Were the votes lost? Too bad because last time I checked I was the only one to vote F and there were 2-3 Ds at most. Well anyway let's see if they can get their shit together to eke out even one series win.
Rate Trelivings 2025 Tdl
- Thread starter Torontonian
- Start date
At the time of the trade deadline I said an A. I was pretty excited about both adds.
After Laughton got moved down to 4c, it’s hard to keep that same opinion.
I don’t think we addressed our needs which was 3c/depth scoring, although we did pick up a long term RD.
Because we got Carlo I’ll still give the deadline a B. The Laughton deal doesn’t look good though and we should have went after Granlund and Luke Schenn instead imo.
After Laughton got moved down to 4c, it’s hard to keep that same opinion.
I don’t think we addressed our needs which was 3c/depth scoring, although we did pick up a long term RD.
Because we got Carlo I’ll still give the deadline a B. The Laughton deal doesn’t look good though and we should have went after Granlund and Luke Schenn instead imo.
CabanaBoy5
Registered User
I gave him a B+ because we didn't get a scorer for the second line. I still like the Carlo trade, but the criticisms of him being a big guy who doesn't use his size seems to be true. The Laughton trade has turned out to be a fleecing for the Flyers. I just don't see what this guy offers and who thought he'd be a good 3C. I'd give him a B- as of today.
I gave the deals a B at the time. I liked the acquisitions and the term but thought we gave up a bit too much to rate them any higher.
Looking back now I'm much less happy about it but really that has more to do with the team's terrible play than disappointment with the new players.
Looking back now I'm much less happy about it but really that has more to do with the team's terrible play than disappointment with the new players.
