I'm sorry, I just didn't see it. He played good games. He played plenty of poor games too. Even the most objective Ranger fans will tell you that Callahan wasn't Callahan this season. You pointed out five or six games, in his 50+ games with the team this season. That's not exactly a selling point. I get what your saying. But for every game he busted his ass, he took a night off or was a complete non-factor for a game. He had too many games this season where he was a complete non-factor.
He wasn't the same player this season. I'm sorry, I've always been a fan of him, but I can objectively say I don't think he was the same player he was even a year ago (and I thought last season he left something to be desired too).