TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
I would take Catton over Eiserman today.
Post your 2024 Draft List
- Thread starter GermanSpitfire
- Start date
Dirtyf1ghter
Registered User
- Aug 7, 2019
- 2,592
- 1,694
Eiserman is very clearly above Catton. He has more elite characteristics and Catton suffers in physical commitment. There are more doubts about him. Eiserman, it's very easy to see him become an elite scorer. The teams that are in the race to select 2nd selected top 4 last year. So there is a good chance that Eiserman plays next to Bedard/Carlsson/Fantilli and Smith. He's going to have fun next to one of these players.
landy92mack29
Registered User
1-Berkly Catton Center Spokane Chiefs Top 3
2-Carter Yakemchuk RHD Calgary Hitmen Top 10
3-Andrew Basha Winger Medicine Hat Tigers 15-25
4-Ryder Ritchie Winger Prince Albert Raiders 15-25
5-Tig Iginla Center Kelowna Rockets 15-25
6-Tanner Howe Forward Regina Pats 15-25
7-Cayden Lindstrom Forward Medicine Hat Tigers 20-30
8-Charlie Elick RHD Brandon Wheat Kings 25-40
9-Colton Roberts RHD Vancouver Giants 2nd
10-Terik Parascak Winger Prince George Cougars 2nd
11-Miguel Marques Winger Lethbridge Hurricanes 2-3
12-Clarke Caswell Winger Swift Current Broncos 2-3
13-Adam Jecho Center Edmonton Oil Kings 2-3
14-Julius Miettinen Winger Everett Silvertips 2-3
15-Ollie Josephson Center Red Deer Rebels 3-4
16-Max Curran Center Tri-City Americans 3-4
17-Tarin Smith LHD Everett Silvertips 3-4
18-Carson Wetsch Center Calgary Hitmen 4-5
19-Miles Cooper Center Wenatchee Wild 4-5
20-Dawson Cowan Goalie Spokane Chiefs 4-5
21-Harrison Brunicke RHD Kamloops Blazers 4-5
22-Tomas Mrsic Center Medicine Hat Tigers 4-5
23-Diego Buttazzoni Center Portland Winterhawks 4-5
24-Evan Gardner Goalie Saskatoon Blades 5-7
25-Chase Wutzke Goalie Red Deer Rebels 5-7
26-Gavin Hodnett Winger Edmonton Oil Kings 5-7
27-Jesse Heslop Winger Everett Silvertips 5-7
28-Will McIsaac RHD Spokane Chiefs 5-7
29-Josh Zakreski Winger Portland Winterhawks 5-7
30-Hiroki Gojsic Winger Kelowna Rockets 5-7
2-Carter Yakemchuk RHD Calgary Hitmen Top 10
3-Andrew Basha Winger Medicine Hat Tigers 15-25
4-Ryder Ritchie Winger Prince Albert Raiders 15-25
5-Tig Iginla Center Kelowna Rockets 15-25
6-Tanner Howe Forward Regina Pats 15-25
7-Cayden Lindstrom Forward Medicine Hat Tigers 20-30
8-Charlie Elick RHD Brandon Wheat Kings 25-40
9-Colton Roberts RHD Vancouver Giants 2nd
10-Terik Parascak Winger Prince George Cougars 2nd
11-Miguel Marques Winger Lethbridge Hurricanes 2-3
12-Clarke Caswell Winger Swift Current Broncos 2-3
13-Adam Jecho Center Edmonton Oil Kings 2-3
14-Julius Miettinen Winger Everett Silvertips 2-3
15-Ollie Josephson Center Red Deer Rebels 3-4
16-Max Curran Center Tri-City Americans 3-4
17-Tarin Smith LHD Everett Silvertips 3-4
18-Carson Wetsch Center Calgary Hitmen 4-5
19-Miles Cooper Center Wenatchee Wild 4-5
20-Dawson Cowan Goalie Spokane Chiefs 4-5
21-Harrison Brunicke RHD Kamloops Blazers 4-5
22-Tomas Mrsic Center Medicine Hat Tigers 4-5
23-Diego Buttazzoni Center Portland Winterhawks 4-5
24-Evan Gardner Goalie Saskatoon Blades 5-7
25-Chase Wutzke Goalie Red Deer Rebels 5-7
26-Gavin Hodnett Winger Edmonton Oil Kings 5-7
27-Jesse Heslop Winger Everett Silvertips 5-7
28-Will McIsaac RHD Spokane Chiefs 5-7
29-Josh Zakreski Winger Portland Winterhawks 5-7
30-Hiroki Gojsic Winger Kelowna Rockets 5-7
First Round Locks:
1. Macklin Celebrini
2. Artyom Levshunov
3. Berkly Catton
4. Sam Dickinson
5. Zeev Buium
6. Cayden Lindstrom
7. Konsta Helenius
8. Cole Eiserman
9. Ivan Demidov
10. Anton Silyaev
11. Zayne Parekh
12. Carter Yakemchuk
13. Michael Brandsegg-Nygard
14. Adam Jiricek
15. Aron Kiviharju
The Others:
16. Liam Greentree
17. Trevor Connelly
18. Emil Hemming
19. Ryder Ritchie
20. Henry Mews
21. Igor Chernyshov
22. Tij Iginla
23. Nikita Artamonov
24. Andrew Basha
25. Sacha Boisvert
26. Terik Parascak
27. Charlie Elick
28. Cole Hutson
29. Jesse Pulkkinen
30. Leo Sahlin Wallenius
31. Maxim Massé
Castle8130
Registered User
- May 9, 2017
- 3,017
- 2,527
I highly doubt Kiviharju goes in the 1st round. Undersized and slow is not a favorable combination for NHL teams
Pavel Buchnevich
"Pavel Buchnevich The Fake"
Castle8130
Registered User
- May 9, 2017
- 3,017
- 2,527
I'm not disputing the talent. He is just the complete opposite of what NHL teams desire
TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
End of Nov:
Celebrini
Catton
Levshunov
Eiserman
Helenius
Demidov
Dickinson
Yakemchuk
Lindstrom
Silayev
Buium
Still going on watching games.
Update to January:
Celebrini
Catton
Levshunov
Dickinson
Lindstrom
Silayev
Demidov
Buium
Helenius
Yakemchuk
Eiserman
Greentree
Basha
Iginla
Connelly
Parekh
Jiricek
Ritchie
Brandsegg-Nygard
Still working on filling out a complete 32 but I've seen everyone on this list play full games >= 7 times.
Celebrini
Catton
Levshunov
Eiserman
Helenius
Demidov
Dickinson
Yakemchuk
Lindstrom
Silayev
Buium
Still going on watching games.
Update to January:
Celebrini
Catton
Levshunov
Dickinson
Lindstrom
Silayev
Demidov
Buium
Helenius
Yakemchuk
Eiserman
Greentree
Basha
Iginla
Connelly
Parekh
Jiricek
Ritchie
Brandsegg-Nygard
Still working on filling out a complete 32 but I've seen everyone on this list play full games >= 7 times.
Last edited:
Sergei Shirokov
Registered User
1. Celebrini
2. Demidov
3. Catton
4. Lindstrom
5. Yakemchuk
6. Silayev
7. Dickinson
8. Helenius
9. Brandsegg-Nygard
10. Eiserman
11. Buium
12. Jiricek
13. Shuravin
14. Greentree
15. Parekh
Haven't quite gotten a full 32 yet. But this is where I'm at for the first half.
Hard to rank this year after Celebrini, especially the Dmen.
2. Demidov
3. Catton
4. Lindstrom
5. Yakemchuk
6. Silayev
7. Dickinson
8. Helenius
9. Brandsegg-Nygard
10. Eiserman
11. Buium
12. Jiricek
13. Shuravin
14. Greentree
15. Parekh
Haven't quite gotten a full 32 yet. But this is where I'm at for the first half.
Hard to rank this year after Celebrini, especially the Dmen.
Haven't had time to really dig through the youngsters earlier during this season due to work but initial list in tiers, most guys I have seen only like one game to have at least some idea so might be very hot takes(for example, I did not see what the buzz was with Lindström yet other than size), have to look more. Still guys that I want to see more(need to see more of most top d's for example) so not quite 32 players yet for me either.
