comp pick.

That’s some AB shit right there.

When is the last time the Steelers didn’t have a head case at receiver?

Ward?
 
Nah that's not enough of a long-term addition for the WR group. Adams is purely a 1 or 2 year guy and they simply need to draft their next #1 WR as soon as possible.

Right, but I don't want to get tied into looking for that long term WR1 in this draft. I look at the draft profiles and think the chance that they'd end up taking a subpar guy because they had to take someone is unacceptably high, and that in doing so they might walk away from a better player who also fits a long term need (particularly DL).

Hell, long term, no team should get tied to "we need this position in the first round" unless it's an extremely strong draft if they can help it.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad