It’s possible. I think 5-6 first rounders were traded last deadline, so the question is if he’s among the 5-6 best players available. Hard to say without knowing exactly who will be sellers and who they’ll be selling. Easier to say Brock will get a first because he plays a premium position and it doesn’t look like there will be a lot of decent options there. I’ll take a first for Palmieri but if he gets a second plus I won’t be surprised.
Roster/Rumors/Speculation/Trade Talk - 2024-25: Re-Tool, Re-Group, Re-Mix, Re-Build
- Thread starter PK Cronin
- Start date
mm11
Registered User
Nelson has proved to be pretty clutch in the post season. Think a first is in the bag if isles dangle him
Let's hope so, he hasn't really stood out to me this year so far.
Brock’s already looks like and is playing like he’s moving outta LI so let’s just get this done asap once the holiday freeze is over
exaclty; he has not looked good this year at all. Still hoping he returns a first, but won't suprise me if he doesnt
scottywiper
Registered User
- Dec 2, 2018
- 8,979
- 4,765
Sorta fine with it but he’s on his second team and still not producing, quickly approaching the Wahlstrom zone.
Top Corner
Registered User
How can you improve a league worst PK in practice when the worst PP is at the same practice? Just doesn’t work. Only way to improve both sides is the injection of speed that can get to lose pucks before the other team gets it. So many times this year and in the past is the Isles player is a half second late getting to lose pucks resulting in loss of possession for both PP or PK units
This. It’s the blind leading the blind.
As for loose pucks, isles always back off the 50/50 pucks and defend instead of going for it. It’s a joke.
And PS- Roy sucks. Not NHL HC material.
LeapOnOver
Mackenzie is a hack!
Anyone thinking Nelson won't net a first is off their rocker. Coaching is leading to this shitshow, and Nelson is just along for the ride. GMs know that he'll be fine on a team run correctly.
Torrey Redux
Please!
There is consensus among people who are guessing. It's possible, maybe even probable, but he has an M-NTC and so it depends to some degree on who is on that list or if Brock is willing to waive. Presumably he would waive to go to a Cup contender but the joke around here is that the boys are all pretty attached to their "country club", that is, they are all very comfortable here.
impaaaaaact
Registered User
He's having an off year like the rest of the team, but his goal totals from the three previous years are 34, 36, and 37, averaging 70 points per 82 over that span. He plays center but can shift to left wing if need be, and has both PP and PK experience (we weren't always the worst in the league). Plays big in the playoffs, and is the team's current iron man - he's missed something like 15 total games since his rookie season.
Anything less than a first + would mean that every GM is weighing his last 35 games on a terrible team more than his last 250. Even with the slow start to the year it's possible he's the consensus top forward add at the deadline depending on who is available.
As much as it would pain me to see him on the Devils, putting him on a line with Hughes and Bratt would be lethal and it feels like a team he wouldn't have on his list. Brock is 54% from the dot this season and generally is best when someone else is transporting the puck as he's not the most dynamic guy in the world. What he will do is find the soft spaces and snipe the puck and clean up the garbage. Probably a perfect fit tbh
Last edited:
Yeah the reason I dropped in to ask. We have 3- 2nds this yr but no 1sts. Most in our camp think a Nelson/Palms up top and another 4th liner. We look pretty good right now, so our GM will part with picks. Not sure of the prospects you'd have in mind. I'm hoping he doesn't move one of the defenders for a rental. Love Lou Lams but it's time, actually it was time while he was still in Jersey. Thx for the info, good luck on turning it around
Didn't realize that. Some of these guys gotta be hungry to make a nice run at so e point you'd think. Thx
impaaaaaact
Registered User
Yeah I mean my guess would be that Silayev, Casey, and Gritsyuk are all off limits. Maybe Hameenaho and a second for Brock? Palmieri feels like two seconds and we can throw you Zeeker for a bag of pucks too
Osakahaus
Chillin' on Fuji
- May 28, 2021
- 8,506
- 4,185
They should but will they? If they trade with the Leafs we dont get a first. We need to secure at least a first and NHL ready prospect. Get the next generation ready.
periferal
Registered User
- Jul 5, 2007
- 29,374
- 16,770
Totally agree.
So what does it say if Lou is not only still left in charge, but resigns (overpays) Nelson to s 6 year deal?
I agree that there will be a few teams who are in need of a 2-way center, great teammate, who has 30-goal poential, and that bidding war will get the Isles a 1st+.
That said...As long as Lou is running the show I do NOT believe that he will sell off literally anyone. In fact I think if any player is traded it would be a sign to me that Lou's hand is being forced by Malkin or Roy is the de facto GM, but either way he's on his way out.
Point is...I think we should all be prepared for Nelson/Palmieri to be kept and resigned, and not believe a sell off will happen...Unless it actually happens.
impaaaaaact
Registered User
Lebrun mentioned in his latest article that he thinks Nelson intends on testing free agency, which would make sense with Lou saying they haven’t begun negotiations.
Can’t make the same mistake twice. Gotta deal him.
Can’t make the same mistake twice. Gotta deal him.
impaaaaaact
Registered User
Red Wings make a coaching change. they’ll probably get a little bump which should move us up a pick
The Real JT
The crowd called out for more
I will always be an Isles fan but if that sh!t happens I’m taking a sabbatical.Totally agree.
So what does it say if Lou is not only still left in charge, but resigns (overpays) Nelson to s 6 year deal?
I agree that there will be a few teams who are in need of a 2-way center, great teammate, who has 30-goal poential, and that bidding war will get the Isles a 1st+.
That said...As long as Lou is running the show I do NOT believe that he will sell off literally anyone. In fact I think if any player is traded it would be a sign to me that Lou's hand is being forced by Malkin or Roy is the de facto GM, but either way he's on his way out.
Point is...I think we should all be prepared for Nelson/Palmieri to be kept and resigned, and not believe a sell off will happen...Unless it actually happens.
I’m gonna guess no one here or in the Isles management particularly gives a shit but that’s what things have come to for me.
Kevin27NYI
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2009
- 20,168
- 6,155
I still don't see why Palms and Nelson can't both fetch first rounders but for Palms that depends on the market. Toffoli might be a comp and that's a second and a third. Have Brock go to Dallas for a first +, Palms maybe back to the Devils for a second and a third. See what the market is for Lee, Cizikas and Pageau. I wouldn't rush to trade Lee but if he does go it gives plenty of cap space to overpay for Rantanen or Marner if they reach free agency. Or you can aggressively trade picks for younger talent that also costs money like a Zegras.
8EJS9
Registered User
I’m in the boat that not only Brock could get a first but Palms as well.
Kevin27NYI
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2009
- 20,168
- 6,155
He's having a strong year but I think it's worth pointing out top 6 wingers (rentals) usually go for a second plus and not firsts. That's usually for centers and top 4 Dmen.
