Speculation: Roster Building Thread : Part XVI (Playoffs or Retool?)

You’re right, he’s playing great . We’re lucky to have him

How many goals has it led to?

64 straight games without a game winning goal for Mika and only 2 over the last 121. With that much ice time/PP/OT usage you could probably get more than that by accident. The last one he had was in a 7-4 blowout a little under a year ago.

He's not finishing enough or when it matters.

There, I spun it.

how about this: SCORE SOME f***ING GOALS
nice lil poison quote in there

Don't even try.

I get that we all have our favorites and therefore create biases. Being aware of mine I had always kept my favorite players to higher standards to "compensate" for these biases and not look ridiculous.

This here is a case in point of the opposite. Zibanejad has been underperforming for what now has been over 1.5 seasons. I can (and did) cut him slack for slow starts (for two years) or puck luck, etc. But at this point having this smug condescending attitude in writing responding toward rightful criticism of supposedly 1C center is unwarranted at best - it's been one excuse after another after another.
As I expected. Strawmans and running goal posts.

Rightful criticism? Give me a f***ing break :laugh: How the f*** can he be a detriment to the team when he is constantly creating offence? I mean, what are we doing here? Has this board gone completely insane? Are xGF/60 a bogus stat all of a sudden. Cuylle is having more high danger chances than ever before playing with Mika. Even more than when he was playing on "the best line in hockey". Sure, the scoring is down but that is due to puck luck.

You guys are so delusional and entrenched in your hatred towards Zibanejad that It would kill you to give fair criticism. Heck, just a couple of hours ago someone posted a Tweet falsely painting Mika as the culprit for Cuylle cooling down and you all went and bombed it with likes without even looking up the actual numbers. Luckily we had a few posters quickly debunking that Tweet with actual facts.

At this point I would respect you more if you just came out and admitted that you dont like the guy whether he plays well or not.
 
Will Cuylle leads the team in individual high danger chances for since being put with Zibanejad.

Pucks haven’t gone in for him. That’s it. That line has been creating more offense than any of our other lines they just haven’t been able to finish.

I’m all for calling out players who are playing like shit but this one doesn’t pass the sniff test, eye test or any test.
Awesome look forward to when he starts producing like before he was with 93
I won't hold my breath
But hey I understand someone has to play on a line with a guy who refuses to win puck battles and right now Cuylle is that sacrificial lamb
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Siddi
I think that you can attribute some (most?) of Pettersson's PS fall off to his knee. His game started to dip the second that it became an issue last year (last Jan) and it carried over. I'm not willing to paint him as Panarin part 2 just yet (whose RS to PS fall off is next level and we've got more than enough data to support this) but it's definitely a pink flag. I think the worry with him is his head space but more so the knee which seems like it's still an issue. He missed time and his speed has completely left him. He was a 93rd percentile top speed guy as recently as a year ago.

He's been sub 50th percentile this year. Thats a massive red flag. You can't chalk his struggles up to JT Miller, thats straight up a physical thing and I'd be worried that he hasn't been able to bounce back from it with time off between seasons and some time off this year. He isn't that old.

It's a gamble either or. But it also seems clear that the Rangers target is more Miller and I'd guess that Vancouver is more inclined to keep EP. It's not that I watch the Canucks all that much.....it does seem to me when we've played them the last couple/3 years JT's been more of a factor.....then again being with us before he's got reason to be motivated.

I do have a bias towards bigger, more physical players. I also think the Rangers don't have enough of that in their top 6. I'm not talking necessarily about guys who play mean, nasty and fight. I think of Barkov as a physical player and it's not like Zibanejad ever went around plastering players with hits but seems to me he used to be more physically engaged than he is these days. When you have an asset you need to use it to your advantage. A guy like Barkov has a lot of skill but he's also willing to impose his way to your goalmouth. I think we could use more of that and that's something I think JT can bring.

Again to a potential JT trade---not sure that it's getting to a point where it will be too late to save this season. To me that's another thing to factor because Vancouver will likely take from us at least two if not three younger assets---whether roster players, developing prospects or draft picks and there's a good chance our 1st will be part of the deal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Overcast
Will Cuylle leads the team in individual high danger chances for since being put with Zibanejad.

Pucks haven’t gone in for him. That’s it. That line has been creating more offense than any of our other lines they just haven’t been able to finish.

I’m all for calling out players who are playing like shit but this one doesn’t pass the sniff test, eye test or any test.
This is why I'm fine with trading for JT Miller if it means Kreider eventually goes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: leetch99
As I expected. Strawmans and running goal posts.

Rightful criticism? Give me a f***ing break :laugh: How the f*** can he be a detriment to the team when he is constantly creating offence? I mean, what are we doing here? Has this board gone completely insane? Are xGF/60 a bogus stat all of a sudden. Cuylle is having more high danger chances than ever before playing with Mika. Even more than when he was playing on "the best line in hockey". Sure, the scoring is down but that is due to puck luck.

You guys are so delusional and entrenched in your hatred towards Zibanejad that It would kill you to give fair criticism. Heck, just a couple of hours ago someone posted a Tweet falsely painting Mika as the culprit for Cuylle cooling down and you all went and bombed it with likes without even looking up the actual numbers. Luckily we had a few posters quickly debunking that Tweet with actual facts.

At this point I would respect you more if you just came out and admitted that you dont like the guy whether he plays well or not.
Mika has 9 goals and 29 points in 49 games. So much offense. So f***ing sexy that guy. It’s kinda hard to score when you never shoot or when you do you whiff like Aaron Judge in the playoffs. Give me a break. This has nothing to do with Mika as a person. Not a single person here disliked him 5 years ago right before Covid hit when he had that 5 goal game and was lighting the league on fire. What’s changed? Idk but he looks like the groundhog who sees his shadow and instead of it being winter another 6 weeks he sees his shadow gets scared and hides for 6 weeks.
 
You guys are missing the forest through the trees. If getting JT Miller for 50% of his value is available now, you do it, and you figure the rest out later. Is it risk free? No, but trading guys like Sykora, Lindgren, Chlemar, even Chytil, is not mortgaging the future.

I've heard it forever that the team needs all guys under 25 years old on lifetime contracts below market value. It's not how reality works. Miller is one of the few bulldogs in the league with skill you get him for the next 4-5 years and pair him with Trocheck there are your 1-2 centers. Figure out what to do with Mika, either he bounces back and pushes Trocheck to 3C or he's forced out of here.

This team has some good pieces in place, and is retooling. It's pretty evident Drury is identifying what he believes is missing and he's got the freedom to implement his plan. So we are going to have to live with his plan as fans. Let's hope he gets it right but frankly, adding guys with jam and skill is exactly what wins in this league. We saw it with Vegas Colorado Florida Tampa, skill + jam. Too many of the Rangers skill guys don't have the jam. Miller does.
bold: issue is not how much we pay, but what is optimal currency expenditure that makes most sense for us
what will they take they we can not only live with, but prefer to do

we don't have to give up Chytil or a 1st
peeps, pls let that sink in
they desp want to ditch Desharnais who is a pylon
Lindgren is actually more mobile and a functional upgrade
so the combo that works is

Kaliyev, Sykora, Smith + Lindgren
for
jtm + desharnais

THAT is THE line that should be held
if we want to be generous, and enable them to say they got something out of us, you throw in Jones and/or BMB
THAT'S IT
no Chytil, bigger primo prospects

underline: you want the best players regardless of age BUT
REMEMBER THE FOLLOWING
you want max chances to win the most
that is NOT going all in short term win now stupidity
it is as much quality youth as you can obtain/develop

remember
chemistry can be age irrespective
BUT
esp in POs, energy/hunger of youth >> vet experience

I invite challenges to say the above is wrong.


A player struggling 40 games into a season is labeled "in decline."

A player gets hot for 40 games and the response is "let's see him keep doing it before we decide"

It's very unlikely that Fox, Panarin, Trocheck, Zibanejad, and Kreider are all in decline. Maybe 1 or 2 of them, but very unlikely all of them are.
you do not mean it, my friend, but in your haste and passion you are sloppy.

Fox + bread are obv not in decline
they should be dealt only b'c
the return extends our window and in Fox's case, it's now or never as to permissions

tro is just a bit slow. Not ready to say decline just yet.
Again, compare value of kept vs return

Kreider, again, he is playing injured and he can not constantly set up Zib who fails REPEATEDLY

zib = bite me, you selfish arrogant bastard, bite me



Thanks for objectively demonstrating how much Zib totally sucks
not regular sucks, but ass level sucks


Miller can and should also return a 1st. Kreider would be the last player is trade unless the off is too good to pass up
Agreed, tho at this pt, esp w/Fortescue believed to be a season/+ away, I would extend KAM and keep unless return is too good.
Healthy Kreider returns a lot, but this is not healthy Kreider.
The persecution of a real heart and soul guy who is like only one who contributes real beast factor has to stop

And going forward, Edstrom and Rempe should be the PP guys in front of the net.


This is to all the "eye test" posters out there.

Despite all of your posturing and cheast beating about Mika being a detriment to this team and what not. How is it that for the past 10+ games his line leads the team in xGF/60? Mikas line is literally our best line at creating offence.

I would love to see the peanut gallery try to spin this.
You cherry pick all you want.
He is allergic to contact, his def is beyond attrocious
and he is not actually put the puck in the net enough to merit excusal

Your argument is basically forget he was wasting Kreider +, now he is pulling down Cuylle, but b'c he is slightly better statistically (assuming your claim is accurate), let it go

pay no attention to the man behind the curtain
he is not the great and powerful wizard of Ahhs or anything else


You're like fancy bern, lol.
@RangerBoy remains our most esteemed poster.
I am merely our most creative one.
I am honored by the comparison, even if we disagree a bit here and there


i think drury is trying to wait out VAN and see if they'll do mika for miller

and then we have to get mika to waive

i'd honestly be surprised at this point if drury trades for him otherwise.

and this is the only way the move makes any real sense.

trading one guy whose value is in the toilet for the other. plus a 500K cap savings!
Mika is not waiving to VAN at this pt
He MIGHT if either/both EP and JTM are gone
but I doubt it.
On paper I could MAYBE see ANA if we gave him to them max retained
but that is also a stretch
looks like it will be an EC team

That said, we should not wait.
His ridiculous def is basis enough to make him sit and sit and sit
until he breaks
and waives now not later


Mika and Kreider are anchors.
Not true, and I won't repeat myself.


you could have tipped her 22% for Beuk & Leetch......just sayin....
There is one idiot here who I will not name who constantly ha-ha's me, constantly. Like if I said water was wet constantly.
Lately @Mandar has been joining that poster w/constant haha.

Ok, my turn!


We have a few Mika apologists in here. Why ? God knows.
b'c for any of a number of reasons, incl they would rather go there than admit bern was right
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Mandar
Cuylle-Zibanejad-Smith have muffed a lot of the chances they've generated, whether it's blowing an odd man, not getting a shot off, shooting into the goalie or getting robbed by the goalie. And waived-off goals too.
 
As I expected. Strawmans and running goal posts.

Rightful criticism? Give me a f***ing break :laugh: How the f*** can he be a detriment to the team when he is constantly creating offence? I mean, what are we doing here? Has this board gone completely insane? Are xGF/60 a bogus stat all of a sudden. Cuylle is having more high danger chances than ever before playing with Mika. Even more than when he was playing on "the best line in hockey". Sure, the scoring is down but that is due to puck luck.

You guys are so delusional and entrenched in your hatred towards Zibanejad that It would kill you to give fair criticism. Heck, just a couple of hours ago someone posted a Tweet falsely painting Mika as the culprit for Cuylle cooling down and you all went and bombed it with likes without even looking up the actual numbers. Luckily we had a few posters quickly debunking that Tweet with actual facts.

At this point I would respect you more if you just came out and admitted that you dont like the guy whether he plays well or not.
Man I"m happy to make excuses for a long time for a lot of these guys but at some point you gotta turn that xGF/60 into real goals, and we're going on like year 3 of Zibanejad and his line not doing that.

Yeah it still means something (at least they're generating chances) but if the real goals scored never budges then what's the use? Why are we relying on this line to be one of the top lines for the team when they can't score goals?

Cuylle-Zibanejad-Smith have muffed a lot of the chances they've generated, whether it's blowing an odd man, not getting a shot off, shooting into the goalie or getting robbed by the goalie. And waived-off goals too.
yeah well and that's been happening for years now

at some point you can't just keep shrugging and saying "bad luck" or whatever.
 
As I expected. Strawmans and running goal posts.

Rightful criticism? Give me a f***ing break :laugh: How the f*** can he be a detriment to the team when he is constantly creating offence? I mean, what are we doing here? Has this board gone completely insane? Are xGF/60 a bogus stat all of a sudden. Cuylle is having more high danger chances than ever before playing with Mika. Even more than when he was playing on "the best line in hockey". Sure, the scoring is down but that is due to puck luck.

You guys are so delusional and entrenched in your hatred towards Zibanejad that It would kill you to give fair criticism. Heck, just a couple of hours ago someone posted a Tweet falsely painting Mika as the culprit for Cuylle cooling down and you all went and bombed it with likes without even looking up the actual numbers. Luckily we had a few posters quickly debunking that Tweet with actual facts.

At this point I would respect you more if you just came out and admitted that you dont like the guy whether he plays well or not.
1738013277961.png
You're a guy who loves to post advanced stats charts & graphs. So courtesy of @duhmetreE , I'll leave this here for you & ask you to spin it.
 
Man I"m happy to make excuses for a long time for a lot of these guys but at some point you gotta turn that xGF/60 into real goals, and we're going on like year 3 of Zibanejad and his line not doing that.

Yeah it still means something (at least they're generating chances) but if the real goals scored never budges then what's the use? Why are we relying on this line to be one of the top lines for the team when they can't score goals?


yeah well and that's been happening for years now

at some point you can't just keep shrugging and saying "bad luck" or whatever.

First of all, it's an honor whenever you reply to a post of mine.

Second, even the PDOphiles will tell everyone that bad luck normalizes over time, not just guys who go on benders.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TheDirtyH
This is why I'm fine with trading for JT Miller if it means Kreider eventually goes.
zib should go yesterday
our vets returning profit should be moved now
Kreider eventually but if he is healthy enuf by end of next year, and is willing to give us sweetheart deal 1 yr at a time like 3.5-4 per, I say he is worth keeping
 
  • Like
Reactions: bl02
One thing I'll say is that the expected results for a Cuylle-Mika combo are pretty good, especially since they are not getting starts in the offensive zone. 2 out of every 3 faceoffs are either in the defensive or neutral zone.

The one counter point to this is that Mika had a similar situation with Kakko, but there are differences in that too.

The Mika-Kakko combo had a majority of offensive zone starts where they were getting roughly 2 out of every 3 starts in the offensive zone.

Mika had a change in his usage in the new year. Prior to the new year, he was getting a pretty even split between OZ/NZ/DZ starts. Since then, he's been used much more as a shutdown C. While the actual results haven't been great, it's a small sample, and should start going the other direction.

Also none of this supports Mika staying or changing his role on the current team. All it means is that while Mika has underperformed, it hasn't been recently. He shouldn't be on PP1 at this point either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
This is to all the "eye test" posters out there.

Despite all of your posturing and cheast beating about Mika being a detriment to this team and what not. How is it that for the past 10+ games his line leads the team in xGF/60? Mikas line is literally our best line at creating offence.

I would love to see the peanut gallery try to spin this.
Because Mika can't hit the broad side of a barn with his shot.

Mika has looked better but still nowhere near a 1C and that's the problem. At this point I'm thinking the Rangers need to try to win with a strategy of having 3 or 4 centers who could be a 2C on most teams because the odds of getting a bona-fide 1C aren't good.

JT Miller is intriguing but he's not young and we're potentially giving up Chytil for him who has 2C+ potential. I'm not ready to give on on Chytil. He's a 3C with legit upside, relatively cheap contract and the only skater that can consistently move the puck up the ice (Jones can too but that ship has sailed).

