I'll say this, even though it's a big overpayment, they didn't give Barclay this money to be a 4th liner. He's going to be a first option penalty killer and consistently in the top 9, playing big minutes like he did for Tampa Bay down the stretch.
As a contender you want three scoring lines, but you can accomplish this without every top 9 forward being a finesse guy. Goodrow with two skill guys provides a bit of balance.
The big question now is how his body holds up over the duration of the contract.