One Winged Angel
You Can't Escape
Half the league would have taken DeBrincat in a do-over. Probably the same for Girard. A lot of teams miss--every year there are a handful of guys who should have gone round one that didn't. But that doesn't make other guys who did go in the first unworthy.
Maybe to you, that might be the case. I’d rather take my chances on a boom or bust pick than someone like Howden, whose likely projection was that of a good 3rd line center, especially if you’re a team like Tampa was at that time, deep and young enough to afford to be able to swing for the fence.
Having watched both Katchouk and Howden a lot in junior (especially Katchouk), I would take Howden every day of the week. I definitely think Howden would be matching Katchouk's AHL production if he was down there where he should be. Raddysh, probably a toss up for me. I have zero interest in Carter Hart, and certainly nowhere near round one. Kyrou I would have taken over Howden.
That’s fine, we’ll never agree on Hart or Raddysh, who I think were both slam dunks for me, but I think those two players both end up way better players at their position at the NHL level than Howden does.
Here’s to hoping I’m wrong.
Anyway, I know why Howden is up. He's here because we're ****. The other guys aren't up because for many of them, their teams are not ****! Howden should be in the AHL, I have said this repeatedly. It just seems that people are now panning him, calling him unworthy of a first round pick, because we've put him in a position to fail. If we weren't ****, he'd be in the AHL like the others and he'd probably be doing really well and everyone would still be excited about him.
Would that change the mindset? Possibly, but I still don’t like the player and don’t think he should have been a major piece in that trade.
Howden has been a big time prospect since he entered the WHL years ago. He had an accomplished junior career. He was good for Team Canada. Literally everyone had him pegged as a first round pick, because of his tangible and intangible skills. He absolutely deserved to be drafted in round one. No doubt about it. That he's being asked to do too much shouldn't diminish his stock, at least relative to his peers who haven't been put in the same position to fail. You want to cherry pick guys from round two or later that should have gone in front of him, fine, but that's lots of players in every round one.
Big time prospect? I wouldn’t say that. I’d say a good prospect. When you use words like that, it implies near the top and he’s never been that type of prospect.
Asked to do too much? Who is asking him to do too much? Quinn? He has him as a 3rd line center.
Just because some think that he doesn’t have upside worth being a 1st rounder doesn’t mean that anyone is asking too much of him. It means we don’t see the upside in a player that was a safe pick and nothing more.