Speculation: Roster Building Thread - Part XIII (Nanaki edition)

Status
Not open for further replies.

eco's bones

Registered User
Jul 21, 2005
26,907
13,956
Elmira NY
Things very rarely happened according to script. You have all kinds of hopes but shit happens and much more often than not they get dialed back. Last year the regular season was just fantastic beyond anything that I and I'm sure others were expecting which naturally led to bigger hopes for the postseason which started out great too.

Coming off of that with pretty close to the same team expectations for this year were pretty high but so far the regular season compared to last year has been opposite day. I'm kind of expecting some moves are going to be made. It might not be the most underwhelming players because those guys might be the hardest to move. Shit happens.

What I will say is the Rangers aren't going to punish their team into success. Shit don't work that way. You punish your workforce (and we're not just talking about a hockey team) and you almost always end up with even worse results and you create animosity and resentment. So what you do do needs to be thoughtful or considered. It seems to me that this team has lost some faith in itself. That might go on for a while or even take this entire year to get over......consider also that the 1993 Rangers team had underwhelming performances from any number of players including their big stars and did not make the playoffs.
 

Kocur Dill

picklicious
Feb 7, 2010
3,215
1,712
Have we *ever* tried Schneider with Fox?

He can play LD effectively.

He's defensively responsible.

Is an above average skater who can keep up with Fox and cover him so he can take more chances.

Has no problem playing Bad Cop. Not that Fox is a wimp, but you dont want him in the box or injured.

Can pass effectively. Is a rare throwback that has an effective slapper. To play offhand and be that option for Fox is a huge asset. Playing off hand with his back to the boards is a cheat to get back on defence quicker.

Fox is being held back by having to be a "complete" defensman becasue of inadequate partners on this roster.

Miller should have been a good fit. Hes athletic enough. Has offensive instincts. But lacks defensive zone reading, has no will to be the Bad Cop, and clearly wasnt effective when given the opportunity.

I know we have a pleathora of issues. But getting the D figured out should be paramount.

Before we go haphazardly plugging in whatever vet scraps some other GM "may" be willing to trade for whoever we can jimmy-rig out the door through a contract loophole.

It may be prudent to exhaust ALL options.

At a minimum, we "could" ride out the season with...

Miller-Trouba
Schneider-Fox
Jones-Mancini (sheltered 8-10m/per/g)

Then re-evaluate if Trouba and/or Miller need to be moved, and we have the 10% cap overage to work with as well as UFA, Draft, summer inactivity.

Get assets now for Lindgren. He's a worthwhile rental and the room (kids we want to take leadership at some point) needs him elsewhere. IMO, he makes too much to be resigned and giving him a salary reduction isnt gonna work for multiple reasons.

And honestly, i'd seriously consider taking the C from Trouba and putting it on Trocheck. He'd be my interm Captain till contract runs out and hopefully one of the kids steps up then. There is nothing written in stone that a player cant be stripped of the Captaincy while they are still on the roster. Im pretty sure they did it to Marleau in SJ iirc and he was the drafted golden boy there.

Just my $0.02c
 
  • Like
Reactions: skipmowerman

UnparalledPark

Registered User
Jun 15, 2022
141
113
I've been passing on the Stars' posts to a friend who's a Dallas fan....here's his take on what we've commented on (especially Bourque):

"absolutely not on Bourque, Dallas’ blue chip prospects pool is about ¼ inch deep, and Dallas needs zero more veteran forwards. I wouldn’t really expect them to add a forward at all to replace Seguin this year, they’ll take the position that it’s time for others to step up."

Thought I'd pass this along.
Makes sense. That’s why I believe it will take a Schneider, Miller or Laf added to any deal to get a young talented C or LD, though to be honest I’m not a big fan of Bourque anyway. I think Kreider could really help Dallas too. Oh well, their loss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RangersFan1994

Clark Kellogg

NYU Film Student
Sponsor
Aug 2, 2013
7,776
10,142
Vermont, USA
After 1 Wolf Pack up 1-0 @ Bridgeport.
Belzile with the goal.
Harland in goal.
Chmler on PP1
Rempe having some good offensive opportunities. Set up a tic-tac-toe play with Mancini that didn’t hit net.
Matt also hit the crossbar bar on his last rush.
 

JCProdigy

Registered User
Apr 4, 2002
2,832
3,068
I want what I want
Things very rarely happened according to script. You have all kinds of hopes but shit happens and much more often than not they get dialed back. Last year the regular season was just fantastic beyond anything that I and I'm sure others were expecting which naturally led to bigger hopes for the postseason which started out great too.

