Speculation: Roster Building Thread: Part XLVII

[Irishguy42]

It would have been very very embarrassing had I posted that and then been wrong.

Go big or go home. Leave it, no balls

Should have just said @Amazing Kreiderman smoked crack because he shaved his head

 

[Ghost of jas]

He did center Tkachuk this year as well. Can't give an accurate assessment of how much or how long.

From a style standpoint, he's more of a finisher than a straight playmaker. So in that sense, like Zibanejad, he'd pair well with a playmaking winger.

I mean, in theory, this is a guy you pair with someone like Lafreniere.

Or Panarin

 

[Edge]

Buch and that Carolina 1st would be in the theoretical deal. That's the start. Maybe another prospect in there, but nothing major.

I'd imagine Buch, Carolina pick, and then either a prospect or a young roster player.

 

[bobbop]

So he went from RangerMan -> RangerBoy. He does not understand human aging.

I often wondered if he was Ranger Man at RFC. I posted there for years.

 

[Ghost of jas]

It would cost more than Buch, I can tell you that much.

I would probably pay that price.

 

[RangersFan1994]

Buch and that Carolina 1st would be in the theoretical deal. That's the start. Maybe another prospect in there, but nothing major.

Buch Strome for Bennett Lindholm and Dube?

 

[Edge]

Or Panarin

Bingo.

And this just kind of reaffirms the message that it's perfectly alright if our wingers are playmakers. It just means we have to have the right centers.

 

[Edge]

I would probably pay that price.

Honestly, I suspect the Rangers would as well.

What Calgary would be looking for, if anything? Not entirely sure.

 

[Ola]

Lindholm has been skating hard in Sweden the entire spring and summer. He has been on fire this POs.

 

[Ghost of jas]

Honestly, I suspect the Rangers would as well.

What Calgary would be looking for, if anything? Not entirely sure.

I’ll throw an idea out there...DeAngelo and Buch for Hanifan and Lindholm...the Rangers get the two exact players they need to fill their lineup.

 

[LaffyTaffy]

I'd imagine Buch, Carolina pick, and then either a prospect or a young roster player.

Buch+CAR 1st+Howden/Lemieux/Gauthier I would do any of those. When you get into the Chytils and Kravtsovs is where I stop being interested in the deal. If they do not like that and insist on a prospect instead then I would offer Robertson as the absolute highest value prospect available.

 

[Edge]

I’ll throw an idea out there...DeAngelo and Buch for Hanifan and Lindholm...the Rangers get the two exact players they need to fill their lineup.

I....would be very open to that.

 

[LaffyTaffy]

I....would very open to that.

Sign me up too

 

[NYR Viper]

I....would very open to that.

That would be an intriguing deal for sure. Also 'lol' at Hanifan and Lindholm being traded together...again

 

[HatTrick Swayze]

I’ll throw an idea out there...DeAngelo and Buch for Hanifan and Lindholm...the Rangers get the two exact players they need to fill their lineup.

Very much on the keep ADA train but that’s the kind of deal I could support.

 

[JESSEWENEEDTOCOOK]

I’ll throw an idea out there...DeAngelo and Buch for Hanifan and Lindholm...the Rangers get the two exact players they need to fill their lineup.

Legit proposal. It’s basically ADA for Lindholm and Buch for Hanifin. Very fair.

love it. Does Lindholm play wing for the flames though? I think we’d want him at C

 

[Fitzy]

Sam Bennett didn't kill penalties this year for Carolina. That's a red flag for me for a bottom 6 pivot.

 

[Amazing Kreiderman]

Go big or go home. Leave it, no balls

Should have just said @Amazing Kreiderman smoked crack because he shaved his head

#NoHairForLafreniere

 

[Trxjw]

I’ll throw an idea out there...DeAngelo and Buch for Hanifan and Lindholm...the Rangers get the two exact players they need to fill their lineup.

I'd gladly take that deal. I think it skews a bit in our favor though. As great as Tony was this year, it's a big ask from Calgary.

 

[JESSEWENEEDTOCOOK]

Holy shit just looked up Lindholm’s stats and the dude has basically play SEVEN NHL seasons I swear it feels like he got drafted yesterday wtf

 

[JimmyG89]

I’ll throw an idea out there...DeAngelo and Buch for Hanifan and Lindholm...the Rangers get the two exact players they need to fill their lineup.

I think it sounds ideal for us, but for Calgary, which is a team that has a hard time getting free agents to go an play there, TDA and Buch don't have nearly the team control for them. Tony has 3 years before UFA, Buch I think is the same, if not 2 years. DeAngelo is probably the most valuable player there, but I have a hard time with this being the way Calgary would go.

I would think they would move one of those, but not both.

 

[Amazing Kreiderman]

Sam Bennett didn't kill penalties this year for Carolina. That's a red flag for me for a bottom 6 pivot.

Did he kill any for Calgary?

 

[Ghost of jas]

Legit proposal. It’s basically ADA for Lindholm and Buch for Hanifin. Very fair.

love it. Does Lindholm play wing for the flames though? I think we’d want him at C

You're getting him to play center.

 

[GoAwayPanarin]

Sam Bennett didn't kill penalties this year for Carolina. That's a red flag for me for a bottom 6 pivot.

I automatically thought this was a @Thirty One post

 

[Ghost of jas]

I'd gladly take that deal. I think it skews a bit in our favor though. As great as Tony was this year, it's a big ask from Calgary.

We could throw in a prospect to even it up.