Proposal: Phi/Buf/Cgy

[Starat327]

This deal doesn't work for Philly at all. We give up our biggest need, and get in return, someone who would be a luxury. Pretty easy pass for the Flyers.

 

[MayDayMayDay]

Awful for Buffalo.

 

[ArchAngel55]

I did not know Gostisbehere was a future hall of Famer, the next Peter Forsberg

You have to look at the value of a puck moving defenseman right now. Hall went for Larsson. Plus Gaudreau is unsigned and wants alot.

 

[DJN21]

I wouldn't do this as a buffalo fan.

 

[LongWayDown37]

In a trade around Ghost and Gaudreau Calgary is the one adding

Noo....

 

[Sabresruletheschool]

Lmao to Buffalo adding to Reinhart for Ghost

 

[Skobel24]

...I'd actually be tempted to do this, but I also really wanted Sam Reinhart at that draft. I like Schenn too.

 

[Gritty]

I guess I'm in the minority that would accept Brayden Schenn and Sam Reinhart quite easily for Gaudreau and Shinkaruk...

We'd have such a deep team with those two pieces! Mind you, I'm a big Sam Reinhart homer.

 

[Skobel24]

I guess I'm in the minority that would accept Brayden Schenn and Sam Reinhart quite easily for Gaudreau and Shinkaruk...

We'd have such a deep team with those two pieces! Mind you, I'm a big Sam Reinhart homer.

Bennett - Monahan - Schenn
Tkachuk - Backlund - Reinhart

 

[flyersfan018]

Philly adds Rubtsov, Myers and a 1st to Calgary's return and it's an interesting deal. Interesting, though still not good.

Lol yea ok. You just took a horrible proposal and made it worse.

 

[Maurice of Orange]

The Flyers biggest need is for offence but not at the expense of giving up Schenn and Gostisbehere for Gaudreau and Shinkaruk.

What's up with all these Gaudreau to philly proposals lately. I can't see Calgary trading away Gaudreau.

Johnny Hockey will most likely re-sign with Calgary to a 7-8 year deal for around 7.5mil a season, Gaudreau isn't going anywhere any time soon.

 

[Roughly6Owls]

What's up with all these Gaudreau to philly proposals lately. I can't see Calgary trading away Gaudreau.

Gaudreau grew up in Flyers territory, and he's unsigned.

So a ton of HFBoards is speculating that he's holding out cause he doesn't want to play in Calgary, he just wants to go home -- because that's the only motivating factor for star players now.

 

[paulmm3]

Yeah as a Buffalo fan I'm not trading Reinhart for Gostisbehere straight up

 

[Beerz]

Yeah no thanks for Buffalo.


Calgary is the big loser here tho

 

[Rufus]

Not a good proposal, but not really sure what I expected. Gaudreau is not going anywhere, Gostisbehere is not getting traded.

 

[OvermanKingGainer]

the point went way over your head. Philly traded a ton of top prospects/players for a player (Lindros) who was touted to be the next Gretzky/Lemieux. the equivalent of that type of player today would be McDavid. you're asking for a similar return for Gaudreau. he is nowhere near that type of player. he is not even close to being a generational talent. what you proposed was outright stupid.

Ghost+Schenn+Myers+1st+Rubtsov... does not get you McDavid. Or even Eichel/Matthews/Ekblad.

It does get you into the conversation for a 23 year old likely Art Ross winner though.

Conversation though. Would depend how a given team values the two prospects.

 

[AtlasRust]

This thread is criminally underrating Brayden Schenn.

 

[Bfreezy40]

This isn't NHL 17 LOL. But yeah i'd love to have Gostisbehere on the Sabres.

 

[BrindamoursNose]

Ghost+Schenn+Myers+1st+Rubtsov... does not get you McDavid. Or even Eichel/Matthews/Ekblad.

Objectively:

You're dead wrong about that. Perennial All-Stars don't get packages that good.

 

[Stuzchuk]

In a trade around Ghost and Gaudreau Calgary is the one adding

say WHAT?!?!?

 

[Djp]

As opposed to Reinhart's multiple great seasons?

Reinhart was drafted at 2 and is 20 to start this year, ghost drafter in the mid afternoon Rd and will be 23 to start the season.

Reinhart is going to be better and have more value than ghost.

 

[BrindamoursNose]

Reinhart was drafted at 2 and is 20 to start this year, ghost drafter in the mid afternoon Rd and will be 23 to start the season.

Reinhart is going to be better and have more value than ghost.

Well, maybe. To be fair, Ghost is the one who just placed second in ROY voting as a first-season defenseman.

I don't disagree though that Reinhart needs to be looked at much more favorably in this thread, though.

 

[SnoopDogg]

Good for Buffalo? This is awful for Buffalo, at this point I wouldn't give Reinhart up for Ekblad, let alone Gotisbehere.

 

[Alexander Edler]

Every team passes I just don't see Buffalo trading Reinhart for a Dman he is a key part of their future

 

[phlocky]

Yeah as a Buffalo fan I'm not trading Reinhart for Gostisbehere straight up

Then you are a fool. Reinhart is a good player but you really should take Ghost over him very day of the week.