Again, being a hall of fame hockey player does not make you knowledgeable when it comes to running an entire organization.
I don't automatically assume anything about Robitaille. I have been around at various events and talked one on one with people in the Kings organization in the past. My impression is they don't think Robitaille is very capable. Blake is smart, Robitaille isn't. Like it or not this is what people in the organization believe to be true.
Let me put forward a hypothesis which based on conversations and observations I believe to be true. Kopitar's agent comes in asking for 8 years, $80M with much of it paid in the early years of the contract and a NTC. Dean says the two sides aren't even in the same ballpark. This happens in September of 2015.
Lombardi: Kings, Kopitar not close in talks - LA Kings Insider
Kings, Kopitar ‘not even in the ballpark’ on new contract
Contract talks stall for some time. Robitaille gets involved. Instead of thinking what would be best from the organization's perspective, he approaches it from the standpoint of what he believes he would be asking for if he was in Kopitar's position, and viola it's a done deal, Kopitar gets his asking price. Also at the same time Robitaille goes to Uncle Phil and starts whispering in his ear about how Dean is ready to trade or let Kopitar walk and playing hardball with Kopitar is a mistake.
I don't say this because I have heard it. I am not plugged in like the mayor. I say it, because when I say it to people in the organization, they go quiet and kind of shrug and give you that head tilt you get when you are on the right track, but they don't want to say it.
Then in mid-January of 2016, Kopitar gets exactly what he was seeking.
Kings C Kopitar agrees to eight-year extension
Do any of you really believe Dean Lombardi went from saying "not even in the same ballpark" to let's give Kopitar exactly what he wants in 4 months? Not a chance. The Kopitar contract has Robitaille's finger prints all over it.
The Richards gaffe was the beginning of the end for Dean Lombardi, but Dean is keen on critical self evaluation. He had already said he wasn't going to make that kind of mistake again, and was going to start treating his players more like assets. Use logic here and I think you will draw the same conclusion I have reached.
If this hypothesis is correct, and I believe it is, does it give you confidence in Robitaille's brillance as a leader of an entire NHL organization?
I really hope Dean Lombardi writes that book someday.