Mr Misunderstood
Must win.
I agree. As a Ravens fan, I'm biased, but his stats are pretty impressive.
He's 90.57%, tops all-time. He's 98.1% on kicks under 40yds. He's clutch - nailing 50 straight 4th quarter kicks, including 16 for 16 in the last minute of a game.
Dude's been money.
47 yarder in 2nd OT in Mile High during that Super Bowl run
2/2 in the Super Bowl
Of course Vinatieri has been in more clutch situations, but I'd take Tucker