I swear if he wasn't English he'd be considered half the player he is now by the media.
He delivers set pieces - and that's it.
I hope Spurs can give City a fight in the quarters - and get past them, but City have had Spurs' number since Pep came in.
He is not terrible all the time. And his crossing really is exceptional for a full back - not only at set pieces. He hits the ball so so sweetly. But playing for a team fighting for titles (or trying to) he just isn't consistent enough - and those individual mistakes in big games are just too costly. If you play for a mid table team you don't really expect points against the best so if you make a big individual mistake it hasn't really cost you anything. You move on and the next big game a Trippier cross might bring you a surprise win. All perfectly acceptable. Basically the way Spurs used to be.
I don't know how his general reputation is. Probably a bit hyped after the WC (which he played very well in - to his credit - he surprised me). Spurs bought him cheaply from Burnley as a backup kind of player. He is a decent that suddenly became the English first choice in a bit of a WC run. And with Aurier being a huge disappointment at Spurs he then found himself in a key role both for club and country. All fairly random. I can't really blame him for not coping with responsibilities he was never really expected to have. I would have no issues with him as a 2nd choice - even if Pochettino is a bit stupid when it comes to full back - they usually play every other game regardless when both alternatives are fit.
What is so surprising with his mistakes is that he always seems fairly intelligent in interviews. He is quite well spoken for a football player (bar is not high). He also seems to be quite disciplined. His mistakes are not down to laziness or lack of attention (the latter being quite typical for Aurier). If he was younger I would have expected them to disappear as he got more and more experience, but obviously that is not likely as he is closing in on 30.
The last game in October wasn't terribly one sided between Spurs and City, but good old Trippier made a huge mistake so 0-1 after 5 mins.... two premier league meetings before that City completely out-classed Spurs. I expect more of the same even if Spurs are quite decent when fit and confident. Haven't seen much of that this season though. Beat Chelsea, but other than that they have rarely played well against good teams. BVB is a good team, but not at the time Spurs played them. Barcelona obviously are very good, and I think Spurs did very well in the away leg, but clearly Barcelona didn't care much.