I agree, they would be foolish to pass on Marner so would any team picking prior to the Devils.
Similarly the Devils would be foolish to pass on Hanifin and the Ivan if they are on the board.
Prospect Info: The 2015 NHL Draft Thread VII
- Thread starter Emperoreddy
- Start date
- Status
I agree, they would be foolish to pass on Marner so would any team picking prior to the Devils.
Similarly the Devils would be foolish to pass on Hanifin and the Ivan if they are on the board.
Emperoreddy
Show Me What You Got!
It could still happen though. Carolina might be higher on a top D or a big winger like Crouse.
It seems unlikely to us but we don't know what teams big boards look like.
Exactly! Then add a dman of everyones choice (Merr/Gelly-But how bout Helg+) to get Yak
That is an interesting proposition. Just looking at it from an Edmonton perspective, they could play Draisaitl at wing if it got too crowded down the middle. They overpaid Benoit Pouliot since their LW depth was thin. Draisaitl is AHL eligible this season and he might benefit from a full season there.
Their previous braintrust seemed to think that adding an 18 year old defender wasn't the answer to their blueline issues. But Chiarelli could add to their D on top of (hypothetically) Provorov.
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
I think trading 6 overall would be a little bit unorthodox, especially if the return is another prospect.
But if it were a prospect and rostered player, in the deepest draft in years?
Definitely would be unusual. The only recent example I can think of is Ottawa trading their pick in 2010 for David Rundblad who was drafted in 2009.
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
I still would not trade it. I believe in drafting and developing.
The Senators were lucky to get Turris in Rundblad's subsequent trade, but consequently they lost Tarasenko. I think this provides evidence that it is easier to simply keep the pick.
Burner Account
Registered User
- Feb 14, 2008
- 37,418
- 1,744
You can't blanket-think like that, though. Different situations require different decisions.
If Lou doesn't trade #9 for Schneider, who is the Devils' starting goalie? We don't know. But what we do know is that the Devils have a top-10 goalie in the league because they traded the pick. Would you rather have a top-10 goalie or Bo Horvat?
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
You are right. Schneider became available at the right time. In the current situation, the seemingly available players are Kessel and O'Reilly, both of which come with a degree of uncertainty and risk.
I do still think that 6 overall is more valuable to us than Kessel or O'Reilly.
Russian Factor was in play for Ottawa. If I recall correctly, they had been targeting Jaden Schwartz but got sniped by St. Louis. At the time, they simply liked Rundblad more than whoever was left; BPAs (not including Tarasenko) according to TSN's list were Austin Watson, Emerson Etem, and Beau Bennett.
Ray Shero faced a similar situation when he first took over the Pens in 2006. He had the #2 pick and Carolina was offering Jack Johnson who was picked #3 the year before. Shero kept the pick, but gave it some serious thought and called a couple other GMs for advice.
I'd be curious to see who they had in mind before winning the lotto. What were they 3, 4? They may already have been targeting one of those defenseman at that spot to begin with.
I just see so many trade down options if we don't get a Marner/Strome, why not target a guy like Draisaitl (even if we add another piece), who I think would be a unanimous yes over Barzal, Zacha, Rantanen etc.
I believe the Blues traded Rundblad to Ottawa for their pick the following season at the same spot. Who was it? Tarasenko!
Devils Dominion
Now we Plummet
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
If we are looking for offense at that pick, he is not the guy. 45 in 66 games.
If we are looking for the BPA, my guess is there will be a few fallers available better than him.
I would take him with our third rounder if he falls.
Senyshyn is a guy who might go higher than expected. Seemed like he didn't get a ton of PP time as the Greyhounds loaded up and picked up Nick Ritchie and Justin Bailey. The one thing I like is that 23 of his 26 goals were at even strength. By comparison, Marner had 29 even strength goals and Max Domi had 20. Lawson Crouse had 22. Michael Dal Colle had 26.
Seems like a safe bet for Senyshyn to put up better numbers next year when Ritchie/Bailey turn pro. Kyle Dubas was the former GM for the Greyhounds and he's now working for Toronto. I'd be curious to see if Toronto tries to get back into the 2nd round to take Senyshyn.
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
It's amazing that he ranks up there with names like that! I wouldn't mind drafting him in the second with this knowledge.
Devils Dominion
Now we Plummet
He's got good speed and size too.
A scout quoted in Hockey News thinks he will be a steal in the second round.
Cheddabombs
Status Quo
- Mar 13, 2012
- 25,082
- 33,196
I'd love Looke with our 2nd round pick, if he's still there. Especially if we draft a center with our 1st.
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
That stat is also interesting since Lawson Crouse is on there. I guess he would have a better stat line with a more productive PP. In my opinion he still is a certain possibility for us at 6.
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
I think there is a good chance he is available. When you look at the NA and EU rankings from Central scouting there are essentially 37 players that could go in the first round, which means we have a pretty good shot at getting essentially 2 first round prospects or even 3 if we are lucky.
http://www.eliteprospects.com/draftcenter.php?year=2015&layout=&ranking=Rank7&con=NA
http://www.eliteprospects.com/draftcenter.php?year=2015&layout=&ranking=Rank7&con=EU
R8Devs
1-5-6-12
I like Guryanov with our 2nd pick(possible trade up). Denis Malgin had 7 points in 6 games playing for Switzerland in the U20 WJC as a 17 year old(although a good amount came from playing against Germany--still impressive nonetheless), he's small but I wouldn't mind him with a 3rd round pick or later.
I think Timoshov would be a possible good late round pick as well(risk but it's a late round pick anyway odds are they are not making the NHL so why not try to pick a guy if he does make it will be as a top 6 forward).
I think Timoshov would be a possible good late round pick as well(risk but it's a late round pick anyway odds are they are not making the NHL so why not try to pick a guy if he does make it will be as a top 6 forward).
Marshal Rochambeau
Send it
Guryanov has first round talent and can drop due to the Russian factor. He would be such a steal at 36.
thethinglonger
Castron & Crew
Maple Leafs apparently have hired Lindsay Hofford, scouting director for the London Knights...looks like Marner doesn't drop past 4th overall
Devils1029
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2008
- 2,988
- 2
So, if Arizona takes Strome, the it goes Marner to TOR and Hanifin to CAR,
if Arizona takes Hanifin, TOR takes Strome then Marner possibly gets past CAR to NJ
If Arizona takes Hanifin and TOR takes Marner, does Carolina take Strome, Crouse, or Provorov
Or..we can just not care and go ahead and pick Barzal at #6 and go home happy.
If strome happens to drop to #6, Conte better run up to that podeum before Carolina changes their minds....
- Status
