Rumor: Rumors & Proposals Thread: “I’d buy that for a dollar!!!” Edition

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think the point here is...there is rumored to only be...Dumba, Walker and a long list of guys worse than Ceci actually available. Dumba, is NOT an improvement on Ceci. And analytically Walker is, but there is a good chance he will either be stupid expensive, or not move at all.
Like would you pay Ceci, 1st for Walker? I don't think I would.
Maybe I’m being naive but I just don’t think walker goes for that.

Tanev is clearly better and didnt get a first. Id definitely do a 2+ for Walker

I do agree about Dumba being a not want.

Still also hoping Carrier may shake lose, even with the preds being in a playoff spot
 
  • Like
Reactions: CycloneSweep
Carrier, Walker (is an UPGRADE), Chychrun (even as a LHD), Jensen, TVR (on the low end). etc.

You have been spiraling for a while now. Assuming the team will somehow trade for Jarred Smithson and Brandon Manning, and they slap themselves on the back.

Chill the f*** out. Let things Actually happen, before you declare everything a f***ing failure.
I don’t think Walker or Carrier have separated themselves enough or have the track record to be able to definitively say they are upgrades on Ceci. I’d say chances are good they would be especially given how Ceci has played lately but it’s a bit of a toss up.

Jensen definitely would of been but he’s showing his age a bit this year and hasn’t been the same as he was the last few years playing with Orlov. He’s got another 2 years after this one too.

Provorov is a guy they should try and pull out of Columbus, he’d be a solid addition to the top 4. He’s a lefty but has played on the right before. Not ideal but he’s better then anyone else being floated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Canovin
I don’t think Walker or Carrier have separated themselves enough or have the track record to be able to definitively say they are upgrades on Ceci. I’d say chances are good they would be especially given how Ceci has played lately but it’s a bit of a toss up.

Jensen definitely would of been but he’s showing his age a bit this year and hasn’t been the same as he was the last few years playing with Orlov. He’s got another 2 years after this one too.

Provorov is a guy they should try and pull out of Columbus, he’d be a solid addition to the top 4. He’s a lefty but has played on the right before. Not ideal but he’s better then anyone else being floated.
We don't have the cap space for Provorov. Columbus won't be retaining 50% with an extra year. But I agree with most of the things you said.

Walker/Carrier isn't an upgrade on Ceci as much as people keep telling themselves. They bring something different to the Oilers.
 
Not an expert on the player but that contract for Seeler doesn't look justifiable.

I don't think Desharnais will be playing for the Oilers next year.
This is why it was stupid to keep Ceci/Kulak/Foegele in the summer and sacrificing singing Bouchard long term. Paycheques for DMen go up exponentially
 
This is why it was stupid to keep Ceci/Kulak/Foegele in the summer and sacrificing singing Bouchard long term. Paycheques for DMen go up exponentially
:facepalm: You know that doesn't mean things can't be adjusted in THIS offseason. Also, teams lose bottom of the roster most offseasons.

I'm a massive fan of Desharnais, but this team doesn't need to overpay him.
 
We don't have the cap space for Provorov. Columbus won't be retaining 50% with an extra year. But I agree with most of the things you said.

Walker/Carrier isn't an upgrade on Ceci as much as people keep telling themselves. They bring something different to the Oilers.
Ceci would likely be moved out in another trade.

Difference between Provorov and Ceci is 1.5M, they could fit him in pretty easily with Ceci out.
 
Vinny is a loyal guy who wants to win, we gave him his shot. I'm pretty certain we sign him

If the market is pushing Vinny's AAV high I think that could be solved by giving him some term that nobody else is interested in.

Say something like $1.3Mx5 would probably get him similar dollars, and would still give us flexibility to send him back down the line should his game fall off and have most or all of the deal buryable. He seems like a guy that would value term as well because that pushes out his playing career longer than it might with a shorter, but higher AAV deal.
 
Tarasenko thinking he was the missing piece to Florida cup last year....probably
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad