I agree with you right up until the playoffs started. Tynan has been locked in for the postseason. 3rd in save %, second in GAA, and CHL goalie if the week. You can see the difference in his play.
If we had any chance of contending next season, I would never contemplate this deal. Only suggested it because you seem desperate for a goalie and McCallum seems to have been passed by some on the depth chart, and we have room for a vet forward.
If he was performing at expectations for a late first rounder in his 3rd season (~.8 pts/gm) then I would expect the deal would look more like Tynan + 3rd + conditional 3rd. However, he isn't, so there wouldn't be conditionals because he is undrafted. Tynan + 2 2nds is a non starter. If he was that valuable then Sudbury would never trade him in a season where they are looking to take a big step forward.
Anyway, thanks to everyone who responded. It was great for a few laughs.