lidstromiscool
Registered User
- May 5, 2007
- 1,800
- 1,205
Where would he go in the 2017 draft? Seems like a lot of D prospects in this draft would be the top pick of last years draft
Wilde had a fantastic game today. Definitely there are defensive issues and sometimes he looks a little clumsy, but this guy is a potential star. The real definition of a boom-bust prospect. Could be a star #1D, could flame out of hockey. I honestly have no idea. But his game today was excellent.
He had some defensive miscues in the game tonight, too, but was bailed out by his goaltender Drew DeRidder. The offensive talent is there, but he's a big liability on defense. Definitely a boom/bust prospect.
He had a couple miscues, but he more than made up for it offensively. I wouldn't call him a liability, but defense isn't his strength.
I'm trying to decide who I like the most out of Wilde, K'Andre Miller, and Mattias Samuelsson. I'm leaning towards Miller>Wilde>Samuelsson but I could see an argument for any of them. I think all of them should go between 15-25ish.
I think his defense is a liability, but he's 6'2, 195. I think teams would be drafting him hoping he could turn into a good defensive player.
I would say that the order I have those three in is Wilde, Samuelsson, Miller for draft rankings. If its who's the best now, Samuelsson, Wilde, Miller. I would add Emberson into this discussion, as well, he goes pretty underrated. I'd probably have him fourth in draft rankings, but I'd have him at least 3rd in current play, and maybe 2nd.
Samuelsson is so solid defensively. Gives up nearly nothing, and there's some offense there. I don't think there's a defenseman in this draft who defends better than him, besides Dahlin. After that, its mostly potential with Wilde and Miller. I think Wilde has a better shot and is more skilled, although Miller has some skill, as well. I also think he might be further along in his development than Miller.
Samuelsson is the best right now, arguably, but I’m not so sure what his upside is. I’m not convinced he has legit top-pairing potential. I think the other two do, even if they’re more risky. I personally prefer guys with upside rather than “safe” guys.
Wilde is not a defensive liability nor does he have "low iq" . He's a full on risk-taker, he's going to get burned at times, he's going to make mistakes. I love this guy, he's always so active, so involved and he's the center of the play on most nights.
He's a low IQ player and a defensive liability if youre willing to say Burns, Subban, Karlsson and co are too.
I would pick Miller over M.Samuelsson and Wilde without any hesitation, that kid is the best all around defenseman of the 3 by a good margin and has some untapped offensive potential, I see Miller as a very solid 2nd pairing defenseman who does everything well, it will be interesting to see how his offensive game evolve since he is a former foward that was converted in defenseman about 3 years ago, its crazy to think how solid and composed he already is when you think about it.. Wilde is more purely skilled offensively but makes some real dumb plays every games, I think his IQ is definitely in question here and I think he isnt dominant enough offensively to make up for his dumb moments.. I see a kid with high bust potential, thats why I have Miller over him on my list.. Mathias Samuelsson has a little bit more offense to his game than Miller right now, but Miller is much more composed and better defensively.. In Matthias I see a guy who might not be good enough offensively to be an offensive player at the next level and a guy who might not be good enough defensively to be relied on..
Miller
Wilde
Samuelsson
As a former season ticket holder, I miss them, too. I am just grateful that Pete Karmanos sold the arena to USA Hockey instead of a developer who would have bulldozed the building to make room for another commercial development that this area doesn't need.The US Team is okay. But man, i miss the Whalers. Off topic, apologies......
I would pick Miller over M.Samuelsson and Wilde without any hesitation, that kid is the best all around defenseman of the 3 by a good margin and has some untapped offensive potential, I see Miller as a very solid 2nd pairing defenseman who does everything well, it will be interesting to see how his offensive game evolve since he is a former foward that was converted in defenseman about 3 years ago, its crazy to think how solid and composed he already is when you think about it.. Wilde is more purely skilled offensively but makes some real dumb plays every games, I think his IQ is definitely in question here and I think he isnt dominant enough offensively to make up for his dumb moments.. I see a kid with high bust potential, thats why I have Miller over him on my list.. Mathias Samuelsson has a little bit more offense to his game than Miller right now, but Miller is much more composed and better defensively.. In Matthias I see a guy who might not be good enough offensively to be an offensive player at the next level and a guy who might not be good enough defensively to be relied on..
Miller
Wilde
Samuelsson
His defensive play is still a weakness, IMO. He makes a lot of poor decisions and gets himself out of position. He needs a lot of work in this area.
The Draft Analyst | 2018 Draft: U18 Five Nations Recap and Scouting ReportsI'm baffled how you've decided Miller is the best of the three defensively. I think he's the worst of the three defensively right now.
This player is a 6'2 200 RH shot defenseman.