Tier 1
Macklin Celebrini
Berkly Catton
Cole Eiserman
Tier 2
Sam Dickinson
Artyom Levshunov
Anton Silayev
Konsta Helenius
Ivan Demidov
Tier 3
Cayden Lindstrom
Zayne Parekh
Zeev Buium
Adam Jiricek
Tier 4
Tij Iginla
Trevor Connelly
Emil Hemming
Andrew Basha
Tanner Howe
Tier 5
Aron Kiviharju
Cole Hutson
Liam Greentree
Tier 1
Macklin Celebrini
Berkly Catton
Cole Eiserman
Tier 2
Sam Dickinson
Artyom Levshunov
Anton Silayev
Konsta Helenius
Ivan Demidov
Tier 3
Cayden Lindstrom
Zayne Parekh
Zeev Buium
Adam Jiricek
Tier 4
Tij Iginla
Trevor Connelly
Emil Hemming
Andrew Basha
Tanner Howe
Tier 5
Aron Kiviharju
Cole Hutson
Liam Greentree
Last edited:
Pavel Buchnevich
"Pavel Buchnevich The Fake"
January update.
2024 Draft List:
1. Mack Celebrini-C
2. Berkly Catton-C
3. Ivan Demidov-W
4. Artyom Levshunov-RHD
5. Cole Eiserman-W
6. Anton Silayev-LHD
7. Carter Yakemchuk-RHD
8. Sam Dickinson-LHD
9. Zeev Buium-LHD
10. Cayden Lindstrom-C
11. Adam Jiricek-RHD
12. Konsta Helenius-C
13. Aron Kiviharju-LHD
14. Nikita Artomonov-W
15. Michael Brandsegg Nygard-W
16. Henry Mews-RHD
17. Will Skahan-LHD
18. Igor Chernyshov-W
19. Matvei Shuravin-
20. Tij Iginla-C
21. Kamil Bednarik-C
22. Trevor Connelly-W
23. Zayne Parekh-RHD
24. Liam Greentree-W
25. Michael Hage-C
26. Leo Sahlin Wallenius-LHD
27. Charlie Elick-RHD
28. Cole Hutson-LHD
29. Sacha Boisvert-C
30. Ryder Ritchie-W
31. Maxim Masse-W
32. Emil Hemming-W
33. Mac Swanson-W
34. Veeti Vaisanen-LHD
35. Tory Pitner-RHD
36. Andrew Basha-W
36. Justin Poirier-W
37. Simon Zether-C
38. Alfons Freij-LHD
39. Yegor Surin-C
40. Tanner Howe-W
41. Terik Parascak-W
42. Luke Misa-C
43. Lucas Pettersson-C
44. Dean Letourneau-C
45. EJ Emery-RHD
46. Colton Roberts-RHD
47. Miguel Marques-W
48. Marek Vanacker-W
49. Niilopekka Muhonen-LHD
50. Sam O’Reilly-C
51. Dominik Badinka-RHD
52. Jett Luchanko-C
53. Leon Muggli-LHD
54. Adam Jecho-W
55. Noah Lapointe-LHD
56. Tomas Lavoie-RHD
57. Lucas Van Vliet-C
58. Timur Kol-LHD
59. Ben Danford-RHD
60. Christian Humphreys-W
61. Sebastian Soini-RHD
62. Aidan Park-C
63. Noel Fransen-LHD
64. Tarin Smith-LHD
32 Unordered HM’s (approximates a third round): Carter George (G), Eriks Mateiko (W), Melvin Fernstrom (W), Tomas Galvas (LHD), Anthony Cristoforo (RHD), Oskar Vuollet (W), Stian Solberg (LHD), Linus Eriksson (C), Aatos Koivu (C), Tuomas Suoniemi (C), Ivan Kornilov (RHD), Clarke Caswell (W), Max Plante (W), John Whipple (LHD), Nick Kempf (LHD), Mitja Jokinen (LHD), Ondrej Kos (W), Mikhail Yegorov (G), Teddy Stiga (W), Felix Lacerte (C), Austin Baker (C), Raoul Boilard (C), Alexandre Blais (W), Marcus Kearsey (LHD), Ryerson Leenders (G), Luca Marrelli (RHD), John Mustard (W), Artyom Shchuchinov (LHD), Lukas Fischer (LHD), Cole Beaudoin (C), Julius Miettinen (W), Karl Sterner (W)
1. Mack Celebrini-C
2. Berkly Catton-C
3. Ivan Demidov-W
4. Artyom Levshunov-RHD
5. Cole Eiserman-W
6. Anton Silayev-LHD
7. Carter Yakemchuk-RHD
8. Sam Dickinson-LHD
9. Zeev Buium-LHD
10. Cayden Lindstrom-C
11. Adam Jiricek-RHD
12. Konsta Helenius-C
13. Aron Kiviharju-LHD
14. Nikita Artomonov-W
15. Michael Brandsegg Nygard-W
16. Henry Mews-RHD
17. Will Skahan-LHD
18. Igor Chernyshov-W
19. Matvei Shuravin-
20. Tij Iginla-C
21. Kamil Bednarik-C
22. Trevor Connelly-W
23. Zayne Parekh-RHD
24. Liam Greentree-W
25. Michael Hage-C
26. Leo Sahlin Wallenius-LHD
27. Charlie Elick-RHD
28. Cole Hutson-LHD
29. Sacha Boisvert-C
30. Ryder Ritchie-W
31. Maxim Masse-W
32. Emil Hemming-W
33. Mac Swanson-W
34. Veeti Vaisanen-LHD
35. Tory Pitner-RHD
36. Andrew Basha-W
36. Justin Poirier-W
37. Simon Zether-C
38. Alfons Freij-LHD
39. Yegor Surin-C
40. Tanner Howe-W
41. Terik Parascak-W
42. Luke Misa-C
43. Lucas Pettersson-C
44. Dean Letourneau-C
45. EJ Emery-RHD
46. Colton Roberts-RHD
47. Miguel Marques-W
48. Marek Vanacker-W
49. Niilopekka Muhonen-LHD
50. Sam O’Reilly-C
51. Dominik Badinka-RHD
52. Jett Luchanko-C
53. Leon Muggli-LHD
54. Adam Jecho-W
55. Noah Lapointe-LHD
56. Tomas Lavoie-RHD
57. Lucas Van Vliet-C
58. Timur Kol-LHD
59. Ben Danford-RHD
60. Christian Humphreys-W
61. Sebastian Soini-RHD
62. Aidan Park-C
63. Noel Fransen-LHD
64. Tarin Smith-LHD
32 Unordered HM’s (approximates a third round): Carter George (G), Eriks Mateiko (W), Melvin Fernstrom (W), Tomas Galvas (LHD), Anthony Cristoforo (RHD), Oskar Vuollet (W), Stian Solberg (LHD), Linus Eriksson (C), Aatos Koivu (C), Tuomas Suoniemi (C), Ivan Kornilov (RHD), Clarke Caswell (W), Max Plante (W), John Whipple (LHD), Nick Kempf (LHD), Mitja Jokinen (LHD), Ondrej Kos (W), Mikhail Yegorov (G), Teddy Stiga (W), Felix Lacerte (C), Austin Baker (C), Raoul Boilard (C), Alexandre Blais (W), Marcus Kearsey (LHD), Ryerson Leenders (G), Luca Marrelli (RHD), John Mustard (W), Artyom Shchuchinov (LHD), Lukas Fischer (LHD), Cole Beaudoin (C), Julius Miettinen (W), Karl Sterner (W)
cheechoo
Lilje 4-ever
Castle8130
Registered User
- May 9, 2017
- 3,017
- 2,527
TLEH
Pronounced T-Lay
pretty good list this year pavel.
higher on Basha, Emery, Misa, but that is nitpicking.
GermanSpitfire
EU Video Scout for McKeen’s | Rest Easy #13
If anyone was interested in what my mid term top-32 was, here it is!
Man if the Habs cam get Demidov and Iginla. I would be very happy
GermanSpitfire
EU Video Scout for McKeen’s | Rest Easy #13
There’s a group of guys in the I’d say 20-50 range in my opinion that can easily be interchanged for one another on any given day. He is in that range, however I haven’t gotten many good looks of him so far this year so there is room for him to jump significantly when I dive deep into his game.
LeProspector
AINEC
- Feb 14, 2017
- 5,401
- 6,275
GermanSpitfire
EU Video Scout for McKeen’s | Rest Easy #13
Injury doesn’t help things, I also think he is the kind of player that is good at everything, but not good enough at one or two paticular skills to put him over the top. I think there are other defenders in the class that have those elite traits in their respective games that I would prefer to Jiricek.
