Speculation: Roster Building Thread: Part XX

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
your perception is whatever the graph tells you.

Who has Buch been playing with? Zibs, Panarin, Kreider and Chytil...

Who has Lemieux been playing with? Howden your favorite.

Use some critical thinking and dive deeper than just looking at charts

Sure, yes.

I want the Rangers to be better at analytics. Lynch me.
 
And I think you’ll find that successful players, have some combination of finesse and power. It might be an 80-20 mix, compared to a 50-50 mix, but it’s there.

That’s also what makes someone like Chytil interesting, because he’s a blend of both.
Again, I'm with you on that point.

But am I balking at a player with high offensive upside because a) he lacks other elements or b) I feel like we're in a position to turn that down? No.

I don't see this as a "medium range" team and I still want bullets in the chamber. We can worry about nuance when more chips are in place.
 
Some of us are being trolled by insomnia.
To be honest. With the clocks turning back. I have a hard time making it past 830 right now. I’ve woke up 45 mins ago, having already slept for 4 hrs.

Now trend is up for 2-3 hours and then maybe I get back to sleep for another 2-3 hours after that

And no I’m not a wizard, I’m a troll
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband and Ola
To be honest. With the clocks turning back. I have a hard time making it past 830 right now. I’ve woke up 45 mins ago, having already slept for 4 hrs.

Now trend is up for 2-3 hours and then maybe I get back to sleep for another 2-3 hours after that

And no I’m not a wizard, I’m a troll
are you 35+?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NernieBichols
At this point in present time, it seems i am in fact 35+.

Which makes me LOL bc i still feel 16 in so many ways
I had the same problem and it was very mild acid reflux. woke me up almost every night till i got it ironed out.

could also be time to go to the doctor and see him about the thumb in the :eek:
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
I had the same problem and it was very mild acid reflux. woke me up almost every night till i got it ironed out.

could also be time to go to the doctor and see him about the thumb in the :eek:
Is that why I want to puke every time i read postgame threads after a loss when I wake up in the middle of night?
 
Last edited:
I still don’t think it’s finesse or grit.

It’s finesse and grit. Be it in combinations of players, or being to find players who combine different percentages of both.

This issue always becomes more black and white than it needs to be.
If Strome was able to produce another level of grit, be it by becoming stronger or meaner, I would advocate to resign him because he added that element.
 

What he means is "play harder" is more impoetant for teams on the cusp of being contenders as oppoaed to teams in the modst of a rebuild.

We need to get more skill in here. While I agree that teaching the kids to play hard early is a good thing, it's not a main focus right now for the team as a whole. We aren't gritting our way to a cup here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Machinehead
If the Rangers decided to trade Georgiev, there should be a very good market for him. You can make the argument about Georgiev is better than most of the starting goaltenders on other teams. Any team trading for Georgiev will have to protect him in the expansion draft. So many teams don't even have a legit goaltending prospect in the pipeline.

Boston has Rask signed for one more season. He will 34 at the end of his contract. They don't have a young goaltender in their system.

Georgiev would be the best goaltender on Buffalo. He is better than Hutton, Ullmark and the Finn goalie prospect playing in the ECHL.

The Red Wings goaltenders stink. Bernier and Howard. Georgiev would be #1 there.

Florida and Montreal have two goaltenders signed for big money and big term. Florida has Knight.

Georgiev would #1 in Ottawa. They don't have any long term option there either.

TB no.

Toronto has Andersen under contract for one more season. Do they look at Georgiev who they can sign to an affordable contract and dump Andersen?

Carolina has awful goaltending. Georgiev is better than Mrazek and Reimer.

Columbus has Korpisalo. Georgiev is better.

Georgiev would be #1 on the Devils. The Rangers aren't trading him to NJ.

Islanders no. They have their own Russian goalie prospect in Sorokin. Varlamov is under contract for three more years.

Philly no. Hart.

Pittsburgh no. Murray. Jarry has been terrific for them.

Capitals no. Samsonov. Holtby is a free agent.

Chicago has Lehner. They probably sign him long-term this summer. Maybe.

Grubauer has been good in Colorado. He is a long term option for them? He is signed for another season.

Dallas has Bishop signed for big money. NMC.

Dubnyk is signed for another season. He will 35 at the end of his contract.

Both of Nashville's goaltenders have struggled. Georgiev is better that Rinne and Sarros. Rinne has one more season left on his contract. He will be 38 at the end of the contract.

St. Louis no.

Winnipeg no.

Anaheim no.

Arizona has Raanta who is signed for one more season. Kuemper signed a two year extension. Georgiev is better than both of them.

Calgary yes. Rittich and Talbot.

Edmonton yes. Smith and Koskinen.

LA yes. LA is stuck with Quick's contract. Georgiev is better than Quick and Campbell.

SJ is a mess. Jones is terrible. Georgiev is better. SJ has Jones under contract for four more years.

Vancouver has Markstrom who they want to re-sign. They also have Demko.

Vegas has Fleury who signed for two more seasons. No NMC. They don't have to protect him in expansion.

If the Rangers had to move Georgiev, there should be a robust market for him. Just look at all of goaltending situations around the NHL. Nearly 2/3 of the goaltending situations are in flux. He will sign an affordable contract this summer. He won't be very expensive.

The free agent market for goaltenders is thin. Holtby. Lehner. Markstrom. The latter two might re-sign with their current teams. Holtby is 50/50 to stay in Washington.

There aren't many other trade options available.

If the Rangers don't want to force the issue with Lundqvist(and he wants to keep playing) and Shesterkin doesn't want to spend another year in the AHL, Georgiev is the odd man out. Reality. Shesterkin has a KHL assignment clause. Is it for next season too? Kravtsov had the clause for just this season. We saw what happened with him. Rykov has the clause in his contract next season in the second year. He missed the first three months of this season with a high ankle sprain.

Brooks is mental. Two weeks ago, he wrote there was a changing of the guard in net for the Rangers with Georgiev getting more starts. A few days later, Brooks was on the New York Post Rangers podcast hosted by Ron Duguay. Brooks says Lundqvist will be a Ranger until the end of his current contract. When Andersson quit the Pack in the AHL, Brooks wrote the Rangers have to be concerned about Shesterkin bolting for Russia after the Kravtsov and Andersson situations. Something has to give. The changing of the guard will come with Shesterkin taking over as #1. The Rangers should call up Shesterkin this season. Reward him for his good play. Give him a few starts.

Last week,Brooks wrote the Rangers screwed up the Hayes and Trouba situations. Hayes is worth the money while Trouba isn't. He wrote the Rangers could have had Hayes for less than he got as a free agent. Newsflash. Both of them aren't worth the money.

Brooks wrote about the Rangers keeping Kreider. I was watching the Rangers-Carolina last Friday at the bar. Kreider woke up and had a good game. The guy sitting next to me said how soon before Brooks writes the Rangers need to keep Kreider and not really trade anyone. It took 3 days.

The Blues traded Shattenkirk in 2017 to the Caps. They were a playoff team and they couldn't re-sign him. They traded him for futures.

Kreider saw what happened to Shattenkirk who turned down multiple 7 year offers to take the Rangers 4 year offer and the Rangers bought Shattenkirk out after the 2nd season. Shattenkirk left so much money on the table to play in New York. Shattenkirk isn't recouping that money this summer. The market is loaded with free agent D. Kreider isn't stupid. He should take the best offer this summer. Just like Hayes did. New York City isn't the end all and be all. So many people are fleeing New York these days for numerous reasons.
 
Since I doubt the Rangers will find takers in Smith or Staal, both should get bought out this summer so the Rangers have flexibility to do what needs to be done this offseason. Also frees up roster spots.

They would save $3.7MM next season and then the following season there would be a total charge of $1.8MM.
 
Is the Kreider to Penguins rumor legit? I could have been away, but have seen some references of HNIC talking about Kreider to Pitt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
Is the Kreider to Penguins rumor legit? I could have been away, but have seen some references of HNIC talking about Kreider to Pitt.
Doubtful.Gorton wont move him in division and i doubt Pitt would want to help us out in any way.
 
Doubtful.Gorton wont move him in division and i doubt Pitt would want to help us out in any way.

Kreider could tic a lot of boxes for some GMs and coaches. He is business, for good and bad. But you are getting a force of nature, we all know that Kreider isn’t always very effective, but he ‘could’ be.

Pittsburg is a little worn down. They don’t have that extreme drive.

With that said, I don’t know what Pittsburg got to offer. I am not a big fan of their prospects (Hållander included). Poulin is OK. Two 1st’s?
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
Posted the below on the main boards in one of the Leafs threads, some Leafs fans think it was fair. Goes with my above post about buying out Staal and Smith.

Skjei ($5.25MM x 4 years), Kravstov ($950k ELC x 2 years), Georgiev ($800K RFA) for Nylander ($7MM x 4 years) and Kapanen ($3.2MM x 2 years)

I took out the offered 2nd round pick coming from the Leafs in the original proposal.

Cap to Leafs: $6.25MM plus Georgiev new contract (probably $3-4MM) so $9.25-$10.25MM.

Cap to Rangers: $10.2MM. Both Staal and Smith should get bought out this offseason
 
Kreider could tic a lot of boxes for some GMs and coaches. He is business, for good and bad. But you are getting a force of nature, we all know that Kreider isn’t always very effective, but he ‘could’ be.

Pittsburg is a little worn down. They don’t have that extreme drive.

With that said, I don’t know what Pittsburg got to offer. I am not a big fan of their prospects (Hållander included). Poulin is OK. Two 1st’s?
Galchenyuk is a pending UFA that hasn't worked out as hoped, it might be a perfect situation where you can buy low. Former 30 goal scorer, even with the inconsistencies there's things to like. Zibby is only a year apart and just recently started putting together all the aspects it takes to reach that next level, especially off the ice, so can that rub off on him? The Sens added a 2nd in the Brassard trade, if the Pens don't see Alex in their future can you get them to add a pick?
 
They should sell Kreider and Fast, they are pending UFAs and neither contract is going to fit the player when the Rangers would maybe be ready to compete in the playoffs for real.

They are likely to lose Lias for not much, they still are short on forward prospects. Take the picks and either use them or trade them again for something closer or already in the NHL later.

Sign their RFAs, DeAngelo will have value on his next contract no matter what. Lemieux likely too. Strome is the tricky one, I'd probably sign him for his last RFA year and deal with his UFA years later.

I'd keep Georgiev, without him any injury or down turn with Shesterkin over the next couple years means the Rangers have gone from goalie strong to goalie weak.

If they are trading out a defender, it should really probably be Skjei who seems to have plateaued into the same thing he was when they gave him a long term instead of a bridge. Yet since he is under contract for some years he'd have some value. He is the type of player and contract that will help them stay right in the dreaded middle, same for Kreider and Fast.

Use some combination of their own futures and/or the futures they get from Kreider, Fast, Skjei to replace Kreider, Fast, Skjei.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kovazub94
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad