With some time to reflect since the 2023 TDL…aka the day the (failed)rebuild attempt of the early 2020’s Chicago White Sox officially ended…I’ve been able to piece together my final opinion on what exactly it was that happened/went wrong(and when) with this monumental failure of a rebuild for the incredibly incompetent(and perhaps a bit unlucky) ChiSox:
Say what you want about 2020, it was still a solid step forward and a clear sign that the Sox had a bright future and were bound to contend in 2021.
If u REALLY look at the 2021 season, and I’ve thought a lot about this recently, that team should have competed for a World Series but bottom line pure and simple: injuries KILLED them. And I don’t mean the injuries most people associate with that season like the ones to Eloy and Robert who both missed most of the regular season…but the ones late in the season to Rodon, Lynn, and Cease(Rodon broke down over time largely because he was overworked early on and wasn’t properly ramped up throughout the season, Lynn’s knee needed surgery, and Cease suffered a freak arm injury right before the round 1 series and couldn’t recover in time on that big stage). Those 3 come playoff time weren’t close to being the same guys they were all throughout the majority of the season. And then they ran into the Astros of all teams with their once dominant starting pitching now a weakness. It changed everything. If you look back it was 100% what cost them that championship. Cuz after acquiring Kimbrel they had probably the best roster on paper in all MLB, and Vegas had them as favorites. But it was short lived.
Then the following offseason….when it was obvious they were on the doorstep and needed to make a couple big time moves to put themselves over the hump…they inexplicably let Rodon go and didn’t replace him at all(unless u call Vince Velazquez a replacement). And on top of that they SOMEHOW didn’t (legitimately)address the holes in the OF or at 2B. It was a pathetic and embarrassing offseason response to the playoff failure the season before, and anyone with half a brain could see the writing on the wall when AJ Pollock(to the surprise of literally zero human beings) got injured 2 games into the season and landed on the IL…
…then the rest is history. Of course Rodon goes on to have a Cy young worthy season for the Giants, the Sox slowly and methodically fade into mediocrity, miss the playoffs, and finally TLR is put out of his misery as the Sox would eventually move on to some guy named Pedro Grifol in yet another underwhelming addition to the club and another sign that the FO missed the mark entirely.
And just like that it was over. Far before this 2023 season ever started. That’s the harsh truth.
These runs at/towards the top don’t last forever for young and budding teams, or at least not nearly as long as you initially think. Just ask the Cubs who at one point thought 2016 might be just the beginning. And this Sox team never even got CLOSE to sniffing that kind of success.
Unlucky in 2021? Yes. No doubt. With the May/June versions of Rodon/Lynn that Sox team would have had a real shot at getting past HOU, and that arguably might have wound up being their overall toughest opponent. But we’ll never know.
What we do know? That 2022 was 100% on the front office. And it’s a joke that they’re all still here running the show.