Toggle sidebar

OT: OT: Lets Go Cardinals! (All Baseball Talk Here) Part 2

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
TheDizee said:
Wonder who they can get for play by play.
Click to expand...
No clue. But dude needs to get some help.

Maybe John Kelly can transition to MLB. He's already used to working with a washed up former player in Panger, why not also do the same with Edmonds. :sarcasm::sarcasm::sarcasm:
 
Goold's article this morning made it seem like if we trade for a catcher, then we will be more aggressive with a free agent SS, but if we have to sign a catcher, then less active in the SS market. The 4 listed were Murphy, Jansen, Contreras, and Vazquez, with Murphy being the top target.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeywiz542
Linkens Mastery said:
No clue. But dude needs to get some help.

Maybe John Kelly can transition to MLB. He's already used to working with a washed up former player in Panger, why not also do the same with Edmonds. :sarcasm::sarcasm::sarcasm:
Click to expand...
It's a real shitty situation for him and his family. I truly do like the man Danny Mac and hope he does get the help he needs. I glad that for this time, he didn't cause any harm to anyone on the roadways.

In terms of PBP, though, he was not really a favorite of mine. I get Extra Innings package and watch a LOT of baseball throughout the year for fantasy reasons and listening to other team's broadcasts has really shed a light on how mediocre Danny Mac has become as a PBP personality.
 
bleedblue1223 said:
Goold's article this morning made it seem like if we trade for a catcher, then we will be more aggressive with a free agent SS, but if we have to sign a catcher, then less active in the SS market. The 4 listed were Murphy, Jansen, Contreras, and Vazquez, with Murphy being the top target.
Click to expand...
Murphy is far and away the best catcher in that group. Unless it costs Walker we should be all over him.
 
Vladys Gumption said:
Murphy is far and away the best catcher in that group. Unless it costs Walker we should be all over him.
Click to expand...
I kind of wonder if Murphy costs Gorman or Donovan, and that's why we'd be more interested in the SS market.

Murphy comes with 3 years of control too, so that's a big plus.
 
bleedblue1223 said:
I kind of wonder if Murphy costs Gorman or Donovan, and that's why we'd be more interested in the SS market.

Murphy comes with 3 years of control too, so that's a big plus.
Click to expand...
If I’m being honest, I’d move Gorman for Murphy without losing sleep, especially if we can land a shortstop. Donovan and Edman are more than good enough to hold down second base
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spear
Vladys Gumption said:
If I’m being honest, I’d move Gorman for Murphy without losing sleep, especially if we can land a shortstop. Donovan and Edman are more than good enough to hold down second base
Click to expand...
Especially if the plan is to spend big money on Swanson or Bogarets. Move Edman to 2nd, and Donovan is still there to be the utility guy.
 
bleedblue1223 said:
Especially if the plan is to spend big money on Swanson or Bogarets. Move Edman to 2nd, and Donovan is still there to be the utility guy.
Click to expand...
I’d be very happy if that’s how the off-season plays out. Walker really is the only untouchable for me, and I don’t even know if I’d call him untouchable in the right deal.
 
Murphy won't return Walker. Not many top 10 prospects get traded and only for people like Juan Soto. Plus with rumors the Athletics want Major League ready talent I think some combination of Gorman/Liberatore/Burelson/Yepez with someone else like Joshua Baez/McGreevy/Graceffo. Honestly I think the cardinals package is something like Gorman, Liberatore/Graceffo, and Burleson with some random player thrown in.
 
A's want MLB ready players. I really think it's going to be end up being Gorman+Noot+another or similar package.
 
Linkens Mastery said:
A's want MLB ready players. I really think it's going to be end up being Gorman+Noot+another or similar package.
Click to expand...
No thanks then. I don't mind trading Nootbar at all but Gorman is going to be a 30hr bat as soon as a year or two from now.
 
Oli was on MLB Network. Cards had some good meetings with Contreras, but are looking at all routes for an upgrade at the Catcher spot. Murphy and Contreras are looking to be the two main targets.
 
Linkens Mastery said:
Oli was on MLB Network. Cards had some good meetings with Contreras, but are looking at all routes for an upgrade at the Catcher spot. Murphy and Contreras are looking to be the two main targets.
Click to expand...
Think they really want Murphy, so they have budget for free agents, but Athletics are probably playing hardball.
 
bleedblue1223 said:
Cubs got Bellinger, 1 year, 17.5M. I'd pass on that.
Click to expand...
Makes sense for all parties, honestly. Cubs get someone who can put a few butts in seats during another down year and Bellinger gets to play in a stress-free environment for a year where he knows expectations aren't high so he can try and put up the best stats he can and be moved to a contender and then go on the market again with higher value.

PJJJPanesar said:
Murphy won't return Walker. Not many top 10 prospects get traded and only for people like Juan Soto. Plus with rumors the Athletics want Major League ready talent I think some combination of Gorman/Liberatore/Burelson/Yepez with someone else like Joshua Baez/McGreevy/Graceffo. Honestly I think the cardinals package is something like Gorman, Liberatore/Graceffo, and Burleson with some random player thrown in.
Click to expand...
I think that package is wayyy too much for Murphy. Gorman is highly thought of with plenty of control. They don't need another top 100 MLB prospect in Liberatore or Graceffo AND another player who has had great minor league numbers, all of which have as much team control as you can want.

I think it'd likely be Gorman and a couple prospects outside the top 10 Cards system that should get it done.
 
Allens Five Hole said:
Makes sense for all parties, honestly. Cubs get someone who can put a few butts in seats during another down year and Bellinger gets to play in a stress-free environment for a year where he knows expectations aren't high so he can try and put up the best stats he can and be moved to a contender and then go on the market again with higher value.


I think that package is wayyy too much for Murphy. Gorman is highly thought of with plenty of control. They don't need another top 100 MLB prospect in Liberatore or Graceffo AND another player who has had great minor league numbers, all of which have as much team control as you can want.

I think it'd likely be Gorman and a couple prospects outside the top 10 Cards system that should get it done.
Click to expand...
But the thing is we are competing against many other teams for him. It will take an overpay from our end. I mean Cleveland can offer 1 of Valera/Williams/Bibee who will be ranked around the 20-40 range similar to when Gorman was a prospect. Tampa is in the hunt and they can offer similar prospects to Gorman. I also don't have much faith at all in Liberatore. His fastball sucks and is his worst pitch and he had a era of 5 in Triple A and in the Majors. He will have to totally revamp his fastball for him to become a starting pitcher unless he can pitch like Max Fried and reverse pitch his way through a game. It will take at least 2 top 100 prospects for him minimum
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom