I heard the Madden interview with Scuds and he was pretty honest about himself. Said positioning and playing it safe is what got him to the NHL and not really great talent. He explained that if he has time he looks to make a play (I laughed), but he more or less has to keep it simple. He said he felt he was a mobile guy when he came into the league and he was, but he knows he only limited years left now. Felt he can still skate well, which isn't entirely false.
The knock on Scuds has been the same since he came up through the ranks: he is offensively Pejorative Slured. It's just gotten worse with age now. He's a big liability with the puck on his stick, especially in the attacking zone.
I still think he is quite solid in his own end, but is he outstanding enough there to justify all of the plays that die on his stick in the other end? The contract is also an issue. If he was given a 2 year deal, it would have made sense, given the young kids in the system. But the long term deal he got, is probably the biggest reason people dislike Scuds. Well that and he is the artist known as the half board assassin.