At this point, I view Mika as a high-end 3C or low-end 2C. Trocheck is the best center we have and he's still a high-end 2C. Chytil has the potential to surpass everyone but isn't there yet.
 
Awesome look forward to when he starts producing like before he was with 93
I won't hold my breath
But hey I understand someone has to play on a line with a guy who refuses to win puck battles and right now Cuylle is that sacrificial lamb
Another empty retort avoiding the facts I brought up.
Mika has 9 goals and 29 points in 49 games. So much offense. So f***ing sexy that guy. It’s kinda hard to score when you never shoot or when you do you whiff like Aaron Judge in the playoffs. Give me a break. This has nothing to do with Mika as a person. Not a single person here disliked him 5 years ago right before Covid hit when he had that 5 goal game and was lighting the league on fire. What’s changed? Idk but he looks like the groundhog who sees his shadow and instead of it being winter another 6 weeks he sees his shadow gets scared and hides for 6 weeks.
I can promise you that If he would have started the season playing the way he has during this last stretch of 10+ games the points would look much more flattering.
Your argument is basically forget he was wasting Kreider +, now he is pulling down Cuylle, but b'c he is slightly better statistically (assuming your claim is accurate), let it go
You are not well.
Man I"m happy to make excuses for a long time for a lot of these guys but at some point you gotta turn that xGF/60 into real goals, and we're going on like year 3 of Zibanejad and his line not doing that.

Yeah it still means something (at least they're generating chances) but if the real goals scored never budges then what's the use? Why are we relying on this line to be one of the top lines for the team when they can't score goals?
Thank you. Level headed fair criticism. Yes, they are generating chances and yes, they need to convert them.
 
Cuylle-Zibanejad-Smith have muffed a lot of the chances they've generated, whether it's blowing an odd man, not getting a shot off, shooting into the goalie or getting robbed by the goalie. And waived-off goals too.

I don't know if his hands are gone or he's just in his head. I think it's mostly the latter. When he's in his head he just pretty much muffs every pass and shot. This happened his entire career almost he just used to snap out of it, he doesn't anymore.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
....

You are not well.
....
Who the fug are you to go there with this kind of insult?
because I disagree w/you and insist you capitulate to the eye test
which shows indisputably zib not only still very subpar on offense but more importantly on defense is beyond horrid, and is contact shy?

you got nothing which is why you say nothing
you are resembling a mirror of zib
Physician heal thyself
 
  • Like
Reactions: bl02
I said it the other day but whether people want Miller or not it would take a ton of pressure off Mika and make him the 3C since he’s basically a checking line center at this point anyway. Hell, I’d even put Kreider back with him too and they can play a checking role since they aren’t providing offense anyway.
I like it. they need to completely simplify their roles. Need to find a 3C though if chytil is moved fot JTM
 
Great! Everybody knows Mika sucked before the break. Now show me the card for the past 10 games, you know, what this discussion is all about.
If he's playing so well why is he still at an Overall of 1?

He has 3 goals & 5 assists in 15 games since the Christmas break. That's not exactly lighting it up, but I know you'll tell us all just how good his x/GF numbers are. Regardless, he needs to score. He's paid as our 1C & the team relies on him to produce.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bl02
If he's playing so well why is he still at an Overall of 1?

He has 3 goals & 5 assists in 15 games since the Christmas break. That's not exactly lighting it up, but I know you'll tell us all just how good his x/GF numbers are. Regardless, he needs to score. He's paid as our 1C & the team relies on him to produce.
he’s almost producing at erik christensen levels now. stud
 
If he's playing so well why is he still at an Overall of 1?

He has 3 goals & 5 assists in 15 games since the Christmas break. That's not exactly lighting it up, but I know you'll tell us all just how good his x/GF numbers are. Regardless, he needs to score. He's paid as our 1C & the team relies on him to produce.
What is it that you guys dont understand? I am not claiming he is lighting it up or that he is back to form. I am challenging those (you among them) who claim he is the worst player on the team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad