What’s he supposed to do specifically?
Well, let’s see. The one thing he does in this entire incident is say something to Brown Jacket Guy. At that moment, all he needed to do was separate BJG from the fight. There’s an entire row of empty seats around the cop — just move BJG to that area, reducing the number of combatants involved.
What does he actually do? He stands there passively while BJG tells him off, then turns around and jumps right back into the fight. And what’s the first thing BJG does? He pulls a guy over a row of seats, sending everyone sprawling.
That’s how you end up with a fellow cop jumping over a melee to try and get it under control — and if the comments above are true, that’s how someone lost a finger. Because you have a cop standing there collecting a public paycheck instead of establishing order at the critical moment.
But hey, it’s just one mistake, right? BJG is responsible for his own actions, so the cop’s main responsibility is to see to it that justice is administered, right?
Well let’s take a look at the second video, which shows the aftermath. What happens to BJG? He gets up and… just kind of stands around while FOUR other people are hauled off in cuffs, including Gronk Jersey Lady who did nothing but get punched trying to break it up. After a full minute of just kind of standing there collecting his bearings and waiting to get arrested, he finally just kind of wanders off on his own accord. At no point is he given any sort of instruction. By all appearances, he was free to go.
One cop in that scenario had the opportunity to stop the brawl before it tumbled over the seats, endangering both the civilians and the responders. One cop had the opportunity to arrest the individual who escalated it to that level.
What did he do instead? He literally just stood there watching every other cop actively intervening, and in at least a couple of cases putting their safety on the line to do so. Literally just standing there in the aisle while active combatants are leaving the scene unidentified.
That’s some bullshit, and a prime example of the worthless cop who can’t be relied upon to do justice to the badge. Hopefully the guy at least gets enough exposure from this to feel some actual shame for being a useless waste of resources at the precise moment when he was very visibly needed.
Well, first he couldn't have stopped the brawl, unless there's another video, as the brawl was in full swing when it (the video) started.
One cop went flying over the pile, while the others/reinforcements just started pulling people from the outskirts.
Brown Jacket Guy certainly isn't a saint, but that brawl was going to continue one way, or another. Cop definitely failed to keep BJG out of it, but it wouldn't have stopped the brawl then and there.
Now what was said, or done we don't know. Someone getting their finger bit off is clearly false, as that would have been posted numerous times in this thread, the article pertaining to that.
Now, it's possible that he could have been useless and stood there, or he was told to observe and take mental notes. Maybe the cops said leave peaceably, or we'll take you out and BJG is the only one who listened. Maybe the cop didn't single him out.
The cop who goes flying over the melee is just as stupid. You going flying over like that is potential to hurt those in the melee and yourself.
Foreground officer could have done a better job with BJG, but you don't jump into a melee like, especially as an officer who's carrying.
If the cop tries to remove BJG, he goes back in, cop goes in after him and holds BJG, he's prone to punches and can't defend himself. That could lead to serious injury, or death. Just like an official shouldn't break a fight up by themselves, a cop shouldn't either unless he/she can get directly between both. This is a multiple people brawl.
Secondly, more extreme, but definitely some severe consequences in thar he gets in the middle and becomes subdued, or someone goes for his gun. Now, not very likely, but it's not impossible.
In short, that guy didn't do the best job, but he did nowhere near as bad as you, Pete Blackburn and others are saying. I get it's the cool thing to do is hate on cops, especially after the Uvalde incident, but this isn't it. And if you're going to try and say he did nothing, then flying cop deserves some hit for his reckless behaviour.