ATD: Rules - Discussion - Trades Thread

[Tony Romo]

We have the Eli Manning test in our rules.

Any player worse than him should be fair game in mentions.

In the hockey ATDs for the last two decades on HfBoards undrafteds were nixed except for Wade Belak and another, more maligned Leafs dman whose name escapes me at the moment....

Aki Berg?

 

[GKJ]

We have the Eli Manning test in our rules.

Any player worse than him should be fair game in mentions.

In the hockey ATDs for the last two decades on HfBoards undrafteds were nixed except for Wade Belak and another, more maligned Leafs dman whose name escapes me at the moment....

Aki Berg?

Bryan McCabe?

 

[VanIslander]

Aki Berg!!

Tony Romo you win a pair of steak knives!
Like Leaf dmen, they have no edge.
For just $99 you can buy the sharpener to make them great.

 

[GKJ]

I nearly took Suggs instead of Allen but I needed someone accomplished at that DE spot.

 

[Tony Romo]

I nearly took Suggs instead of Allen but I needed someone accomplished at that DE spot.

I was gonna go Thomas and Lanier. Think
Thomas is criminally underrated

 

[GKJ]

I was gonna go Thomas and Lanier. Think
Thomas is criminally underrated

He took too long to get to the hall of fame.

 

[Michael Farkas]

I almost took Suggs too...but then I took Mack because he's better haha

 

[Tony Romo]

@LT fantastic back to back picks. Both were on my board with 3 other guys.

 

[LT]

@LT fantastic back to back picks. Both were on my board with 3 other guys.

So far the only non-HoFer I've drafted is Torry Holt, who should get there eventually.

For not knowing much at all about pre-2010s players, I'm happy with how my roster is panning out.

I am in a bit of a bind now though, as I have two MLBs. Wasn't planning to run 3-4, but that may work out in the end. Let's me keep my DL strictly to HoF Italians

 

[Kent Nilsson]

Hindsight team


QB - Undrafted (16)
RB - Jim Brown (1, 3)
RB - Bronko Nagurski (18)
FB - Marion Motley (17)
TE - Rob Gronkowski (4)
TE - Ozzie Newsome (12)
LT - Anthony Munoz (2)
LG - John Hannah (5)
C -
RG - Forrest Gregg (3)
RT - Dan Dierdorf (13)

DE - Julius Peppers (8)
DT - Carl Eller (10)
DT - John Randle (7)
DE - Undrafted (20)
OLB - Ted Hendricks (11)
MLB - Luke Kuechly (9)
OLB -
CB - Stephon Gilmore (19)
CB - Aeneas Williams (6)
SS - Kenny Easley (14)
FS - Earl Thomas (15)

 

[LT]

Shula was gonna be my next pick, damn. Thought I could take the players first in this little stretch of three picks I have.

 

[Ben Grimm]

@LT fantastic back to back picks. Both were on my board with 3 other guys.

Agreed. @LT How does Kuechly go before HoFer Zach Thomas? @Michael Farkas got the best coach. My 15th best OA player is still undrafted.

 

[VanIslander]

OA?

Osteoarthritis?

 

[Ben Grimm]

OA? Osteoarthritis?

Overall

 

[Michael Farkas]

Is it a QB, perhaps a scrambly one? Because there's a roster construction aspect to this, of course, that will de-value much more valuable players...

 

[Ben Grimm]

Is it a QB, perhaps a scrambly one? Because there's a roster construction aspect to this, of course, that will de-value much more valuable players...

Can't say more until a certain team takes a certain position.

 

[Voight]

@LT almost picked Johnson a while ago, sneaky pick.


Can anyone take a list? Ill be at a wedding from this afternoon up until Saturday morning. Ill give a name for my next pick coming up, should be fine for the one after.

Agreed. @LT How does Kuechly go before HoFer Zach Thomas? @Michael Farkas got the best coach. My 15th best OA player is still undrafted.

Used to be a Panthers (NFL) fan on the board who made me hate Kuechy.

 

[Tony Romo]

@LT almost picked Johnson a while ago, sneaky pick.


Can anyone take a list? Ill be at a wedding from this afternoon up until Saturday morning. Ill give a name for my next pick coming up, should be fine for the one after.



Used to be a Panthers (NFL) fan on the board who made me hate Kuechy.

I got you, I'm not up for a while

 

[VanIslander]

OA=overall...k ... i learn that now, i grew up reading too many novels and my dad shagged me mum pre1970s, us with the first color ZENITH tv on our street, b&w out the window and down the street (watching colorful Hawaii 5-0 & Fantasy Island in January in 1976 was wow), though still available to us college kids in '87 for $60 at Zellers. I know,... i know... this is twilight zone to those who still can't grasp there was no Internet in the 1980s and mid-90s. Life pre-Internet was very different.

 

[Pestilence]

I picked Jason Peters to play Right Tackle, obviously he has been LT for most of his career, but played RT in the beginning of his career and also in the later stage. Is this too outlandish then, do I have to switch him to Util (or RB obviously) and pick another RT

 

[GKJ]

I picked Jason Peters to play Right Tackle, obviously he has been LT for most of his career, but played RT in the beginning of his career and also in the later stage. Is this too outlandish then, do I have to switch him to Util (or RB obviously) and pick another RT

Played tight end at Arkansas

 

[Hasbro]

I picked Jason Peters to play Right Tackle, obviously he has been LT for most of his career, but played RT in the beginning of his career and also in the later stage. Is this too outlandish then, do I have to switch him to Util (or RB obviously) and pick another RT

I took Too Tall Jones specifically as a Left End.

 

[VanIslander]

An undrafted NFL great head coach has said guard is a position that can be played either side, but tackle "takes time" to adjust.

 

[LT]

I'm gonna have to get creative with my linebackers too.

 

[VanIslander]

Just like defensemen played a very different role pre-Orr (post-Shore) so do linebackers in different eras.

This is an ALL-time draft, so your guys could reflect the best of any era, at least with hypothetical home games.