Coming off of that with pretty close to the same team expectations for this year were pretty high but so far the regular season compared to last year has been opposite day. I'm kind of expecting some moves are going to be made. It might not be the most underwhelming players because those guys might be the hardest to move. Shit happens.

What I will say is the Rangers aren't going to punish their team into success. Shit don't work that way. You punish your workforce (and we're not just talking about a hockey team) and you almost always end up with even worse results and you create animosity and resentment. So what you do do needs to be thoughtful or considered. It seems to me that this team has lost some faith in itself. That might go on for a while or even take this entire year to get over......consider also that the 1993 Rangers team had underwhelming performances from any number of players including their big stars and did not make the playoffs.
When somebody said they'd never seen this before during their Ranger fandom, the 92-93 team immediately came to mind. I was a kid then. Team coming off a President's Trophy run, losing to the eventual SC champs and really talented, they started off "ok" in the first month but nothing ever really came together and the wheels came off as the season went along. Injuries played a part (The famous Leetch injury) but it's still crazy how that team missed the playoffs entirely. That year sandwiched in between two of the best seasons in franchise history.

NHL-wise and more recently you can look at the Pens who in 15-16 came out the gate slow to only take off and win the cup after Sullivan took the helm. Hell, the Panthers had one of the best regular seasons of all time in 21-22. Hired Maurice for the following year, then friggin backed their way into the playoffs (needed Isles and Pens BOTH to lose on last day of season!) to get hot and go to the finals, before winning it last year.

Note: not saying this team compares to those Rangers teams, nor the Pens/Panthers. But shit can spiral for a multitude of reasons despite talent being present.
 

Clark Kellogg

NYU Film Student
Sponsor
Aug 2, 2013
7,776
10,142
Vermont, USA
After 1 Wolf Pack up 1-0 @ Bridgeport.
Belzile with the goal.
Harland in goal.
Chmler on PP1
Rempe having some good offensive opportunities. Set up a tic-tac-toe play with Mancini that didn’t hit net.
Matt also hit the crossbar bar on his last rush.
Just realized I posted this in the wrong thread but since I’m here I’ll pass this on.
Team dressed 7 d-men but what gave me a double take is that Mancini is paired with Scanlin .
Scanlin is playing on the right and Mancini is playing on the left. Either the coach has lost his mind or they’re is a reason linked to an upcoming move.
I’m going to go with insane, because Robertson is also playing the right side even with Fitzgerald and Ruhwedel in the lineup.
 

Shesterkybomb

Registered User
Dec 30, 2016
16,789
18,099
After a few days of thinking about this, we may as well pull the trigger on a new coaching staff. It's one thing when a guy or two is in free fall but now it seems all our best players are. I mean panarin trochek and Lafreniere started out really good but even they've fallen off. It's time, the coaches have no answers, the team has tuned them out imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: leetch99

Boris Zubov

No relation to Sergei, Joe
May 6, 2016
19,418
27,199
Back on the east coast
Now I truly feel old -- I was 43 in 1993
9cdb4410-0987-424b-a8e5-a3aba0c80e8b_text.gif
 

Jim Ramsay

Registered User
Jul 1, 2003
906
1,011
Warwick, NY
After a few days of thinking about this, we may as well pull the trigger on a new coaching staff. It's one thing when a guy or two is in free fall but now it seems all our best players are. I mean panarin trochek and Lafreniere started out really good but even they've fallen off. It's time, the coaches have no answers, the team has tuned them out imo.

Why let these same players dictate that they get a new coach every other year?? The whole act is old and disappointing at this point.

Some players just need to be purged
 

McRanger92

Registered User
Jun 7, 2017
12,157
22,860
When somebody said they'd never seen this before during their Ranger fandom, the 92-93 team immediately came to mind. I was a kid then. Team coming off a President's Trophy run, losing to the eventual SC champs and really talented, they started off "ok" in the first month but nothing ever really came together and the wheels came off as the season went along. Injuries played a part (The famous Leetch injury) but it's still crazy how that team missed the playoffs entirely. That year sandwiched in between two of the best seasons in franchise history.

NHL-wise and more recently you can look at the Pens who in 15-16 came out the gate slow to only take off and win the cup after Sullivan took the helm. Hell, the Panthers had one of the best regular seasons of all time in 21-22. Hired Maurice for the following year, then friggin backed their way into the playoffs (needed Isles and Pens BOTH to lose on last day of season!) to get hot and go to the finals, before winning it last year.

Note: not saying this team compares to those Rangers teams, nor the Pens/Panthers. But shit can spiral for a multitude of reasons despite talent being present.

Just watched the 04 Red Sox documentary on Netflix. Highly recommend. The Rangers have some similarities to that team. Point being, the season isn’t over and the Rangers are too good
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad