Prospect Info: Pittsburgh Penguins Prospects Thread: 2023-2024 Edition

Status
Not open for further replies.

cygnus47

Registered User
Sep 14, 2013
7,607
2,709
In the discussion it also mentioned Mark Stone. Rossi, Strome, Stone, etc all highlight the idea that you can be an NHL regular and have success even if you're not an elite skater as long as you have several other tools that make up for it. Positioning, IQ, passing, shooting, and moving "good enough" can get him to where we need him to be.

Tavares made huge strides with his skating too, was the first one I thought of. He became an average+ NHL skater after being horrible his first couple years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lokomotiv15

Ulf5

Registered User
Feb 21, 2017
1,513
1,153
Another young player to WBS.
Mats Lindgren 19yo turns 20 in August


Originally drafted 2022 by the sabres .

WBS actually have some interesting players on AHL deals this year in Beck, Calvert, Klaasen and Lindgren.
Would be nice if some of them play good enough to earn an ELC contract later on.

Was pretty confident we would add another in Jelsma, but he hasn't signed yet, so I guess we'll see if it happens.
Got him not necessarily because he sucks but because he never agreed to a contract with Buffalo. So I guess there's a slim chance he doesn't suck and turns into something. 🤣
 

Jacob

as seen on TV
Feb 27, 2002
50,261
26,934
Certainly a large quantity of guys on AHL deals, hopefully a couple can earn NHL contracts.
 

Rudy Russo

Registered User
Mar 16, 2018
2,257
3,606
ZZYZX, California
Another young player to WBS.
Mats Lindgren 19yo turns 20 in August


Originally drafted 2022 by the sabres .

WBS actually have some interesting players on AHL deals this year in Beck, Calvert, Klaasen and Lindgren.
Would be nice if some of them play good enough to earn an ELC contract later on.

Was pretty confident we would add another in Jelsma, but he hasn't signed yet, so I guess we'll see if it happens.
The hockey writers in their 2022/2023 top ten Buffalo prospects had his at #10, but their 2023-2024 ranks he was not listed.
BufHockeyNow on 8/26/2023 had him at #21 in their prospect lists.
This is the write up from the hockey writers-
Lindgren was taken by Buffalo at this past summer’s draft in 2022 during the fourth round. Touted for his speed and offensive creativity, he projects to be a top-four defenseman that can move the puck and quarterback a power play. His skating is smooth and quick, but where he needs improvement is in his defensive awareness and size. He stands at 6-foot and weighs in at 176 pounds, so he will need to bulk up a bit in order to compete properly at the NHL level.
 

HandshakeLine

A real jerk thing
Nov 9, 2005
49,162
33,702
Praha, CZ
I feel that skating is simultaneously hideously overrated and also one of the hardest parts of the game to change, hence my asking. I just am skeptical whenever someone is like "well so and so just needs to get stronger/skate better/get a quicker release" at the age of 20-21.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andy99

HandshakeLine

A real jerk thing
Nov 9, 2005
49,162
33,702
Praha, CZ
In the discussion it also mentioned Mark Stone. Rossi, Strome, Stone, etc all highlight the idea that you can be an NHL regular and have success even if you're not an elite skater as long as you have several other tools that make up for it. Positioning, IQ, passing, shooting, and moving "good enough" can get him to where we need him to be.
I think there's also a huge assumption sometimes that speed is always going to be king in the NHL, and at some point, there's going to be a reaction against it. Teams are going to figure out that you can slow play down again, refs are going to stop calling penalties as much, and players are going to bulk up and play physical.
 

eXile3

Registered User
Dec 12, 2020
4,573
4,404
I feel that skating is simultaneously hideously overrated and also one of the hardest parts of the game to change, hence my asking. I just am skeptical whenever someone is like "well so and so just needs to get stronger/skate better/get a quicker release" at the age of 20-21.
I see it like drafting a QB or pitcher and trying to change their delivery. They’ve probably doing it that way for most, if not all their lives. Especially during developmental years. It’s going to be very hard to correct. That’s why I think a lot of players that have improved their skating has more to do with getting into a strength and conditioning program in the NHL or in college. They add speed and explosiveness by adding strength.

Just a theory of mine though.

I think there's also a huge assumption sometimes that speed is always going to be king in the NHL, and at some point, there's going to be a reaction against it. Teams are going to figure out that you can slow play down again, refs are going to stop calling penalties as much, and players are going to bulk up and play physical.
Why would the NHL allow that? Didn’t they break rating records in this years SCF? Neither the NFL nor the NBA regressed when they saw people wanted to see talented offensive players.
 

Randy Butternubs

Registurd User
Mar 15, 2008
30,447
22,390
Morningside
st ivany j
10​
pieniniemi e
9​
howe t
hallander f
8​
poulin s
7​
ilyin m
6​
murashov s

The top 5 and then the entire list with a little bit more info:

FI9H0nS.png


Text version:

rankplayerceilingpotentialmax p/82readinessoverallstd%
1yager bf - first - all star6.4533.458.289.6%
2blomqvist jgoalie - g nhl - starter5.6n/a7.057.187.8%
3pickering od - top - star5.4372.849.175.5%
4ponomaryov vf - second - two way4.6376.148.374.3%
5koivunen vf - second - scorer4.3356.748.073.8%
6murashov sgoalie - g nhl - starter5.4n/a3.945.670.2%
7ilyin mf - second - two way4.5375.744.468.4%
8poulin sf - third - complimentary3.3276.043.767.2%
9howe tf - second - two way4.3353.138.959.8%
10pieniniemi ed - middle - two way3.6244.837.858.2%
11gauthier tgoalie - g nhl - backup3.5n/a5.035.654.7%
12swanson mf - second - scorer4.3352.434.152.4%
13plante zf - second - scorer4.3352.133.852.0%
14jarventie ef - second - scorer4.3352.032.950.5%
15gruden jf - fourth - complimentary2.5215.532.750.4%
16kral fd - bottom - complimentary2.5175.932.650.1%
17brunicke hd - middle - two way3.6242.132.349.7%
18ludvig jd - bottom - defense only2.4165.532.049.2%
19broz tf - third - scorer3.4282.531.949.1%
20tankov kf - second - complimentary3.8312.531.248.0%
21belliveau id - bottom - complimentary2.5174.629.244.9%
22lucius cf - third - two way3.2262.528.944.5%
23foster cf - third - two way3.2262.628.744.1%
24vaisanen jd - bottom - two way2.7182.424.637.9%
25pietila cd - bottom - two way2.7182.124.537.7%
26harding fd - bottom - two way2.7182.023.235.6%
27ansons rf - extra - complimentary1.5124.522.534.6%
28yoder cf - fourth - two way2.4201.620.932.2%
29devlin lf - fourth - two way2.4201.220.231.0%
30laatsch dd - bottom - defense only2.2151.819.429.8%
31kangas kd - bottom - defense only2.2151.518.728.8%
32frasca jminor - two way0.874.116.525.4%
 

Ulf5

Registered User
Feb 21, 2017
1,513
1,153
The top 5 and then the entire list with a little bit more info:

FI9H0nS.png


Text version:

rankplayerceilingpotentialmax p/82readinessoverallstd%
1yager bf - first - all star6.4533.458.289.6%
2blomqvist jgoalie - g nhl - starter5.6n/a7.057.187.8%
3pickering od - top - star5.4372.849.175.5%
4ponomaryov vf - second - two way4.6376.148.374.3%
5koivunen vf - second - scorer4.3356.748.073.8%
6murashov sgoalie - g nhl - starter5.4n/a3.945.670.2%
7ilyin mf - second - two way4.5375.744.468.4%
8poulin sf - third - complimentary3.3276.043.767.2%
9howe tf - second - two way4.3353.138.959.8%
10pieniniemi ed - middle - two way3.6244.837.858.2%
11gauthier tgoalie - g nhl - backup3.5n/a5.035.654.7%
12swanson mf - second - scorer4.3352.434.152.4%
13plante zf - second - scorer4.3352.133.852.0%
14jarventie ef - second - scorer4.3352.032.950.5%
15gruden jf - fourth - complimentary2.5215.532.750.4%
16kral fd - bottom - complimentary2.5175.932.650.1%
17brunicke hd - middle - two way3.6242.132.349.7%
18ludvig jd - bottom - defense only2.4165.532.049.2%
19broz tf - third - scorer3.4282.531.949.1%
20tankov kf - second - complimentary3.8312.531.248.0%
21belliveau id - bottom - complimentary2.5174.629.244.9%
22lucius cf - third - two way3.2262.528.944.5%
23foster cf - third - two way3.2262.628.744.1%
24vaisanen jd - bottom - two way2.7182.424.637.9%
25pietila cd - bottom - two way2.7182.124.537.7%
26harding fd - bottom - two way2.7182.023.235.6%
27ansons rf - extra - complimentary1.5124.522.534.6%
28yoder cf - fourth - two way2.4201.620.932.2%
29devlin lf - fourth - two way2.4201.220.231.0%
30laatsch dd - bottom - defense only2.2151.819.429.8%
31kangas kd - bottom - defense only2.2151.518.728.8%
32frasca jminor - two way0.874.116.525.4%
Any past lists where all the prospects have "graduated"? Asking for a friend.
 

chethejet

Registered User
Feb 4, 2012
8,730
1,933
Dubas knows the key to the Pens going forward is going from all in to going to prospects for the coming transition of the roster to younger talent. For now, the trend is building the farm system and scouting, development and competition for roster spots. I do think Pens were looking for RH D this draft as a priority despite the best player available mantra, Hopefully next draft, RW is the priority.
 

Jag68Sid87

Sullivan gots to go!
Oct 1, 2003
36,029
1,875
Montreal, QC
The Penguins are at 49/50 contracts, yet they signed Howe first. Could be that they view him as more NHL ready or something completely different like Howe being in debt and needing the money asap. Regardless, Yager isn't getting signed until a contract gets moved out

OR, they sign him as the 50th contract. Who is more important than him for the No. 50 contract?
 

Jag68Sid87

Sullivan gots to go!
Oct 1, 2003
36,029
1,875
Montreal, QC
Obviously, you can make the Hall of Fame despite being a bad skater. Former Penguin Luc Robitaille is the best example, of course. For you old timers out there, Steve Shutt was a great goal-scoring winger who had the choppiest skating stride I think I have ever seen in my life. Did not hurt him.

The issue is the coach. Most, if not all, players whose skating is considered below-average have really struggled under Sullivan. Like, you basically have no shot with this system if your skating is sub-par. I always go back to Tanner Pearson when talking about this. He was a very good player before Sullivan, and he rebounded well after Sullivan. But he was completely useless during Sullivan.

I just hope the guys who have skating issues will be ready when we have a new coach. Otherwise, they are probably going to be traded. That is just how things go under this coach. It is the sad reality.
 

bambamcam4ever

107 and counting
Feb 16, 2012
15,044
7,129
I see it like drafting a QB or pitcher and trying to change their delivery. They’ve probably doing it that way for most, if not all their lives. Especially during developmental years. It’s going to be very hard to correct. That’s why I think a lot of players that have improved their skating has more to do with getting into a strength and conditioning program in the NHL or in college. They add speed and explosiveness by adding strength.

Just a theory of mine though.


Why would the NHL allow that? Didn’t they break rating records in this years SCF? Neither the NFL nor the NBA regressed when they saw people wanted to see talented offensive players.
They certainly did not break any records on US TV, don't know about Canada.
 

eXile3

Registered User
Dec 12, 2020
4,573
4,404
Obviously, you can make the Hall of Fame despite being a bad skater. Former Penguin Luc Robitaille is the best example, of course. For you old timers out there, Steve Shutt was a great goal-scoring winger who had the choppiest skating stride I think I have ever seen in my life. Did not hurt him.

The issue is the coach. Most, if not all, players whose skating is considered below-average have really struggled under Sullivan. Like, you basically have no shot with this system if your skating is sub-par. I always go back to Tanner Pearson when talking about this. He was a very good player before Sullivan, and he rebounded well after Sullivan. But he was completely useless during Sullivan.

I just hope the guys who have skating issues will be ready when we have a new coach. Otherwise, they are probably going to be traded. That is just how things go under this coach. It is the sad reality.
Brett Hull is always the first one I think of. At worst the 4th best goal scorer of all time. Couldn’t skate but he could find open areas and had an absolute beast of a shot.
 

Ulf5

Registered User
Feb 21, 2017
1,513
1,153
Just a screenshot of Excel:

oWjjgT1.png


Edit: from Lindberg and down, the % obviously needs to be fixed. But if you want to calculate the % yourself go ahead and divide "overall" by 65.
Was looking more for potential and ceiling to see how the projections fared.
 

Jacob

as seen on TV
Feb 27, 2002
50,261
26,934
Pieniniemi slides too. Even still I’d start dumping some of these NHL contracts that will probably be lucky to even make WB/S this year, like Frasca or MacArthur.

Get rid of Nieto too. WB/S has enough forwards and he’s not one of our top 14 skaters.

Bonino wasn’t a great skater but could play a fast game because he was smart. Knew where to put the puck and without it knew where to be.
Bonino’s skating was outright bad.

It also helped that he played with speedy wingers.
 

Al Smith

Registered User
Apr 28, 2012
7,510
4,091
Brett Hull is always the first one I think of. At worst the 4th best goal scorer of all time. Couldn’t skate but he could find open areas and had an absolute beast of a shot.
While you and the previous post are talking about old timers like Steve Shutt (not Rod), who played opposite Guy Lafleur, throw Phil Esposito into the group of people who only had to skate well enough to get to the front of the net, establish position, and be better than everyone else at collecting points there. Pens’ recent PP successes have shown that net front presence even by a subpar skater is unnecessary in this day and age.
 

HandshakeLine

A real jerk thing
Nov 9, 2005
49,162
33,702
Praha, CZ
I see it like drafting a QB or pitcher and trying to change their delivery. They’ve probably doing it that way for most, if not all their lives. Especially during developmental years. It’s going to be very hard to correct. That’s why I think a lot of players that have improved their skating has more to do with getting into a strength and conditioning program in the NHL or in college. They add speed and explosiveness by adding strength.

Just a theory of mine though.


Why would the NHL allow that? Didn’t they break rating records in this years SCF? Neither the NFL nor the NBA regressed when they saw people wanted to see talented offensive players.
Because at some point people figure out that the refs are human and don’t like calling those kinds of things. Or that physical tactics work against speedy teams, especially if they don’t have two elite centers. It’s the natural pendulum of the thing.
Brett Hull is always the first one I think of. At worst the 4th best goal scorer of all time. Couldn’t skate but he could find open areas and had an absolute beast of a shot.
Yeah Hull was bad. But it also illustrates that if a player can mould their game around their strengths and not try to mindlessly copy the conventional wisdom, they can have an impact, especially with a shot like that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eXile3

chethejet

Registered User
Feb 4, 2012
8,730
1,933
Lots of bad skaters especially on defense have been NHL performers. Skating is as asset and the better the skater, the better the speed to get to points on the ice. Sullivan loves players who can get to spots for his system. In the end, Skating is one of many attributes needed for playing in the NHL.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

  • HV 71 @ Lulea Hockey
    HV 71 @ Lulea Hockey
    Wagers: 2
    Staked: $85.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Croatia vs Portugal
    Croatia vs Portugal
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $25.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Luxembourg vs Northern Ireland
    Luxembourg vs Northern Ireland
    Wagers: 2
    Staked: $50,050.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Poland vs Scotland
    Poland vs Scotland
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $25.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Serbia vs Denmark
    Serbia vs Denmark
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $25.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:

Ad

Ad