Rumor: Rumors & Proposals Thread | Y'all Got Any Good Goalies?

North

Registered User
Jun 25, 2009
16,308
14,602
I didn’t think that was overly harsh compared to the drive by gotcha attempt, but if that wasn’t how you meant it, then I apologize



That’s certainly a fair criticism. But that’s also pretty similar to how people were talking about Nurse just last year. I’d just rather target a guy who has the size and skill but struggles to consistently put it together over waiting a picking up a plug with limited upside
That isn’t the way I meant it and I appreciate the apology.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDoused

Pip

Registered User
Feb 2, 2012
69,613
9,260
Granduland
Can't argue with the numbers, he's obviously an elite goalie in this League. With stats like his, he'll be amongst the most expensive assets on the market. And with stats like his, he'll test free agency and get paid. It would be a pure rental for us.
I agree it would be a pure rental and I wouldn’t want to pay a lot but if you’re going to get a goalie I think he’s the guy. A lot of the names I see thrown around I don’t think are clearly better than Pickard
 

MessierII

Registered User
Aug 10, 2011
28,791
18,349
he is the one guy we lost that we have not moaned about
Vinny was solid here but he’s a 1 million dollar guy. I was a fan but I completely support the decision to walk.

Any interest in bringing back Nick Bjugstad ? I think him and Henrique would be great bottom six centers.
Not really honestly. We have a wealth of forwards I really don’t understand wanting to add anything there honestly.
 

TheGingaNinja

Edmonton Ex-Pat who still loves his hometown team.
Sep 26, 2019
276
683
Ottawa
I agree it would be a pure rental and I wouldn’t want to pay a lot but if you’re going to get a goalie I think he’s the guy. A lot of the names I see thrown around I don’t think are clearly better than Pickard
I'm not all that convinced with his decent numbers, and excellent contract, that he would be all that cheap to acquire unfortunately.
 

Pip

Registered User
Feb 2, 2012
69,613
9,260
Granduland
I'm not all that convinced with his decent numbers, and excellent contract, that he would be all that cheap to acquire unfortunately.
I’m honesty unsure. I think goalie markets are fickle and it’ll depend who else is looking for a goalie (Carolina?). If there isn’t much of a market and they don’t think they will re-sign him then maybe there’s an opportunity there.
 

TheGingaNinja

Edmonton Ex-Pat who still loves his hometown team.
Sep 26, 2019
276
683
Ottawa
I’m honesty unsure. I think goalie markets are fickle and it’ll depend who else is looking for a goalie (Carolina?). If there isn’t much of a market and they don’t think they will re-sign him then maybe there’s an opportunity there.
Would love for you to be right as he would quite an upgrade over Pickard I think. Just not sure if they would even want to trade him unless it was for a pretty solid return. Guess we will see.

FWIW, he would be my choice too.
 

Scrapin Ice

Registered User
Oct 25, 2024
374
125
Fabbro goes out of position during the play on Killorn's first goal and is on the ice trying to clear the front of the net but screens his goalie on the next goal.
Provorov loses position and is caught flat footed on kilorn OT winner.

Thats mistakes two games running for Dante. All this pining on here about him. He will end up being what he has always been and the Reason Trotz gave up on him. He would not have been my choice either. Dante has always looked a little lost defensively.
Columbus should capitalize while they can and send him to Vancouver.
 
Last edited:

Arpeggio

Registered User
Jul 20, 2006
9,300
4,060
Edmonton
I’m starting to think the best move might be to trade for the best centre you can get. I’m sure it will be a replacement for Stecher, but imagine adding another top six centre to the mix using this years second and a first, and bumping Ryan out of the lineup. The forward group would be absolutely stacked.
 

5 14 6 1

We are the 11.5%
Sep 15, 2010
15,059
17,686
Alberta
I’m starting to think the best move might be to trade for the best centre you can get. I’m sure it will be a replacement for Stecher, but imagine adding another top six centre to the mix using this years second and a first, and bumping Ryan out of the lineup. The forward group would be absolutely stacked.

My wish there would be Brock Nelson if the Isles are out of it
 

Markham30

Registered User
Jan 12, 2016
648
925
Edmonton
I’m starting to think the best move might be to trade for the best centre you can get. I’m sure it will be a replacement for Stecher, but imagine adding another top six centre to the mix using this years second and a first, and bumping Ryan out of the lineup. The forward group would be absolutely stacked.
I’m sorry, but what? You have Mcdavid, Drai, RNH, Henrique, not including Ryan. It’s nice to have depth, but why in the world would you use another 1st and 2nd to upgrade centre?

Defence, specifically RHD should be the top priority. Shut down RHD being more would be preferred. We do not need another “top 6 centre” unless we come across longterm injuries. It’d a waste of draft capital and a waste of cap space. Neither of which we can afford to lose.

Trade for a RHD with cap friendly term. Or an upgrade in goal, if the right deal comes along. Bad take.
 

TheNumber4

Registered User
Nov 11, 2011
46,214
57,540
I’m starting to think the best move might be to trade for the best centre you can get. I’m sure it will be a replacement for Stecher, but imagine adding another top six centre to the mix using this years second and a first, and bumping Ryan out of the lineup. The forward group would be absolutely stacked.
Oh now you've gone and triggered me.....

HoW mAnY cEnteRs dOes oNe tEaM nEed!? 6 CeNteRs!? 8 CeNteRs!? 12 CeNteRs!? wHeN wILl it StoP!? Heck thRoW a CeNter iN nEt toO!! And beHind tHe bEnCh aS coAch! The EqUipMenT gUy cAn bE center toO!!!!! EVERYONE IS CENTER!!!!! AHHHHHH


(lol sorry just jokes, but I would consider a Ryan replacement, however I don't think we should pay up big for it).
 

BarDownBobo

Registered User
Oct 19, 2012
6,591
3,474
City of Champions
He has a no movement clause lol. He can't be traded unless he wants to and I don't see any reason he would want to.
Earlier in the year I was of the opinion that a Skinner trade had zero chance of happening. But as the seasons gone on I’ve had a bit of a change of opinion. All the NMC means is he’s got full control over any move that could potentially happen. There’s definitely a chance he could just decide he’s riding it out here to break his playoff drought like he came here to do. But if he continues to struggle to adapt to the lineup here and hover around 12-13 minutes a night, maybe even less as the team gets healthier, he might be open to a move to a bubble team looking for a goal scoring punch in their top 6. Because if it gets to the point where he’s playing sub 10 minutes down the stretch and even potentially getting healthy scratched come playoff time it’s going to put him in a pretty brutal place for finding a new team to pay him anything worthwhile next summer. He might take a 20 game tryout getting way more ice time to put some more positive film out there.

That said, I do feel like he’s coming on the last few weeks and has been playing better so hopefully that continues and it’s a non issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burnt Biscuits

jukon

NHL Point Leader
Mar 17, 2011
3,591
2,266
There is absolutely zero chance that we make a trade before the TDL. They will wait until deadline day. If they didn't panic and pull the trigger when we had a bad start, no way they will when we are a top 10 team.
 

Mcnotloilersfan

I'm here, I'm bored
Jul 11, 2010
11,355
5,633
Niagara
I’m starting to think the best move might be to trade for the best centre you can get. I’m sure it will be a replacement for Stecher, but imagine adding another top six centre to the mix using this years second and a first, and bumping Ryan out of the lineup. The forward group would be absolutely stacked.
For C at this point, Id rather find a really good 2-way bottom 6 C that's a big upgrade on Ryan. I do think for a long playoff run, that, along with the top 4 We keep hearing about it, will go a long way
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad