The leafs will have to acquire a defenseman this year. Unless Sandin takes a huge step it’s inevitable. I think we’ll see someone from bottom six moved out for a defenseman. Probably Ethan Bear
IMO Sandin is already better than Bear. Watched a decent bit of Bear in Edmonton, he's a borderline NHLer who makes a lot of mistakes. I'd say between Mete and Sandin, but closer to Mete. He's getting consistently healthy scratched in Carolina for mid-20s dmen who
themselves are borderline NHLers (Jalen Chatfield and Dylan Coghlan).
We aren't that hard up for a dman once Lily comes back:
Rielly - Brodie
Gio - Lily
Sandin - Holl
Depth: Mete, Benn, Dahlstrom, Kral
IR: Muzzin (zero read on whether he'll be back or not)
I think if we're making a move, it'd be more of a bigger splash than a depth guy like Bear. Think Holl and other assets (like picks/prospects) for a quality top 4 RD, or Sandin and other assets for a quality top 4 LD. But even without Muzzin we're already got 6 pretty decent dmen, and some decent depth beyond that in case of injuries, I don't see Bear adding much.
Personally though, I think D is the least of our concerns, if we're reasonably healthy. I think we stay steady until near the deadline, then assess:
- How is goaltending? Samsonov has been great so far, but will he keep it up? How about Murray? If goaltending is shaky that's target #1
- If goaltending is fine, then the main target is a winger. We've got 4 awesome forwards, then a sharp dropoff, our main achilles heal in the playoffs has been scoring depth, and that's likely to continue