Trading this many picks away in a short time when you already have a crappy prospect pool is all but guaranteeing a mediocre at best future for this organization. Whether or not we win a Cup with MSL won't change that, it will just make it way easier to swallow. What do you think its going to happen? We're going to magically have a a great farm system by trading away our draft picks? It's selling the future to win now. If that's fine with you, cool, but don't act like that's not what's happening.
The fact that draft picks are no guarantees is exactly why you need a lot of them.
Um, I do?
I understand where you're coming from. But where exactly is this team falling apart any time soon? We have a really young team overall. On D: Moore (23), McD (24), Stralman and Staal (27), Klein and G (29). Are we in desperate need of D in the next 3-5 years beyond maybe needing 1 or 2 new guys? On forward: Kreider (22), Steps (23), Hags (25), Brass and Zucc (26), Pouliot and Dorsett (27), Carcillo, Boyle, Nash (29), Moore and Richards (33), MSL (38). Talbot (26) and Hank (32).
We have a pretty young team overall that is a playoff team year in, year out. You look at that and have to decide which direction to go. You cannot do ten things at once: you can't rebuild and at the same time say, we have Hank at 32, let's try to win now while he's still fairly useful. Which way do you want to go? We're not Pitt, we didn't trade away our roster and then have a lottery ball hand us a generational player on top of it. We didn't have eons of dreadful seasons and stock pile top ten picks like a few teams out there have, some of them having little to no viable success with that I might add.
At the end of the day, you have to look at what you have, decide on a direction to go with it, and do so within the reality that 29 other teams are going to be fighting and clawing to do the same.
IMHO... the team needs to be built to try to win now-ish. We have a hall of fame caliber goalie who is locked up long term and doesn't have forever to have a good team built around him. If we were Buffalo or an older team, heck yes the picks are vital. But we are a perennial playoff team, so adding pieces that really strengthen and improve your team seem like the way to go. And MSL makes any team in this league a better team.
It is not just St Louis' top-end scoring, it is also his top-tier work ethic, his winning attitude, how he makes people around him better, and how all these things cannot help but rub off on everyone around him. This guy is going to ooze into the psyche's of younger players and drill into them great things for seasons to come. The kind of guy that, when Stamkos goes down long term, keeps his team winning and somehow keeps squeezing success out of himself and his teammates, and still stays atop the league scoring leaders even without Stamkos in the lineup.
St Louis is 38 and has a window of effective time, obviously. But we didn't pick up some washed up vet here. He is still, right now, one of the best scorers in the league and much better than anyone on this team. He is also probably in as good or better shape than anyone on the team.
Was this ideal? Who knows? I guess hindsight will let us know at some point. But what is a fact is that we were losing Callahan one way or the next, and even offering him 6 mil was something I felt highly troubled by. In the end, we dropped a few picks to secure one of the top scorers in the league, who is on an incredibly nice contract, with the major risk being a few picks that statistically probably don't amount to much. Our team got better. And however far we may or may not have been from true contender status, St Louis bridges that gap and brings us closer than we were without him. I'm very okay with it and I did my best to try to explain why.