Nice list German. You seems to like Dickinson. What do you think is his offensive ceiling ? Is he an Hanifin type of d-men at +/- 40 pts a year ? Or you think he can be better then that ?
1. Macklin Celebrini
2. Berkly Catton
3. Ivan Demidov
4. Artyom Levshunov
5. Cayden Lindstrom
6. Sam Dickinson
7. Anton Silayev
8. Cole Eiserman
9. Zeev Buium
10. Carter Yakemchuk
11. Konsta Helenius
12. Michael Brandsegg-Nygard
13. Trevor Connelly
14. Liam Greentree
15. Zayne Parekh
16. Adam Jiricek
17. Andrew Basha
18. Igor Chernyshov
19. Michael Hage
20. Sacha Boisvert
21. Tij Iginla
22. Nikita Artamonov
23. Henry Mews
24. Emil Hemming
25. Beckett Sennecke
26. Terik Parascak
27. Leo Sahlin-Wallenius
28. Charlie Elick
29. Matvei Shuravin
30. Ryder Ritchie
31. Jett Luchanko
32. Matvei Gridin
Second Round
Mac Swanson
Tanner Howe
Clark Caswell
Teddy Stiga
Max Plante
Alexandre Blais
Teddy Stiga
John Mustard
Ondrej Kos
Yegor Surin
Justin Poirer
Alexander Zetterberg
Topias Hynninen
Miguel Marques
Maxim Masse
Matvei Babenko
Carson Wetsch
Adam Jecho
Luke Misa
Kamil Bednarik
Cole Beaudoin
Maxmilian Curran
Christian Humphreys
Melvin Fernstrom
Simon Zether
Dean Letourneau
Aron Kiviharju
Cole Hutson
Tomas Galvas
Will Felicio
Veeti Vaisanen
Alfons Freij
John Whipple
Timur Kol
Will Skahan
Niilopekka Muhonen
Anthony Cristoforo
Tory Pitner
Dominik Badinka
Luca Marelli
Tomas Lavoie
EJ Emery
Carter George
Ryerson Leenders
2. Berkly Catton
3. Ivan Demidov
4. Artyom Levshunov
5. Cayden Lindstrom
6. Sam Dickinson
7. Anton Silayev
8. Cole Eiserman
9. Zeev Buium
10. Carter Yakemchuk
11. Konsta Helenius
12. Michael Brandsegg-Nygard
13. Trevor Connelly
14. Liam Greentree
15. Zayne Parekh
16. Adam Jiricek
17. Andrew Basha
18. Igor Chernyshov
19. Michael Hage
20. Sacha Boisvert
21. Tij Iginla
22. Nikita Artamonov
23. Henry Mews
24. Emil Hemming
25. Beckett Sennecke
26. Terik Parascak
27. Leo Sahlin-Wallenius
28. Charlie Elick
29. Matvei Shuravin
30. Ryder Ritchie
31. Jett Luchanko
32. Matvei Gridin
Second Round
Mac Swanson
Tanner Howe
Clark Caswell
Teddy Stiga
Max Plante
Alexandre Blais
Teddy Stiga
John Mustard
Ondrej Kos
Yegor Surin
Justin Poirer
Alexander Zetterberg
Topias Hynninen
Miguel Marques
Maxim Masse
Matvei Babenko
Carson Wetsch
Adam Jecho
Luke Misa
Kamil Bednarik
Cole Beaudoin
Maxmilian Curran
Christian Humphreys
Melvin Fernstrom
Simon Zether
Dean Letourneau
Aron Kiviharju
Cole Hutson
Tomas Galvas
Will Felicio
Veeti Vaisanen
Alfons Freij
John Whipple
Timur Kol
Will Skahan
Niilopekka Muhonen
Anthony Cristoforo
Tory Pitner
Dominik Badinka
Luca Marelli
Tomas Lavoie
EJ Emery
Carter George
Ryerson Leenders
Lots of amazing defenseman, but I remain high on both Catton, and Demidov. Even if they both end up on the wing, they have dynamic offensive skill that strongly suggest first-line talent.
The injury certainly doesn't help. Otherwise, it seems to me that the view of him is quite influenced by the fact that he often played with older players. When he played tournaments with the same age, it was pure dominance on his part.
