Garl
Registered User
- Oct 7, 2006
- 8,127
- 1,079
Panarin, Kaprizov, KuzmenkoNHLe is very worthless. It just doesn't matter, as it's all very role dependent. Michkov would likely play top line top powerplay on about half of KHL teams and have good production, if he was playing in the AHL for a farm team of an NHL team that controlled his development, he'd certainly be on the top line as well, but the SKA situation is what it is and he's like a 13th forward. Assuming players are rapidly shooting down depth charts when they go KHL to NHL and rapidly shooting up depth charts when they go NHL to KHL (think Galchenyuk) only tells you so much of the picture, other than "yes, every top top player in the world is in the NHL" which a chart doesn't need to tell you. If you look at the rare situations where players go from top line KHL (think the late-ish breakouts that then subsequently come to the NHL in their early to mid 20s) to top line NHL you get seldom many examples but like Panarin 2015 -> 2016, Kaprizov 2020 -> 2021, Kuzmenko 2022 -> 2023, we see less dramatic effects on production than an NHLe would suggest. Likewise the other way in the rare instances of top line NHL player bolting for KHL like Kovalchuk, not all of a sudden putting up 2 PPG or whatever in the KHL. Again though, that's a while ago as that doesn't happen seldom ever.
With the AHL, players are often groomed for the roles that they will play in the NHL, but the AHL is a developmental league so that makes sense. If you think a guy is a future top liner, he plays top line in the AHL and depending on where the team is at in their cycle, they'll get a similar opportunity in the NHL (Lukas Reichel on the Blackhawks is similar), whereas your bottom 6 prospects tend to also be bottom 6-ish in the AHL, and the AHL veterans on your roster can plug and play as necessary to support the ones viewed as legitimate NHL prospects in their development.
You forgot some other superstars
Shipachyov, Tkachyov, Gusev, Grigorenko, Plotnikov, Semyonov